Skip to main content
added 411 characters in body
Source Link
Matt E
  • 316
  • 2
  • 4

As explained below, there is a correspondence between non-zero locally principal ideals $I$ in the order of disc. $D$ and quadratic forms $Q$ of disc. $D$. The form $Q$ is naturally defined on $I$ via $x \in I \mapsto N(x)/N(I).$ So $Q(x) = n$ iff $N(x) = n N(I)$ if $N(x I^{-1}) = n,$ so representations of $n$ by $Q$ correspond to ideals in the class of $I^{-1}$ having norm $n$.

If we sum over all ideal classes, or equivalently over all $Q$, (and divide by the number of automorphisms of $Q$, which is the group of units in the order, to count ideals rather than elements that generate them) we will get the number of ideals of norm $n$.

============

The discovery of this correspondence must go back to the 19th century, maybe to Dirichlet or Dedekind? And Will Jagy's answer gives a very concrete description of it.

One can also give a more conceptual description of it. Indeed, it is fairly easy, and classical, to describe the quadratic form attached to an ideal class in conceptual terms; I explain this at the end of my answer. There is also a conceptual approach to going from quadratic forms to ideal classes, but as far as I know it is more recent, and due to Melanie Wood (a version of it is mentioned in this answer).

Namely, if $Q(x,y)$ is a quadratic form over $\mathbb Z$ which is primitive, then one can consider $\mathrm{Proj} \mathbb Z[x,y]/Q(x,y)$, which turns out to be finite flat of degree $2$ over $\mathbb Z$, therefore affine, of the form $\mathrm{Spec} A$ for some quadratic order $A$. And in fact $A$ is isomorphic to $R[(D +\sqrt{D})/2]$, where $D$ is the discriminant of $Q$ (so $A$ is the quadratic order of discriminant $D$). (There is no canonical identification of $A$ with this order though; we can compose with the automorphism $\sqrt{D} \mapsto -\sqrt{D}$ to get another isomorphism.)

Now $\mathrm{Proj}$ comes with a canonical line bundle $\mathcal O(1)$, and so this is an element of $\mathrm{Pic} A$, which can be thought of as the class group of non-zero locally principal ideals in $A$. (The usual class group when $D$ is a fundamental discriminant.)

Using the isomorphism $A \cong R[(D +\sqrt{D})/2],$ we get an element of the class group of $R[(D +\sqrt{D})/2],$ or really a pair $I,I^{-1}$ of elements, because applying the automorphism $\sqrt{D} \mapsto -\sqrt{D}$ switches $I$ and it's inverse.

This gives a map
$$\text{ primitive quadratic forms } Q \text{ of discriminant } D \longrightarrow \text{ pairs } I, I^{-1} \text{ in the class group of } R[(D +\sqrt{D})/2].$$

To see it is a bijection, one can give an explicit inverse (as I mentioned above, this is more classical):

If $I$ is a locally principal ideal in $R[(D +\sqrt{D})/2],$ then the formula $$x \in I \mapsto N(x)/ N(I) \in \mathbb{Z}$$ defines a quadratic form $Q$ on the free rank two $\mathbb{Z}$-module $I$. (Note that $I^{-1}$ will give the same quadratic form, since formation of norms is invariant under conjugation.)

The discovery of this correspondence must go back to the 19th century, maybe to Dirichlet or Dedekind? And Will Jagy's answer gives a very concrete description of it.

One can also give a more conceptual description of it. Indeed, it is fairly easy, and classical, to describe the quadratic form attached to an ideal class in conceptual terms; I explain this at the end of my answer. There is also a conceptual approach to going from quadratic forms to ideal classes, but as far as I know it is more recent, and due to Melanie Wood (a version of it is mentioned in this answer).

Namely, if $Q(x,y)$ is a quadratic form over $\mathbb Z$ which is primitive, then one can consider $\mathrm{Proj} \mathbb Z[x,y]/Q(x,y)$, which turns out to be finite flat of degree $2$ over $\mathbb Z$, therefore affine, of the form $\mathrm{Spec} A$ for some quadratic order $A$. And in fact $A$ is isomorphic to $R[(D +\sqrt{D})/2]$, where $D$ is the discriminant of $Q$ (so $A$ is the quadratic order of discriminant $D$). (There is no canonical identification of $A$ with this order though; we can compose with the automorphism $\sqrt{D} \mapsto -\sqrt{D}$ to get another isomorphism.)

Now $\mathrm{Proj}$ comes with a canonical line bundle $\mathcal O(1)$, and so this is an element of $\mathrm{Pic} A$, which can be thought of as the class group of non-zero locally principal ideals in $A$. (The usual class group when $D$ is a fundamental discriminant.)

Using the isomorphism $A \cong R[(D +\sqrt{D})/2],$ we get an element of the class group of $R[(D +\sqrt{D})/2],$ or really a pair $I,I^{-1}$ of elements, because applying the automorphism $\sqrt{D} \mapsto -\sqrt{D}$ switches $I$ and it's inverse.

This gives a map
$$\text{ primitive quadratic forms } Q \text{ of discriminant } D \longrightarrow \text{ pairs } I, I^{-1} \text{ in the class group of } R[(D +\sqrt{D})/2].$$

To see it is a bijection, one can give an explicit inverse (as I mentioned above, this is more classical):

If $I$ is a locally principal ideal in $R[(D +\sqrt{D})/2],$ then the formula $$x \in I \mapsto N(x)/ N(I) \in \mathbb{Z}$$ defines a quadratic form $Q$ on the free rank two $\mathbb{Z}$-module $I$. (Note that $I^{-1}$ will give the same quadratic form, since formation of norms is invariant under conjugation.)

As explained below, there is a correspondence between non-zero locally principal ideals $I$ in the order of disc. $D$ and quadratic forms $Q$ of disc. $D$. The form $Q$ is naturally defined on $I$ via $x \in I \mapsto N(x)/N(I).$ So $Q(x) = n$ iff $N(x) = n N(I)$ if $N(x I^{-1}) = n,$ so representations of $n$ by $Q$ correspond to ideals in the class of $I^{-1}$ having norm $n$.

If we sum over all ideal classes, or equivalently over all $Q$, (and divide by the number of automorphisms of $Q$, which is the group of units in the order, to count ideals rather than elements that generate them) we will get the number of ideals of norm $n$.

============

The discovery of this correspondence must go back to the 19th century, maybe to Dirichlet or Dedekind? And Will Jagy's answer gives a very concrete description of it.

One can also give a more conceptual description of it. Indeed, it is fairly easy, and classical, to describe the quadratic form attached to an ideal class in conceptual terms; I explain this at the end of my answer. There is also a conceptual approach to going from quadratic forms to ideal classes, but as far as I know it is more recent, and due to Melanie Wood (a version of it is mentioned in this answer).

Namely, if $Q(x,y)$ is a quadratic form over $\mathbb Z$ which is primitive, then one can consider $\mathrm{Proj} \mathbb Z[x,y]/Q(x,y)$, which turns out to be finite flat of degree $2$ over $\mathbb Z$, therefore affine, of the form $\mathrm{Spec} A$ for some quadratic order $A$. And in fact $A$ is isomorphic to $R[(D +\sqrt{D})/2]$, where $D$ is the discriminant of $Q$ (so $A$ is the quadratic order of discriminant $D$). (There is no canonical identification of $A$ with this order though; we can compose with the automorphism $\sqrt{D} \mapsto -\sqrt{D}$ to get another isomorphism.)

Now $\mathrm{Proj}$ comes with a canonical line bundle $\mathcal O(1)$, and so this is an element of $\mathrm{Pic} A$, which can be thought of as the class group of non-zero locally principal ideals in $A$. (The usual class group when $D$ is a fundamental discriminant.)

Using the isomorphism $A \cong R[(D +\sqrt{D})/2],$ we get an element of the class group of $R[(D +\sqrt{D})/2],$ or really a pair $I,I^{-1}$ of elements, because applying the automorphism $\sqrt{D} \mapsto -\sqrt{D}$ switches $I$ and it's inverse.

This gives a map
$$\text{ primitive quadratic forms } Q \text{ of discriminant } D \longrightarrow \text{ pairs } I, I^{-1} \text{ in the class group of } R[(D +\sqrt{D})/2].$$

To see it is a bijection, one can give an explicit inverse (as I mentioned above, this is more classical):

If $I$ is a locally principal ideal in $R[(D +\sqrt{D})/2],$ then the formula $$x \in I \mapsto N(x)/ N(I) \in \mathbb{Z}$$ defines a quadratic form $Q$ on the free rank two $\mathbb{Z}$-module $I$. (Note that $I^{-1}$ will give the same quadratic form, since formation of norms is invariant under conjugation.)

Source Link
Matt E
  • 316
  • 2
  • 4

The discovery of this correspondence must go back to the 19th century, maybe to Dirichlet or Dedekind? And Will Jagy's answer gives a very concrete description of it.

One can also give a more conceptual description of it. Indeed, it is fairly easy, and classical, to describe the quadratic form attached to an ideal class in conceptual terms; I explain this at the end of my answer. There is also a conceptual approach to going from quadratic forms to ideal classes, but as far as I know it is more recent, and due to Melanie Wood (a version of it is mentioned in this answer).

Namely, if $Q(x,y)$ is a quadratic form over $\mathbb Z$ which is primitive, then one can consider $\mathrm{Proj} \mathbb Z[x,y]/Q(x,y)$, which turns out to be finite flat of degree $2$ over $\mathbb Z$, therefore affine, of the form $\mathrm{Spec} A$ for some quadratic order $A$. And in fact $A$ is isomorphic to $R[(D +\sqrt{D})/2]$, where $D$ is the discriminant of $Q$ (so $A$ is the quadratic order of discriminant $D$). (There is no canonical identification of $A$ with this order though; we can compose with the automorphism $\sqrt{D} \mapsto -\sqrt{D}$ to get another isomorphism.)

Now $\mathrm{Proj}$ comes with a canonical line bundle $\mathcal O(1)$, and so this is an element of $\mathrm{Pic} A$, which can be thought of as the class group of non-zero locally principal ideals in $A$. (The usual class group when $D$ is a fundamental discriminant.)

Using the isomorphism $A \cong R[(D +\sqrt{D})/2],$ we get an element of the class group of $R[(D +\sqrt{D})/2],$ or really a pair $I,I^{-1}$ of elements, because applying the automorphism $\sqrt{D} \mapsto -\sqrt{D}$ switches $I$ and it's inverse.

This gives a map
$$\text{ primitive quadratic forms } Q \text{ of discriminant } D \longrightarrow \text{ pairs } I, I^{-1} \text{ in the class group of } R[(D +\sqrt{D})/2].$$

To see it is a bijection, one can give an explicit inverse (as I mentioned above, this is more classical):

If $I$ is a locally principal ideal in $R[(D +\sqrt{D})/2],$ then the formula $$x \in I \mapsto N(x)/ N(I) \in \mathbb{Z}$$ defines a quadratic form $Q$ on the free rank two $\mathbb{Z}$-module $I$. (Note that $I^{-1}$ will give the same quadratic form, since formation of norms is invariant under conjugation.)