Skip to main content

Let X$X$ be a topological space. A compact set K$K$ is called irreducible if for any two compact subsets K1$K_1$,K2 $K_2$ of K$K$ with K$K$ is equal to the union of K1$K_1$ and K2$K_2$, then K$K$ is equal to K1$K_1$ or K2$K_2$. A compact set K$K$ is called prime if for any two compact sets K1$K_1$,K2 $K_2$ of X$X$ with K$K$ is included in the union of K1$K_1$ and K2$K_2$, then K$K$ is included in K1$K_1$ or K2$K_2$.

Are these two properties equivalent? I guess that they are not the same. But I could not come up with anan example.

Let X be a topological space. A compact set K is called irreducible if for any two compact subsets K1,K2 of K with K is equal to the union of K1 and K2, then K is equal to K1 or K2. A compact set K is called prime if for any two compact sets K1,K2 of X with K is included in the union of K1 and K2, then K is included in K1 or K2.

Are these two properties equivalent? I guess that they are not the same. But I could not come up with an example.

Let $X$ be a topological space. A compact set $K$ is called irreducible if for any two compact subsets $K_1$, $K_2$ of $K$ with $K$ is equal to the union of $K_1$ and $K_2$, then $K$ is equal to $K_1$ or $K_2$. A compact set $K$ is called prime if for any two compact sets $K_1$, $K_2$ of $X$ with $K$ is included in the union of $K_1$ and $K_2$, then $K$ is included in $K_1$ or $K_2$.

Are these two properties equivalent? I guess that they are not the same. But I could not come up with an example.

Source Link

irreducible compact set vs prime compact set

Let X be a topological space. A compact set K is called irreducible if for any two compact subsets K1,K2 of K with K is equal to the union of K1 and K2, then K is equal to K1 or K2. A compact set K is called prime if for any two compact sets K1,K2 of X with K is included in the union of K1 and K2, then K is included in K1 or K2.

Are these two properties equivalent? I guess that they are not the same. But I could not come up with an example.