Skip to main content
Notice removed Draw attention by CommunityBot
Bounty Ended with no winning answer by CommunityBot
Notice added Draw attention by Alkan
Bounty Started worth 100 reputation by Alkan
Names of references and mild proofreading
Source Link
LSpice
  • 12.9k
  • 4
  • 45
  • 69

A question related to Hofstadter-Conwaythe Hofstadter–Conway \$10000 sequence

Hofstadter-ConwayThe Hofstadter–Conway \$10000 sequence is defined by the nested recurrence relation $$c(n) = c(c(n-1)) + c(n-c(n-1))$$ with $c(1) = c(2) = 1$. This sequence is https://oeis.org/A004001 and it is well-known that this sequence has many amazing properties which are investigated in a very interesting paperpaper Kubo and Vakil - On Conway's recursive sequence.

A related curious sequence can be defined by similar recurrence relation as below $$c^*(n) = n - c^*(c^*(n-1)) - c^*(n-c^*(n-1))$$ with $c^*(1) = c^*(2) = 1$. I introduced this sequence in https://oeis.org/A287422 and recurrence is also investigated in terms of sensitivity of initial conditions selections hereAlkan and Aybar - On Families of Solutions for Meta-Fibonacci Recursions Related to Hofstadter–Conway $10000 Sequence.

Conjecture. $c(n) - \frac{n}2$ $\ge$ $\left\lvert c^*(n) - \frac{n}2 \right\rvert$ for all $n \ge 1$. (It is checked up to $2^{32}$.)

Question. Can someone show that $c(n) - \frac{n}2$ $\ge$ $\left\lvert c^*(n) - \frac{n}2 \right\rvert$ for all $n \ge 1$ ?

Comments that are related to combinatorial characterization of $c^*(n)$ are also very welcome.

(I the share below graph in order to display behaviours of both sequences for $n \le 2^{10}$.
  Red: $c(n) - \frac{n}2$, Black: $c^*(n) - \frac{n}2$.)

enter image description hereGraphs of c(n) - n/2 and c*(n) - n/2

Note. I believe that it is also possible to see a way to connection of $c(n)$ and $c^*(n)$ thanks to certain auxiliary variants defined by https://oeis.org/A317754 and https://oeis.org/A317854, see the below graph (red: transformation of $c(n)$, black:transformation transformation of $c^*(n)$). (These variants also make probably interesting sounds if one can think that recurrences that produce sequences with curious sounds are general of interest.) enter image description hereGraphs of transformations of c(n) and c*(n)

Thanks.

A question related to Hofstadter-Conway \$10000 sequence

Hofstadter-Conway \$10000 sequence is defined by nested recurrence relation $$c(n) = c(c(n-1)) + c(n-c(n-1))$$ with $c(1) = c(2) = 1$. This sequence is https://oeis.org/A004001 and it is well-known that this sequence has many amazing properties which are investigated in a very interesting paper.

A related curious sequence can be defined by similar recurrence relation as below $$c^*(n) = n - c^*(c^*(n-1)) - c^*(n-c^*(n-1))$$ with $c^*(1) = c^*(2) = 1$. I introduced this sequence in https://oeis.org/A287422 and recurrence is also investigated in terms of sensitivity of initial conditions selections here.

Conjecture. $c(n) - \frac{n}2$ $\ge$ $\left\lvert c^*(n) - \frac{n}2 \right\rvert$ for all $n \ge 1$. (It is checked up to $2^{32}$.)

Question. Can someone show that $c(n) - \frac{n}2$ $\ge$ $\left\lvert c^*(n) - \frac{n}2 \right\rvert$ for all $n \ge 1$ ?

Comments that are related to combinatorial characterization of $c^*(n)$ are also very welcome.

(I share below graph in order to display behaviours of both sequences for $n \le 2^{10}$.
  Red: $c(n) - \frac{n}2$, Black: $c^*(n) - \frac{n}2$)

enter image description here

Note. I believe that it is also possible to see a way to connection of $c(n)$ and $c^*(n)$ thanks to certain auxiliary variants defined by https://oeis.org/A317754 and https://oeis.org/A317854, see below graph (red: transformation of $c(n)$, black:transformation of $c^*(n)$). (These variants also make probably interesting sounds if one can think that recurrences that produce sequences with curious sounds are general of interest.) enter image description here

Thanks.

A question related to the Hofstadter–Conway \$10000 sequence

The Hofstadter–Conway \$10000 sequence is defined by the nested recurrence relation $$c(n) = c(c(n-1)) + c(n-c(n-1))$$ with $c(1) = c(2) = 1$. This sequence is A004001 and it is well-known that this sequence has many amazing properties which are investigated in a very interesting paper Kubo and Vakil - On Conway's recursive sequence.

A related curious sequence can be defined by similar recurrence relation as below $$c^*(n) = n - c^*(c^*(n-1)) - c^*(n-c^*(n-1))$$ with $c^*(1) = c^*(2) = 1$. I introduced this sequence in A287422 and recurrence is also investigated in terms of sensitivity of initial conditions selections Alkan and Aybar - On Families of Solutions for Meta-Fibonacci Recursions Related to Hofstadter–Conway $10000 Sequence.

Conjecture. $c(n) - \frac{n}2$ $\ge$ $\left\lvert c^*(n) - \frac{n}2 \right\rvert$ for all $n \ge 1$. (It is checked up to $2^{32}$.)

Question. Can someone show that $c(n) - \frac{n}2$ $\ge$ $\left\lvert c^*(n) - \frac{n}2 \right\rvert$ for all $n \ge 1$ ?

Comments that are related to combinatorial characterization of $c^*(n)$ are also very welcome.

(I the share below graph in order to display behaviours of both sequences for $n \le 2^{10}$. Red: $c(n) - \frac{n}2$, Black: $c^*(n) - \frac{n}2$.)

Graphs of c(n) - n/2 and c*(n) - n/2

Note. I believe that it is also possible to see a way to connection of $c(n)$ and $c^*(n)$ thanks to certain auxiliary variants defined by A317754 and A317854, see the below graph (red: transformation of $c(n)$, black: transformation of $c^*(n)$). (These variants also make probably interesting sounds if one can think that recurrences that produce sequences with curious sounds are general of interest.) Graphs of transformations of c(n) and c*(n)

added 98 characters in body
Source Link
Alkan
  • 701
  • 5
  • 16

Hofstadter-Conway \$10000 sequence is defined by nested recurrence relation $$c(n) = c(c(n-1)) + c(n-c(n-1))$$ with $c(1) = c(2) = 1$. This sequence is https://oeis.org/A004001 and it is well-known that this sequence has many amazing properties which are investigated in a very interesting paper.

A related curious sequence can be defined by similar recurrence relation as below $$c^*(n) = n - c^*(c^*(n-1)) - c^*(n-c^*(n-1))$$ with $c^*(1) = c^*(2) = 1$. I introduced this sequence in https://oeis.org/A287422 and recurrence is also investigated in terms of sensitivity of initial conditions selections here.

Conjecture. $c(n) - \frac{n}2$ $\ge$ $\left\lvert c^*(n) - \frac{n}2 \right\rvert$ for all $n \ge 1$. (It is checked up to $2^{32}$.)

Question. Can someone show that $c(n) - \frac{n}2$ $\ge$ $\left\lvert c^*(n) - \frac{n}2 \right\rvert$ for all $n \ge 1$ ?

Comments that are related to combinatorial characterization of $c^*(n)$ are also very welcome.

(I share below graph in order to display behaviours of both sequences for $n \le 2^{10}$.
Red: $c(n) - \frac{n}2$, Black: $c^*(n) - \frac{n}2$)

enter image description here

Note. I believe that it is also possible to see a way to connection of $c(n)$ and $c^*(n)$ thanks to certain auxiliary variants defined by https://oeis.org/A317754 and https://oeis.org/A317854, see below graph (red: transformation of $c(n)$, black:transformation of $c^*(n)$). (These variants also make probably interesting sounds if one can think that recurrences that produce sequences with curious sounds are general of interest.) enter image description here

Thanks.

Hofstadter-Conway \$10000 sequence is defined by nested recurrence relation $$c(n) = c(c(n-1)) + c(n-c(n-1))$$ with $c(1) = c(2) = 1$. This sequence is https://oeis.org/A004001 and it is well-known that this sequence has many amazing properties which are investigated in a very interesting paper.

A related curious sequence can be defined by similar recurrence relation as below $$c^*(n) = n - c^*(c^*(n-1)) - c^*(n-c^*(n-1))$$ with $c^*(1) = c^*(2) = 1$. I introduced this sequence in https://oeis.org/A287422 and recurrence is also investigated in terms of sensitivity of initial conditions selections here.

Conjecture. $c(n) - \frac{n}2$ $\ge$ $\left\lvert c^*(n) - \frac{n}2 \right\rvert$ for all $n \ge 1$. (It is checked up to $2^{32}$.)

Question. Can someone show that $c(n) - \frac{n}2$ $\ge$ $\left\lvert c^*(n) - \frac{n}2 \right\rvert$ for all $n \ge 1$ ?

(I share below graph in order to display behaviours of both sequences for $n \le 2^{10}$.
Red: $c(n) - \frac{n}2$, Black: $c^*(n) - \frac{n}2$)

enter image description here

Note. I believe that it is also possible to see a way to connection of $c(n)$ and $c^*(n)$ thanks to certain auxiliary variants defined by https://oeis.org/A317754 and https://oeis.org/A317854, see below graph (red: transformation of $c(n)$, black:transformation of $c^*(n)$). (These variants also make probably interesting sounds if one can think that recurrences that produce sequences with curious sounds are general of interest.) enter image description here

Thanks.

Hofstadter-Conway \$10000 sequence is defined by nested recurrence relation $$c(n) = c(c(n-1)) + c(n-c(n-1))$$ with $c(1) = c(2) = 1$. This sequence is https://oeis.org/A004001 and it is well-known that this sequence has many amazing properties which are investigated in a very interesting paper.

A related curious sequence can be defined by similar recurrence relation as below $$c^*(n) = n - c^*(c^*(n-1)) - c^*(n-c^*(n-1))$$ with $c^*(1) = c^*(2) = 1$. I introduced this sequence in https://oeis.org/A287422 and recurrence is also investigated in terms of sensitivity of initial conditions selections here.

Conjecture. $c(n) - \frac{n}2$ $\ge$ $\left\lvert c^*(n) - \frac{n}2 \right\rvert$ for all $n \ge 1$. (It is checked up to $2^{32}$.)

Question. Can someone show that $c(n) - \frac{n}2$ $\ge$ $\left\lvert c^*(n) - \frac{n}2 \right\rvert$ for all $n \ge 1$ ?

Comments that are related to combinatorial characterization of $c^*(n)$ are also very welcome.

(I share below graph in order to display behaviours of both sequences for $n \le 2^{10}$.
Red: $c(n) - \frac{n}2$, Black: $c^*(n) - \frac{n}2$)

enter image description here

Note. I believe that it is also possible to see a way to connection of $c(n)$ and $c^*(n)$ thanks to certain auxiliary variants defined by https://oeis.org/A317754 and https://oeis.org/A317854, see below graph (red: transformation of $c(n)$, black:transformation of $c^*(n)$). (These variants also make probably interesting sounds if one can think that recurrences that produce sequences with curious sounds are general of interest.) enter image description here

Thanks.

I tried to edit links that were probably bad in terms format.
Source Link
Alkan
  • 701
  • 5
  • 16

Hofstadter-Conway \$10000 sequence is defined by nested recurrence relation $$c(n) = c(c(n-1)) + c(n-c(n-1))$$ with $c(1) = c(2) = 1$. This sequence is https://oeis.org/A004001 and it is well-known that this sequence has many amazing properties: which are investigated in a very interesting https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/0012365X9400303Zpaper.

A related curious sequence can be defined by similar recurrence relation as below $$c^*(n) = n - c^*(c^*(n-1)) - c^*(n-c^*(n-1))$$ with $c^*(1) = c^*(2) = 1$. I introduced this sequence in https://oeis.org/A287422 and recurrence is also investigated in terms of sensitivity of initial conditions selections:   https://link.springer.com/chapter/10.1007%2F978-3-030-35441-1_14here.

Conjecture. $c(n) - \frac{n}2$ $\ge$ $\left\lvert c^*(n) - \frac{n}2 \right\rvert$ for all $n \ge 1$. (It is checked up to $2^{32}$.)

Question. Can someone show that $c(n) - \frac{n}2$ $\ge$ $\left\lvert c^*(n) - \frac{n}2 \right\rvert$ for all $n \ge 1$ ?

(I share below graph in order to display behaviours of both sequences for $n \le 2^{10}$.
Red: $c(n) - \frac{n}2$, Black: $c^*(n) - \frac{n}2$)

enter image description here

Note. I believe that it is also possible to see a way to connection of $c(n)$ and $c^*(n)$ thanks to certain auxiliary variants defined by https://oeis.org/A317754 and https://oeis.org/A317854, see below graph (red: transformation of $c(n)$, black:transformation of $c^*(n)$). (These variants also make probably interesting sounds if one can think that recurrences that produce sequences with curious sounds are general of interest.) enter image description here

Thanks.

Hofstadter-Conway \$10000 sequence is defined by nested recurrence relation $$c(n) = c(c(n-1)) + c(n-c(n-1))$$ with $c(1) = c(2) = 1$. This sequence is https://oeis.org/A004001 and it is well-known that this sequence has many amazing properties: https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/0012365X9400303Z

A related curious sequence can be defined by similar recurrence relation as below $$c^*(n) = n - c^*(c^*(n-1)) - c^*(n-c^*(n-1))$$ with $c^*(1) = c^*(2) = 1$. I introduced this sequence in https://oeis.org/A287422 and recurrence is also investigated in terms of sensitivity of initial conditions selections: https://link.springer.com/chapter/10.1007%2F978-3-030-35441-1_14

Conjecture. $c(n) - \frac{n}2$ $\ge$ $\left\lvert c^*(n) - \frac{n}2 \right\rvert$ for all $n \ge 1$. (It is checked up to $2^{32}$.)

Question. Can someone show that $c(n) - \frac{n}2$ $\ge$ $\left\lvert c^*(n) - \frac{n}2 \right\rvert$ for all $n \ge 1$ ?

(I share below graph in order to display behaviours of both sequences for $n \le 2^{10}$.
Red: $c(n) - \frac{n}2$, Black: $c^*(n) - \frac{n}2$)

enter image description here

Note. I believe that it is also possible to see a way to connection of $c(n)$ and $c^*(n)$ thanks to certain auxiliary variants defined by https://oeis.org/A317754 and https://oeis.org/A317854, see below graph (red: transformation of $c(n)$, black:transformation of $c^*(n)$). (These variants also make probably interesting sounds if one can think that recurrences that produce sequences with curious sounds are general of interest.) enter image description here

Hofstadter-Conway \$10000 sequence is defined by nested recurrence relation $$c(n) = c(c(n-1)) + c(n-c(n-1))$$ with $c(1) = c(2) = 1$. This sequence is https://oeis.org/A004001 and it is well-known that this sequence has many amazing properties which are investigated in a very interesting paper.

A related curious sequence can be defined by similar recurrence relation as below $$c^*(n) = n - c^*(c^*(n-1)) - c^*(n-c^*(n-1))$$ with $c^*(1) = c^*(2) = 1$. I introduced this sequence in https://oeis.org/A287422 and recurrence is also investigated in terms of sensitivity of initial conditions selections  here.

Conjecture. $c(n) - \frac{n}2$ $\ge$ $\left\lvert c^*(n) - \frac{n}2 \right\rvert$ for all $n \ge 1$. (It is checked up to $2^{32}$.)

Question. Can someone show that $c(n) - \frac{n}2$ $\ge$ $\left\lvert c^*(n) - \frac{n}2 \right\rvert$ for all $n \ge 1$ ?

(I share below graph in order to display behaviours of both sequences for $n \le 2^{10}$.
Red: $c(n) - \frac{n}2$, Black: $c^*(n) - \frac{n}2$)

enter image description here

Note. I believe that it is also possible to see a way to connection of $c(n)$ and $c^*(n)$ thanks to certain auxiliary variants defined by https://oeis.org/A317754 and https://oeis.org/A317854, see below graph (red: transformation of $c(n)$, black:transformation of $c^*(n)$). (These variants also make probably interesting sounds if one can think that recurrences that produce sequences with curious sounds are general of interest.) enter image description here

Thanks.

added 170 characters in body
Source Link
Alkan
  • 701
  • 5
  • 16
Loading
added 359 characters in body
Source Link
Alkan
  • 701
  • 5
  • 16
Loading
added 110 characters in body
Source Link
Alkan
  • 701
  • 5
  • 16
Loading
added 25 characters in body
Source Link
Alkan
  • 701
  • 5
  • 16
Loading
edited tags
Link
YCor
  • 63.9k
  • 5
  • 187
  • 286
Loading
added 6 characters in body
Source Link
Alkan
  • 701
  • 5
  • 16
Loading
Source Link
Alkan
  • 701
  • 5
  • 16
Loading