Skip to main content
added 94 characters in body
Source Link
Steve Huntsman
  • 15.4k
  • 7
  • 75
  • 130

Let $V(r,z)$ denote the volume of a napkin ring of outer radius $r$ and height $2z$. We have that $V(r,rz) = r^3 V(1,z)$ and $V(1,az) = a^3 V(1,z)$. The former equality is trivial. To see the latter one, note that $V(1,z) = 4\pi z^3/3$.*

It follows that $V(r,z) = r^3 V(1,r^{-1}z) = r^3 r^{-3} V(1,z) = V(1,z)$.


*This might want some fleshing out: e.g. decomposing the complementary part of the sphere into two spherical cones, a cylinder, and two "negative" cones. The volumes of the cylinder and cones can be trivially computed; the volume of a spherical cone can be computed without calculus using its solid anglesolid angle $\Omega$ and taking the proportion $\Omega/4\pi$.

Let $V(r,z)$ denote the volume of a napkin ring of outer radius $r$ and height $2z$. We have that $V(r,rz) = r^3 V(1,z)$ and $V(1,az) = a^3 V(1,z)$. The former equality is trivial. To see the latter one, note that $V(1,z) = 4\pi z^3/3$.*

It follows that $V(r,z) = r^3 V(1,r^{-1}z) = r^3 r^{-3} V(1,z) = V(1,z)$.


*This might want some fleshing out: e.g. decomposing the complementary part of the sphere into two spherical cones, a cylinder, and two "negative" cones. The volumes of the cylinder and cones can be trivially computed; the volume of a spherical cone can be computed without calculus using its solid angle $\Omega$ and taking the proportion $\Omega/4\pi$.

Let $V(r,z)$ denote the volume of a napkin ring of outer radius $r$ and height $2z$. We have that $V(r,rz) = r^3 V(1,z)$ and $V(1,az) = a^3 V(1,z)$. The former equality is trivial. To see the latter one, note that $V(1,z) = 4\pi z^3/3$.*

It follows that $V(r,z) = r^3 V(1,r^{-1}z) = r^3 r^{-3} V(1,z) = V(1,z)$.


*This might want some fleshing out: e.g. decomposing the complementary part of the sphere into two spherical cones, a cylinder, and two "negative" cones. The volumes of the cylinder and cones can be trivially computed; the volume of a spherical cone can be computed without calculus using its solid angle $\Omega$ and taking the proportion $\Omega/4\pi$.

added 342 characters in body
Source Link
Steve Huntsman
  • 15.4k
  • 7
  • 75
  • 130

Let $V(r,z)$ denote the volume of a napkin ring of outer radius $r$ and height $2z$. We have that $V(r,rz) = r^3 V(1,z)$ and $V(1,az) = a^3 V(1,z)$. The former equality is trivial. To see the latter one, note that $V(1,z) = 4\pi z^3/3$ (this might want some fleshing out).*

It follows that $V(r,z) = r^3 V(1,r^{-1}z) = r^3 r^{-3} V(1,z) = V(1,z)$.


*This might want some fleshing out: e.g. decomposing the complementary part of the sphere into two spherical cones, a cylinder, and two "negative" cones. The volumes of the cylinder and cones can be trivially computed; the volume of a spherical cone can be computed without calculus using its solid angle $\Omega$ and taking the proportion $\Omega/4\pi$.

Let $V(r,z)$ denote the volume of a napkin ring of outer radius $r$ and height $2z$. We have that $V(r,rz) = r^3 V(1,z)$ and $V(1,az) = a^3 V(1,z)$. The former equality is trivial. To see the latter one, note that $V(1,z) = 4\pi z^3/3$ (this might want some fleshing out).

It follows that $V(r,z) = r^3 V(1,r^{-1}z) = r^3 r^{-3} V(1,z) = V(1,z)$.

Let $V(r,z)$ denote the volume of a napkin ring of outer radius $r$ and height $2z$. We have that $V(r,rz) = r^3 V(1,z)$ and $V(1,az) = a^3 V(1,z)$. The former equality is trivial. To see the latter one, note that $V(1,z) = 4\pi z^3/3$.*

It follows that $V(r,z) = r^3 V(1,r^{-1}z) = r^3 r^{-3} V(1,z) = V(1,z)$.


*This might want some fleshing out: e.g. decomposing the complementary part of the sphere into two spherical cones, a cylinder, and two "negative" cones. The volumes of the cylinder and cones can be trivially computed; the volume of a spherical cone can be computed without calculus using its solid angle $\Omega$ and taking the proportion $\Omega/4\pi$.

Source Link
Steve Huntsman
  • 15.4k
  • 7
  • 75
  • 130

Let $V(r,z)$ denote the volume of a napkin ring of outer radius $r$ and height $2z$. We have that $V(r,rz) = r^3 V(1,z)$ and $V(1,az) = a^3 V(1,z)$. The former equality is trivial. To see the latter one, note that $V(1,z) = 4\pi z^3/3$ (this might want some fleshing out).

It follows that $V(r,z) = r^3 V(1,r^{-1}z) = r^3 r^{-3} V(1,z) = V(1,z)$.