Skip to main content
An example added at the end.
Source Link
emiliocba
  • 2.4k
  • 19
  • 26

Remember that $S^3=SO(4)/SO(3)=:G/K$ as a symmetric space. The following actually holds for every compact symmetric space $M=G/K$.

Take the Cartan decomposition $\mathfrak g=\mathfrak k\oplus \mathfrak p$. By using that the vector bundle $\mathcal S_0^2(M)$ of traceless symmetric 2-forms is homogeneous (i.e. $\mathcal S_0^2(M)\simeq G\times_{\tau} Sym^2(\mathcal m^{\mathbb C})$, where $\tau$ denotes the $K$-action on $Sym^2(\mathcal m^{\mathbb C})$), it decomposes as $$ \mathcal S_0^2(M)^{\mathbb C} = \widehat{\bigoplus}_{\pi\in\widehat {G}} V_\pi\otimes Hom_K(V_\pi,Sym_0^2(\mathfrak p)^{\mathbb C}). $$ Of course, this sum is reduced to those $\pi\in\widehat G$ such that $Hom_K(V_\pi,Sym_0^2(\mathfrak p)^{\mathbb C})\neq0$.

Now, since you are interested on $\Gamma\backslash S^3 = \Gamma\backslash G/K$ with $\Gamma$ a discrete subgroup of $G$, one has that $$ \mathcal S_0^2(\Gamma\backslash M)^{\mathbb C} = \widehat{\bigoplus}_{\pi\in\widehat {G}} V_\pi^{\Gamma}\otimes Hom_K(V_\pi,Sym_0^2(\mathfrak p)^{\mathbb C}). $$ In conclusion, the sum is now restricted to those $\pi\in\widehat G$ such that $Hom_K(V_\pi,Sym_0^2(\mathfrak p)^{\mathbb C})\neq0$ and $V_\pi^{\Gamma}\neq 0$.

The Lichnerowicz Laplacian on $\mathcal S_0^2(M)$ (or $\mathcal S_0^2(\Gamma\backslash M)$) acts by the casimir element (here, it is crucial that $G/K$ is symmetric), so each term $V_\pi^{\Gamma}\otimes Hom_K(V_\pi,Sym_0^2(\mathfrak p)^{\mathbb C})$ contributes to the spectrum of the Lichnerowicz Laplacian with the eigenvalue $\lambda_\pi$ such that $Cas\cdot V_\pi = \lambda_\pi Id_{V_\pi}$ (which can be computed with Freudenthal's formula) with multiplicity $\dim V_\pi^{\Gamma}\dim Hom_K(V_\pi,Sym_0^2(\mathfrak p)^{\mathbb C})$.

Let $\lambda_1(M)$ denote the smallest eigenvalue of the Lichnerowicz Laplacian $\Delta_L$ on $M$. (Since $\Delta_L h=\Delta h-6h$ for spherical space forms, where $\Delta$ is the Rough Laplacian, then it is equivalent to work with any of them). One has $$ \lambda_1(G/K) =\min_\pi \lambda_\pi, $$ where $\pi$ runs over $\widehat G$ such that $\dim Hom_K(V_\pi,Sym_0^2(\mathfrak p)^{\mathbb C})>0$, and at least one element in $\mathcal S_0^2(M)$ induced by $V_\pi\otimes Hom_K(V_\pi,Sym_0^2(\mathfrak p)^{\mathbb C})$ is divergence-free (note that I haven't mentioned this condition before).

Concerning your question about whether $\lambda_1(\Gamma\backslash G/K)=\lambda_1(G/K)$ for a given $\Gamma\subset G$, it reduces to check whether $\dim V_\pi^\Gamma>0$ for any $\pi$ attaining the displayed identity above, that is, $\lambda_1(G/K)=\lambda_\pi$.

For the sphere $G/K=S^3$, one has that $\lambda_1(S^3)=12$ (see for instance Example 3.1.2 in Klaus Kröncke's PhD thesis), and it is attainded only by $\pi_{small}:=\pi_{2\varepsilon_1+2\varepsilon_2}$ (the irrep of $SO(4)$ having highest weight $2\varepsilon_1+2\varepsilon_2$). In conclusion, $\lambda_1(\Gamma\backslash S^3)=12$ if and only if $\dim V_{{small}}^{\Gamma}>0$.

It remains to look atNow, the classificationoriginal problem of $3$classifying 3-dimensional sphericalspherical space forms $\Gamma\backslash S^3$ and to check for each of them whethersatisfying $V_{small}^\Gamma\neq0$. If$\lambda_1(\Gamma\backslash S^3)=12$ reduces to the following:

Classify the finite subgroups $\Gamma\subset SO(4)$ acting freely on $S^3$ such that $V_{small}^\Gamma\neq 0$.

For instance, if $\Gamma$ is inside the standard maximal toruscyclic (i.e.hence $\Gamma\backslash S^3$ is a lens space), thenit is conjugate in $O(4)$ to the weight decomposition ofgroup generated by $$ \begin{pmatrix} \cos(2\pi /q) & \sin(2\pi /q)\\ -\sin(2\pi /q) & \cos(2\pi /q) \\ && \cos(2\pi p/q) & \sin(2\pi p/q)\\ && -\sin(2\pi p/q)& \cos(2\pi p/q)\\ \end{pmatrix} ​ $$ for some $V_{small}$ will help$q\in\mathbb N$ and $p\in\mathbb Z$ coprime to $q$. The lens space $\Gamma\backslash S^3$ is usually denoted by $L(q;1,p)$ or just $L(q,p)$. One can check that $V_{small}^\Gamma\neq0$ if and only if $q$ divides $2(1+p)$ or $2(1-p)$. In particular, giving probably a condition on$\lambda_1(L(q;1,1))=12$ for all $q\in\mathbb N$.

The calculation involved for the parameters definingnon-cyclic subgroups of $\Gamma$$SO(4)$ are much more complicated.

Remember that $S^3=SO(4)/SO(3)=:G/K$ as a symmetric space. The following actually holds for every compact symmetric space $M=G/K$.

Take the Cartan decomposition $\mathfrak g=\mathfrak k\oplus \mathfrak p$. By using that the vector bundle $\mathcal S_0^2(M)$ of traceless symmetric 2-forms is homogeneous (i.e. $\mathcal S_0^2(M)\simeq G\times_{\tau} Sym^2(\mathcal m^{\mathbb C})$, where $\tau$ denotes the $K$-action on $Sym^2(\mathcal m^{\mathbb C})$), it decomposes as $$ \mathcal S_0^2(M)^{\mathbb C} = \widehat{\bigoplus}_{\pi\in\widehat {G}} V_\pi\otimes Hom_K(V_\pi,Sym_0^2(\mathfrak p)^{\mathbb C}). $$ Of course, this sum is reduced to those $\pi\in\widehat G$ such that $Hom_K(V_\pi,Sym_0^2(\mathfrak p)^{\mathbb C})\neq0$.

Now, since you are interested on $\Gamma\backslash S^3 = \Gamma\backslash G/K$ with $\Gamma$ a discrete subgroup of $G$, one has that $$ \mathcal S_0^2(\Gamma\backslash M)^{\mathbb C} = \widehat{\bigoplus}_{\pi\in\widehat {G}} V_\pi^{\Gamma}\otimes Hom_K(V_\pi,Sym_0^2(\mathfrak p)^{\mathbb C}). $$ In conclusion, the sum is now restricted to those $\pi\in\widehat G$ such that $Hom_K(V_\pi,Sym_0^2(\mathfrak p)^{\mathbb C})\neq0$ and $V_\pi^{\Gamma}\neq 0$.

The Lichnerowicz Laplacian on $\mathcal S_0^2(M)$ (or $\mathcal S_0^2(\Gamma\backslash M)$) acts by the casimir element (here, it is crucial that $G/K$ is symmetric), so each term $V_\pi^{\Gamma}\otimes Hom_K(V_\pi,Sym_0^2(\mathfrak p)^{\mathbb C})$ contributes to the spectrum of the Lichnerowicz Laplacian with the eigenvalue $\lambda_\pi$ such that $Cas\cdot V_\pi = \lambda_\pi Id_{V_\pi}$ (which can be computed with Freudenthal's formula) with multiplicity $\dim V_\pi^{\Gamma}\dim Hom_K(V_\pi,Sym_0^2(\mathfrak p)^{\mathbb C})$.

Let $\lambda_1(M)$ denote the smallest eigenvalue of the Lichnerowicz Laplacian $\Delta_L$ on $M$. (Since $\Delta_L h=\Delta h-6h$ for spherical space forms, where $\Delta$ is the Rough Laplacian, then it is equivalent to work with any of them). One has $$ \lambda_1(G/K) =\min_\pi \lambda_\pi, $$ where $\pi$ runs over $\widehat G$ such that $\dim Hom_K(V_\pi,Sym_0^2(\mathfrak p)^{\mathbb C})>0$, and at least one element in $\mathcal S_0^2(M)$ induced by $V_\pi\otimes Hom_K(V_\pi,Sym_0^2(\mathfrak p)^{\mathbb C})$ is divergence-free (note that I haven't mentioned this condition before).

Concerning your question about whether $\lambda_1(\Gamma\backslash G/K)=\lambda_1(G/K)$ for a given $\Gamma\subset G$, it reduces to check whether $\dim V_\pi^\Gamma>0$ for any $\pi$ attaining the displayed identity above, that is, $\lambda_1(G/K)=\lambda_\pi$.

For the sphere $G/K=S^3$, one has that $\lambda_1(S^3)=12$ (see for instance Example 3.1.2 in Klaus Kröncke's PhD thesis), and it is attainded only by $\pi_{small}:=\pi_{2\varepsilon_1+2\varepsilon_2}$ (the irrep of $SO(4)$ having highest weight $2\varepsilon_1+2\varepsilon_2$). In conclusion, $\lambda_1(\Gamma\backslash S^3)=12$ if and only if $\dim V_{{small}}^{\Gamma}>0$.

It remains to look at the classification of $3$-dimensional spherical space forms $\Gamma\backslash S^3$ and to check for each of them whether $V_{small}^\Gamma\neq0$. If $\Gamma$ is inside the standard maximal torus (i.e. $\Gamma\backslash S^3$ is a lens space), then the weight decomposition of $V_{small}$ will help, giving probably a condition on the parameters defining $\Gamma$.

Remember that $S^3=SO(4)/SO(3)=:G/K$ as a symmetric space. The following actually holds for every compact symmetric space $M=G/K$.

Take the Cartan decomposition $\mathfrak g=\mathfrak k\oplus \mathfrak p$. By using that the vector bundle $\mathcal S_0^2(M)$ of traceless symmetric 2-forms is homogeneous (i.e. $\mathcal S_0^2(M)\simeq G\times_{\tau} Sym^2(\mathcal m^{\mathbb C})$, where $\tau$ denotes the $K$-action on $Sym^2(\mathcal m^{\mathbb C})$), it decomposes as $$ \mathcal S_0^2(M)^{\mathbb C} = \widehat{\bigoplus}_{\pi\in\widehat {G}} V_\pi\otimes Hom_K(V_\pi,Sym_0^2(\mathfrak p)^{\mathbb C}). $$ Of course, this sum is reduced to those $\pi\in\widehat G$ such that $Hom_K(V_\pi,Sym_0^2(\mathfrak p)^{\mathbb C})\neq0$.

Now, since you are interested on $\Gamma\backslash S^3 = \Gamma\backslash G/K$ with $\Gamma$ a discrete subgroup of $G$, one has that $$ \mathcal S_0^2(\Gamma\backslash M)^{\mathbb C} = \widehat{\bigoplus}_{\pi\in\widehat {G}} V_\pi^{\Gamma}\otimes Hom_K(V_\pi,Sym_0^2(\mathfrak p)^{\mathbb C}). $$ In conclusion, the sum is now restricted to those $\pi\in\widehat G$ such that $Hom_K(V_\pi,Sym_0^2(\mathfrak p)^{\mathbb C})\neq0$ and $V_\pi^{\Gamma}\neq 0$.

The Lichnerowicz Laplacian on $\mathcal S_0^2(M)$ (or $\mathcal S_0^2(\Gamma\backslash M)$) acts by the casimir element (here, it is crucial that $G/K$ is symmetric), so each term $V_\pi^{\Gamma}\otimes Hom_K(V_\pi,Sym_0^2(\mathfrak p)^{\mathbb C})$ contributes to the spectrum of the Lichnerowicz Laplacian with the eigenvalue $\lambda_\pi$ such that $Cas\cdot V_\pi = \lambda_\pi Id_{V_\pi}$ (which can be computed with Freudenthal's formula) with multiplicity $\dim V_\pi^{\Gamma}\dim Hom_K(V_\pi,Sym_0^2(\mathfrak p)^{\mathbb C})$.

Let $\lambda_1(M)$ denote the smallest eigenvalue of the Lichnerowicz Laplacian $\Delta_L$ on $M$. (Since $\Delta_L h=\Delta h-6h$ for spherical space forms, where $\Delta$ is the Rough Laplacian, then it is equivalent to work with any of them). One has $$ \lambda_1(G/K) =\min_\pi \lambda_\pi, $$ where $\pi$ runs over $\widehat G$ such that $\dim Hom_K(V_\pi,Sym_0^2(\mathfrak p)^{\mathbb C})>0$, and at least one element in $\mathcal S_0^2(M)$ induced by $V_\pi\otimes Hom_K(V_\pi,Sym_0^2(\mathfrak p)^{\mathbb C})$ is divergence-free (note that I haven't mentioned this condition before).

Concerning your question about whether $\lambda_1(\Gamma\backslash G/K)=\lambda_1(G/K)$ for a given $\Gamma\subset G$, it reduces to check whether $\dim V_\pi^\Gamma>0$ for any $\pi$ attaining the displayed identity above, that is, $\lambda_1(G/K)=\lambda_\pi$.

For the sphere $G/K=S^3$, one has that $\lambda_1(S^3)=12$ (see for instance Example 3.1.2 in Klaus Kröncke's PhD thesis), and it is attainded only by $\pi_{small}:=\pi_{2\varepsilon_1+2\varepsilon_2}$ (the irrep of $SO(4)$ having highest weight $2\varepsilon_1+2\varepsilon_2$). In conclusion, $\lambda_1(\Gamma\backslash S^3)=12$ if and only if $\dim V_{{small}}^{\Gamma}>0$.

Now, the original problem of classifying 3-spherical space forms $\Gamma\backslash S^3$ satisfying $\lambda_1(\Gamma\backslash S^3)=12$ reduces to the following:

Classify the finite subgroups $\Gamma\subset SO(4)$ acting freely on $S^3$ such that $V_{small}^\Gamma\neq 0$.

For instance, if $\Gamma$ is cyclic (hence $\Gamma\backslash S^3$ is a lens space), it is conjugate in $O(4)$ to the group generated by $$ \begin{pmatrix} \cos(2\pi /q) & \sin(2\pi /q)\\ -\sin(2\pi /q) & \cos(2\pi /q) \\ && \cos(2\pi p/q) & \sin(2\pi p/q)\\ && -\sin(2\pi p/q)& \cos(2\pi p/q)\\ \end{pmatrix} ​ $$ for some $q\in\mathbb N$ and $p\in\mathbb Z$ coprime to $q$. The lens space $\Gamma\backslash S^3$ is usually denoted by $L(q;1,p)$ or just $L(q,p)$. One can check that $V_{small}^\Gamma\neq0$ if and only if $q$ divides $2(1+p)$ or $2(1-p)$. In particular, $\lambda_1(L(q;1,1))=12$ for all $q\in\mathbb N$.

The calculation involved for the non-cyclic subgroups of $SO(4)$ are much more complicated.

Added a coment about the relation of the Rough Laplacian and the Lichnerowicz Laplacian
Source Link
emiliocba
  • 2.4k
  • 19
  • 26

Remember that $S^3=SO(4)/SO(3)=:G/K$ as a symmetric space. The following actually holds for every compact symmetric space $M=G/K$.

Take the Cartan decomposition $\mathfrak g=\mathfrak k\oplus \mathfrak p$. By using that the vector bundle $\mathcal S_0^2(M)$ of traceless symmetric 2-forms is homogeneous (i.e. $\mathcal S_0^2(M)\simeq G\times_{\tau} Sym^2(\mathcal m^{\mathbb C})$, where $\tau$ denotes the $K$-action on $Sym^2(\mathcal m^{\mathbb C})$), it decomposes as $$ \mathcal S_0^2(M)^{\mathbb C} = \widehat{\bigoplus}_{\pi\in\widehat {G}} V_\pi\otimes Hom_K(V_\pi,Sym_0^2(\mathfrak p)^{\mathbb C}). $$ Of course, this sum is reduced to those $\pi\in\widehat G$ such that $Hom_K(V_\pi,Sym_0^2(\mathfrak p)^{\mathbb C})\neq0$.

Now, since you are interested on $\Gamma\backslash S^3 = \Gamma\backslash G/K$ with $\Gamma$ a discrete subgroup of $G$, I guessone has that $$ \mathcal S_0^2(\Gamma\backslash M)^{\mathbb C} = \widehat{\bigoplus}_{\pi\in\widehat {G}} V_\pi^{\Gamma}\otimes Hom_K(V_\pi,Sym_0^2(\mathfrak p)^{\mathbb C}). $$ In conclusion, the sum is now restricted to those $\pi\in\widehat G$ such that $Hom_K(V_\pi,Sym_0^2(\mathfrak p)^{\mathbb C})\neq0$ and $V_\pi^{\Gamma}\neq 0$.

The Lichnerowicz Laplacian on $\mathcal S_0^2(M)$ (or $\mathcal S_0^2(\Gamma\backslash M)$) acts by the casimir element (here, it is crucial that $G/K$ is symmetric), so each term $V_\pi^{\Gamma}\otimes Hom_K(V_\pi,Sym_0^2(\mathfrak p)^{\mathbb C})$ contributes to the spectrum of the Lichnerowicz Laplacian with the eigenvalue $\lambda_\pi$ such that $Cas\cdot V_\pi = \lambda_\pi Id_{V_\pi}$ (which can be computed with Freudenthal's formula) with multiplicity $\dim V_\pi^{\Gamma}\dim Hom_K(V_\pi,Sym_0^2(\mathfrak p)^{\mathbb C})$.

Let $\lambda_1(M)$ denote the smallest eigenvalue of the Lichnerowicz Laplacian $\Delta_L$ on $M$. (Since $\Delta_L h=\Delta h-6h$ for spherical space forms, where $\Delta$ is the Rough Laplacian, then it is equivalent to work with any of them). One has $$ \lambda_1(G/K) =\min_\pi \lambda_\pi, $$ where $\pi$ runs over $\widehat G$ such that $\dim Hom_K(V_\pi,Sym_0^2(\mathfrak p)^{\mathbb C})>0$, and at least one element in $\mathcal S_0^2(M)$ induced by $V_\pi\otimes Hom_K(V_\pi,Sym_0^2(\mathfrak p)^{\mathbb C})$ is divergence-free (note that I haven't mentioned this condition before).

Concerning your question about whether $\lambda_1(\Gamma\backslash G/K)=\lambda_1(G/K)$ for a given $\Gamma\subset G$, it reduces to check whether $\dim V_\pi^\Gamma>0$ for any $\pi$ attaining the displayed identity above, that is, $\lambda_1(G/K)=\lambda_\pi$.

For the sphere $G/K=S^3$, I thinkone has that $\lambda_1(S^3)=12$ (see for instance Example 3.1.2 in Klaus Kröncke's PhD thesis), and it is attainded only by $\pi_{small}:=\pi_{2\varepsilon_1+2\varepsilon}$$\pi_{small}:=\pi_{2\varepsilon_1+2\varepsilon_2}$ (the irrep of $SO(4)$ having highest weight $2\varepsilon_1+2\varepsilon$$2\varepsilon_1+2\varepsilon_2$). In conclusion, $\lambda_1(\Gamma\backslash S^3)=12$ if and only if $\dim V_{{small}}^{\Gamma}>0$.

It remains to look at the classification of $3$-dimensional spherical space forms $\Gamma\backslash S^3$ and to check for each of them whether $V_{small}^\Gamma\neq0$. If $\Gamma$ is inside the standard maximal torus (i.e. $\Gamma\backslash S^3$ is a lens space), then the weight decomposition of $V_{small}$ will help, giving probably a condition on the parameters defining $\Gamma$.

Remember that $S^3=SO(4)/SO(3)=:G/K$ as a symmetric space. The following actually holds for every compact symmetric space $M=G/K$.

Take the Cartan decomposition $\mathfrak g=\mathfrak k\oplus \mathfrak p$. By using that the vector bundle $\mathcal S_0^2(M)$ of traceless symmetric 2-forms is homogeneous (i.e. $\mathcal S_0^2(M)\simeq G\times_{\tau} Sym^2(\mathcal m^{\mathbb C})$, where $\tau$ denotes the $K$-action on $Sym^2(\mathcal m^{\mathbb C})$), it decomposes as $$ \mathcal S_0^2(M)^{\mathbb C} = \widehat{\bigoplus}_{\pi\in\widehat {G}} V_\pi\otimes Hom_K(V_\pi,Sym_0^2(\mathfrak p)^{\mathbb C}). $$ Of course, this sum is reduced to those $\pi\in\widehat G$ such that $Hom_K(V_\pi,Sym_0^2(\mathfrak p)^{\mathbb C})\neq0$.

Now, since you are interested on $\Gamma\backslash S^3 = \Gamma\backslash G/K$ with $\Gamma$ a discrete subgroup of $G$, I guess that $$ \mathcal S_0^2(\Gamma\backslash M)^{\mathbb C} = \widehat{\bigoplus}_{\pi\in\widehat {G}} V_\pi^{\Gamma}\otimes Hom_K(V_\pi,Sym_0^2(\mathfrak p)^{\mathbb C}). $$ In conclusion, the sum is now restricted to those $\pi\in\widehat G$ such that $Hom_K(V_\pi,Sym_0^2(\mathfrak p)^{\mathbb C})\neq0$ and $V_\pi^{\Gamma}\neq 0$.

The Lichnerowicz Laplacian on $\mathcal S_0^2(M)$ (or $\mathcal S_0^2(\Gamma\backslash M)$) acts by the casimir element (here, it is crucial that $G/K$ is symmetric), so each term $V_\pi^{\Gamma}\otimes Hom_K(V_\pi,Sym_0^2(\mathfrak p)^{\mathbb C})$ contributes to the spectrum of the Lichnerowicz Laplacian with the eigenvalue $\lambda_\pi$ such that $Cas\cdot V_\pi = \lambda_\pi Id_{V_\pi}$ (which can be computed with Freudenthal's formula) with multiplicity $\dim V_\pi^{\Gamma}\dim Hom_K(V_\pi,Sym_0^2(\mathfrak p)^{\mathbb C})$.

Let $\lambda_1(M)$ denote the smallest eigenvalue of the Lichnerowicz Laplacian on $M$. One has $$ \lambda_1(G/K) =\min_\pi \lambda_\pi, $$ where $\pi$ runs over $\widehat G$ such that $\dim Hom_K(V_\pi,Sym_0^2(\mathfrak p)^{\mathbb C})>0$, and at least one element in $\mathcal S_0^2(M)$ induced by $V_\pi\otimes Hom_K(V_\pi,Sym_0^2(\mathfrak p)^{\mathbb C})$ is divergence-free (note that I haven't mentioned this condition before).

Concerning your question about whether $\lambda_1(\Gamma\backslash G/K)=\lambda_1(G/K)$ for a given $\Gamma\subset G$, it reduces to check whether $\dim V_\pi^\Gamma>0$ for any $\pi$ attaining the displayed identity above, that is, $\lambda_1(G/K)=\lambda_\pi$.

For the sphere $G/K=S^3$, I think that $\lambda_1(S^3)=12$ (see for instance Example 3.1.2 in Klaus Kröncke's PhD thesis), and it is attainded only by $\pi_{small}:=\pi_{2\varepsilon_1+2\varepsilon}$ (the irrep of $SO(4)$ having highest weight $2\varepsilon_1+2\varepsilon$). In conclusion, $\lambda_1(\Gamma\backslash S^3)=12$ if and only if $\dim V_{{small}}^{\Gamma}>0$.

It remains to look at the classification of $3$-dimensional spherical space forms $\Gamma\backslash S^3$ and to check for each of them whether $V_{small}^\Gamma\neq0$. If $\Gamma$ is inside the standard maximal torus (i.e. $\Gamma\backslash S^3$ is a lens space), then the weight decomposition of $V_{small}$ will help, giving probably a condition on the parameters defining $\Gamma$.

Remember that $S^3=SO(4)/SO(3)=:G/K$ as a symmetric space. The following actually holds for every compact symmetric space $M=G/K$.

Take the Cartan decomposition $\mathfrak g=\mathfrak k\oplus \mathfrak p$. By using that the vector bundle $\mathcal S_0^2(M)$ of traceless symmetric 2-forms is homogeneous (i.e. $\mathcal S_0^2(M)\simeq G\times_{\tau} Sym^2(\mathcal m^{\mathbb C})$, where $\tau$ denotes the $K$-action on $Sym^2(\mathcal m^{\mathbb C})$), it decomposes as $$ \mathcal S_0^2(M)^{\mathbb C} = \widehat{\bigoplus}_{\pi\in\widehat {G}} V_\pi\otimes Hom_K(V_\pi,Sym_0^2(\mathfrak p)^{\mathbb C}). $$ Of course, this sum is reduced to those $\pi\in\widehat G$ such that $Hom_K(V_\pi,Sym_0^2(\mathfrak p)^{\mathbb C})\neq0$.

Now, since you are interested on $\Gamma\backslash S^3 = \Gamma\backslash G/K$ with $\Gamma$ a discrete subgroup of $G$, one has that $$ \mathcal S_0^2(\Gamma\backslash M)^{\mathbb C} = \widehat{\bigoplus}_{\pi\in\widehat {G}} V_\pi^{\Gamma}\otimes Hom_K(V_\pi,Sym_0^2(\mathfrak p)^{\mathbb C}). $$ In conclusion, the sum is now restricted to those $\pi\in\widehat G$ such that $Hom_K(V_\pi,Sym_0^2(\mathfrak p)^{\mathbb C})\neq0$ and $V_\pi^{\Gamma}\neq 0$.

The Lichnerowicz Laplacian on $\mathcal S_0^2(M)$ (or $\mathcal S_0^2(\Gamma\backslash M)$) acts by the casimir element (here, it is crucial that $G/K$ is symmetric), so each term $V_\pi^{\Gamma}\otimes Hom_K(V_\pi,Sym_0^2(\mathfrak p)^{\mathbb C})$ contributes to the spectrum of the Lichnerowicz Laplacian with the eigenvalue $\lambda_\pi$ such that $Cas\cdot V_\pi = \lambda_\pi Id_{V_\pi}$ (which can be computed with Freudenthal's formula) with multiplicity $\dim V_\pi^{\Gamma}\dim Hom_K(V_\pi,Sym_0^2(\mathfrak p)^{\mathbb C})$.

Let $\lambda_1(M)$ denote the smallest eigenvalue of the Lichnerowicz Laplacian $\Delta_L$ on $M$. (Since $\Delta_L h=\Delta h-6h$ for spherical space forms, where $\Delta$ is the Rough Laplacian, then it is equivalent to work with any of them). One has $$ \lambda_1(G/K) =\min_\pi \lambda_\pi, $$ where $\pi$ runs over $\widehat G$ such that $\dim Hom_K(V_\pi,Sym_0^2(\mathfrak p)^{\mathbb C})>0$, and at least one element in $\mathcal S_0^2(M)$ induced by $V_\pi\otimes Hom_K(V_\pi,Sym_0^2(\mathfrak p)^{\mathbb C})$ is divergence-free (note that I haven't mentioned this condition before).

Concerning your question about whether $\lambda_1(\Gamma\backslash G/K)=\lambda_1(G/K)$ for a given $\Gamma\subset G$, it reduces to check whether $\dim V_\pi^\Gamma>0$ for any $\pi$ attaining the displayed identity above, that is, $\lambda_1(G/K)=\lambda_\pi$.

For the sphere $G/K=S^3$, one has that $\lambda_1(S^3)=12$ (see for instance Example 3.1.2 in Klaus Kröncke's PhD thesis), and it is attainded only by $\pi_{small}:=\pi_{2\varepsilon_1+2\varepsilon_2}$ (the irrep of $SO(4)$ having highest weight $2\varepsilon_1+2\varepsilon_2$). In conclusion, $\lambda_1(\Gamma\backslash S^3)=12$ if and only if $\dim V_{{small}}^{\Gamma}>0$.

It remains to look at the classification of $3$-dimensional spherical space forms $\Gamma\backslash S^3$ and to check for each of them whether $V_{small}^\Gamma\neq0$. If $\Gamma$ is inside the standard maximal torus (i.e. $\Gamma\backslash S^3$ is a lens space), then the weight decomposition of $V_{small}$ will help, giving probably a condition on the parameters defining $\Gamma$.

A mistake fixed in the last paragraph. A new paragraph at the end adding information.
Source Link
emiliocba
  • 2.4k
  • 19
  • 26

Remember that $S^3=SO(4)/SO(3)=:G/K$ as a symmetric space. The following actually holds for every compact symmetric space $M=G/K$.

Take the Cartan decomposition $\mathfrak g=\mathfrak k\oplus \mathfrak p$. By using that the vector bundle $\mathcal S_0^2(M)$ of traceless symmetric 2-forms is homogeneous (i.e. $\mathcal S_0^2(M)\simeq G\times_{\tau} Sym^2(\mathcal m^{\mathbb C})$, where $\tau$ denotes the $K$-action on $Sym^2(\mathcal m^{\mathbb C})$), it decomposes as $$ \mathcal S_0^2(M)^{\mathbb C} = \widehat{\bigoplus}_{\pi\in\widehat {G}} V_\pi\otimes Hom_K(V_\pi,Sym_0^2(\mathfrak p)^{\mathbb C}). $$ Of course, this sum is reduced to those $\pi\in\widehat G$ such that $Hom_K(V_\pi,Sym_0^2(\mathfrak p)^{\mathbb C})\neq0$.

Now, since you are interested on $\Gamma\backslash S^3 = \Gamma\backslash G/K$ with $\Gamma$ a discrete subgroup of $G$, I guess that $$ \mathcal S_0^2(\Gamma\backslash M)^{\mathbb C} = \widehat{\bigoplus}_{\pi\in\widehat {G}} V_\pi^{\Gamma}\otimes Hom_K(V_\pi,Sym_0^2(\mathfrak p)^{\mathbb C}). $$ In conclusion, the sum is now restricted to those $\pi\in\widehat G$ such that $Hom_K(V_\pi,Sym_0^2(\mathfrak p)^{\mathbb C})\neq0$ and $V_\pi^{\Gamma}\neq 0$.

The Lichnerowicz Laplacian on $\mathcal S_0^2(M)$ (or $\mathcal S_0^2(\Gamma\backslash M)$) acts by the casimir element (here, it is crucial that $G/K$ is symmetric), so each term $V_\pi^{\Gamma}\otimes Hom_K(V_\pi,Sym_0^2(\mathfrak p)^{\mathbb C})$ contributes to the spectrum of the Lichnerowicz Laplacian with the eigenvalue $\lambda_\pi$ such that $Cas\cdot V_\pi = \lambda_\pi Id_{V_\pi}$ (which can be computed with Freudenthal's formula) with multiplicity $\dim V_\pi^{\Gamma}\dim Hom_K(V_\pi,Sym_0^2(\mathfrak p)^{\mathbb C})$.

OneLet $\lambda_1(M)$ denote the smallest eigenvalue of the Lichnerowicz Laplacian on $M$. One has $$ \lambda_1(G/K) =\min_\pi \lambda_\pi, $$ where $\pi$ runs over $\widehat G$ such that $\dim Hom_K(V_\pi,Sym_0^2(\mathfrak p)^{\mathbb C})>0$, and at least one element in $\mathcal S_0^2(M)$ induced by $V_\pi\otimes Hom_K(V_\pi,Sym_0^2(\mathfrak p)^{\mathbb C})$ is divergence-free (note that I haven't mentioned this condition before).

Concerning your question about whether $\lambda_1(\Gamma\backslash G/K)=\lambda_1(G/K)$ for a given $\Gamma\subset G$, it reduces to check whether $\dim V_\pi^\Gamma>0$ for any $\pi$ attaining the displayed identity above, that is, $\lambda_1(G/K)=\lambda_\pi$.

For the sphere $G/K=S^3$, I think that $\lambda_1(S^3)=12$ (rather than 6 as you claimed, seesee for instance Example 3.1.2 in Klaus Kröncke's PhD thesis), and it is attainded only by $\pi_{2\varepsilon_1}$$\pi_{small}:=\pi_{2\varepsilon_1+2\varepsilon}$ (the irrep of $SO(4)$ having highest weight $2\varepsilon_1$$2\varepsilon_1+2\varepsilon$), which is equivalent to $Sym_0^2(\mathbb C^4)$. In conclusion, $\lambda_1(\Gamma\backslash S^3)=12$ if and only if $\dim V_\pi^{\Gamma}=\dim Sym_0^2(\mathbb C^4)^{\Gamma}>0$$\dim V_{{small}}^{\Gamma}>0$.

It remains to look at the classification of $3$-dimensional spherical space forms $\Gamma\backslash S^3$ and to check for each of them whether $V_{small}^\Gamma\neq0$. If $\Gamma$ is inside the standard maximal torus (i.e. $\Gamma\backslash S^3$ is a lens space), then the weight decomposition of $V_{small}$ will help, giving probably a condition on the parameters defining $\Gamma$.

Remember that $S^3=SO(4)/SO(3)=:G/K$ as a symmetric space. The following actually holds for every compact symmetric space $M=G/K$.

Take the Cartan decomposition $\mathfrak g=\mathfrak k\oplus \mathfrak p$. By using that the vector bundle $\mathcal S_0^2(M)$ of traceless symmetric 2-forms is homogeneous (i.e. $\mathcal S_0^2(M)\simeq G\times_{\tau} Sym^2(\mathcal m^{\mathbb C})$, where $\tau$ denotes the $K$-action on $Sym^2(\mathcal m^{\mathbb C})$), it decomposes as $$ \mathcal S_0^2(M)^{\mathbb C} = \widehat{\bigoplus}_{\pi\in\widehat {G}} V_\pi\otimes Hom_K(V_\pi,Sym_0^2(\mathfrak p)^{\mathbb C}). $$ Of course, this sum is reduced to those $\pi\in\widehat G$ such that $Hom_K(V_\pi,Sym_0^2(\mathfrak p)^{\mathbb C})\neq0$.

Now, since you are interested on $\Gamma\backslash S^3 = \Gamma\backslash G/K$ with $\Gamma$ a discrete subgroup of $G$, I guess that $$ \mathcal S_0^2(\Gamma\backslash M)^{\mathbb C} = \widehat{\bigoplus}_{\pi\in\widehat {G}} V_\pi^{\Gamma}\otimes Hom_K(V_\pi,Sym_0^2(\mathfrak p)^{\mathbb C}). $$ In conclusion, the sum is now restricted to those $\pi\in\widehat G$ such that $Hom_K(V_\pi,Sym_0^2(\mathfrak p)^{\mathbb C})\neq0$ and $V_\pi^{\Gamma}\neq 0$.

The Lichnerowicz Laplacian on $\mathcal S_0^2(M)$ (or $\mathcal S_0^2(\Gamma\backslash M)$) acts by the casimir element (here, it is crucial that $G/K$ is symmetric), so each term $V_\pi^{\Gamma}\otimes Hom_K(V_\pi,Sym_0^2(\mathfrak p)^{\mathbb C})$ contributes to the spectrum of the Lichnerowicz Laplacian with the eigenvalue $\lambda_\pi$ such that $Cas\cdot V_\pi = \lambda_\pi Id_{V_\pi}$ (which can be computed with Freudenthal's formula) with multiplicity $\dim V_\pi^{\Gamma}\dim Hom_K(V_\pi,Sym_0^2(\mathfrak p)^{\mathbb C})$.

One has $$ \lambda_1(G/K) =\min_\pi \lambda_\pi, $$ where $\pi$ runs over $\widehat G$ such that $\dim Hom_K(V_\pi,Sym_0^2(\mathfrak p)^{\mathbb C})>0$, and at least one element in $\mathcal S_0^2(M)$ induced by $V_\pi\otimes Hom_K(V_\pi,Sym_0^2(\mathfrak p)^{\mathbb C})$ is divergence-free (note that I haven't mentioned this condition before).

Concerning your question about whether $\lambda_1(\Gamma\backslash G/K)=\lambda_1(G/K)$ for a given $\Gamma\subset G$, it reduces to check whether $\dim V_\pi^\Gamma>0$ for any $\pi$ attaining the displayed identity above, that is, $\lambda_1(G/K)=\lambda_\pi$.

For the sphere $G/K=S^3$, I think that $\lambda_1(S^3)=12$ (rather than 6 as you claimed, see for instance Example 3.1.2 in Klaus Kröncke's PhD thesis), and it is attainded only by $\pi_{2\varepsilon_1}$ (the irrep of $SO(4)$ having highest weight $2\varepsilon_1$), which is equivalent to $Sym_0^2(\mathbb C^4)$. In conclusion, $\lambda_1(\Gamma\backslash S^3)=12$ if and only if $\dim V_\pi^{\Gamma}=\dim Sym_0^2(\mathbb C^4)^{\Gamma}>0$.

Remember that $S^3=SO(4)/SO(3)=:G/K$ as a symmetric space. The following actually holds for every compact symmetric space $M=G/K$.

Take the Cartan decomposition $\mathfrak g=\mathfrak k\oplus \mathfrak p$. By using that the vector bundle $\mathcal S_0^2(M)$ of traceless symmetric 2-forms is homogeneous (i.e. $\mathcal S_0^2(M)\simeq G\times_{\tau} Sym^2(\mathcal m^{\mathbb C})$, where $\tau$ denotes the $K$-action on $Sym^2(\mathcal m^{\mathbb C})$), it decomposes as $$ \mathcal S_0^2(M)^{\mathbb C} = \widehat{\bigoplus}_{\pi\in\widehat {G}} V_\pi\otimes Hom_K(V_\pi,Sym_0^2(\mathfrak p)^{\mathbb C}). $$ Of course, this sum is reduced to those $\pi\in\widehat G$ such that $Hom_K(V_\pi,Sym_0^2(\mathfrak p)^{\mathbb C})\neq0$.

Now, since you are interested on $\Gamma\backslash S^3 = \Gamma\backslash G/K$ with $\Gamma$ a discrete subgroup of $G$, I guess that $$ \mathcal S_0^2(\Gamma\backslash M)^{\mathbb C} = \widehat{\bigoplus}_{\pi\in\widehat {G}} V_\pi^{\Gamma}\otimes Hom_K(V_\pi,Sym_0^2(\mathfrak p)^{\mathbb C}). $$ In conclusion, the sum is now restricted to those $\pi\in\widehat G$ such that $Hom_K(V_\pi,Sym_0^2(\mathfrak p)^{\mathbb C})\neq0$ and $V_\pi^{\Gamma}\neq 0$.

The Lichnerowicz Laplacian on $\mathcal S_0^2(M)$ (or $\mathcal S_0^2(\Gamma\backslash M)$) acts by the casimir element (here, it is crucial that $G/K$ is symmetric), so each term $V_\pi^{\Gamma}\otimes Hom_K(V_\pi,Sym_0^2(\mathfrak p)^{\mathbb C})$ contributes to the spectrum of the Lichnerowicz Laplacian with the eigenvalue $\lambda_\pi$ such that $Cas\cdot V_\pi = \lambda_\pi Id_{V_\pi}$ (which can be computed with Freudenthal's formula) with multiplicity $\dim V_\pi^{\Gamma}\dim Hom_K(V_\pi,Sym_0^2(\mathfrak p)^{\mathbb C})$.

Let $\lambda_1(M)$ denote the smallest eigenvalue of the Lichnerowicz Laplacian on $M$. One has $$ \lambda_1(G/K) =\min_\pi \lambda_\pi, $$ where $\pi$ runs over $\widehat G$ such that $\dim Hom_K(V_\pi,Sym_0^2(\mathfrak p)^{\mathbb C})>0$, and at least one element in $\mathcal S_0^2(M)$ induced by $V_\pi\otimes Hom_K(V_\pi,Sym_0^2(\mathfrak p)^{\mathbb C})$ is divergence-free (note that I haven't mentioned this condition before).

Concerning your question about whether $\lambda_1(\Gamma\backslash G/K)=\lambda_1(G/K)$ for a given $\Gamma\subset G$, it reduces to check whether $\dim V_\pi^\Gamma>0$ for any $\pi$ attaining the displayed identity above, that is, $\lambda_1(G/K)=\lambda_\pi$.

For the sphere $G/K=S^3$, I think that $\lambda_1(S^3)=12$ (see for instance Example 3.1.2 in Klaus Kröncke's PhD thesis), and it is attainded only by $\pi_{small}:=\pi_{2\varepsilon_1+2\varepsilon}$ (the irrep of $SO(4)$ having highest weight $2\varepsilon_1+2\varepsilon$). In conclusion, $\lambda_1(\Gamma\backslash S^3)=12$ if and only if $\dim V_{{small}}^{\Gamma}>0$.

It remains to look at the classification of $3$-dimensional spherical space forms $\Gamma\backslash S^3$ and to check for each of them whether $V_{small}^\Gamma\neq0$. If $\Gamma$ is inside the standard maximal torus (i.e. $\Gamma\backslash S^3$ is a lens space), then the weight decomposition of $V_{small}$ will help, giving probably a condition on the parameters defining $\Gamma$.

A references to Klaus Kröncke's thesis was added
Source Link
emiliocba
  • 2.4k
  • 19
  • 26
Loading
Several modifications in the last three paragraphs
Source Link
emiliocba
  • 2.4k
  • 19
  • 26
Loading
Source Link
emiliocba
  • 2.4k
  • 19
  • 26
Loading