Skip to main content
Rollback to Revision 1
Source Link
Tim Campion
  • 63.9k
  • 13
  • 143
  • 384

Let $X$ be a CW complex. If If $E$ is a vector bundle over $X$, then it's well-known that the Stiefel-Whitney classes $w_j(E) \in H^j(X,\mathbb F_2)$ of $E$ are determined from the classes $w_{2^k}(E)$ (for $2^k \leq j$) via the Wu formula, using the cup product and the action of the Steenrod algebra.$E$ is a vector bundle over EDIT: I currently understand$X$, then it's well-known that The Wu formula need only be satisfied by the Stiefel-Whitney classes $w_j(E) \in H^j(X,\mathbb F_2)$ of $E$ are determined from the classes tangent bundle of a smooth manifold$w_{2^k}(E)$ -- not by an arbitrary vector bundle(for $2^k \leq j$) via the Wu formula, using the cup product and the action of the Steenrod algebra.


Question 1: Does the Wu formula imply any further relations? This is a purely algebraic question which I make more precise in (a) and (b) below.

That is, let $H$ be a nonnegatively-graded $\mathbb F_2$-algebra with an unstable action of the Steenrod algebra satisfying the Cartan formula and $Sq^{|x|}(x) = x^2$ for all homogenenous $x \in H$. Let $W$ be the set of sequences $(w_j \in H^j)_{j \in \mathbb N}$ with $w_0 = 1$ and satisfying the Wu formla.

(a) For any sequence $(v_{2^k} \in H^{2^k})_{k \in \mathbb N}$, does there exist $w \in W$ (necessarily unique) with $w_{2^k} = v_{2^k}$ for all $k \in \mathbb N$?

Presumably (i) the Whitney sum formula and (ii) the universal formula for the Stiefel-Whitney classes of a tensor product of vector bundles are compatible with the Wu formula, so that $W$ is a commutative ring using (i) for addition and (ii) for multiplication.

(b) Is $W$ a polynomial algebra on whichever generators from (a) do exist?


Question 2: What restrictions beyond the Wu formula are there restricting the Stiefel-Whitney classes of a vector bundle $E$ on a CW complex $X$? This is a genuinely topological question.

Over here Mark Grant describes one such restriction, but ideally I'd like a more systematic discussion.


If it simplifies matters to assume that $X$ is finite, or even a compact manifold, then that's fine.

Let $X$ be a CW complex. If $E$ is a vector bundle over $X$, then it's well-known that the Stiefel-Whitney classes $w_j(E) \in H^j(X,\mathbb F_2)$ of $E$ are determined from the classes $w_{2^k}(E)$ (for $2^k \leq j$) via the Wu formula, using the cup product and the action of the Steenrod algebra. EDIT: I currently understand that The Wu formula need only be satisfied by the Stiefel-Whitney classes of the tangent bundle of a smooth manifold -- not by an arbitrary vector bundle.


Question 1: Does the Wu formula imply any further relations? This is a purely algebraic question which I make more precise in (a) and (b) below.

That is, let $H$ be a nonnegatively-graded $\mathbb F_2$-algebra with an unstable action of the Steenrod algebra satisfying the Cartan formula and $Sq^{|x|}(x) = x^2$ for all homogenenous $x \in H$. Let $W$ be the set of sequences $(w_j \in H^j)_{j \in \mathbb N}$ with $w_0 = 1$ and satisfying the Wu formla.

(a) For any sequence $(v_{2^k} \in H^{2^k})_{k \in \mathbb N}$, does there exist $w \in W$ (necessarily unique) with $w_{2^k} = v_{2^k}$ for all $k \in \mathbb N$?

Presumably (i) the Whitney sum formula and (ii) the universal formula for the Stiefel-Whitney classes of a tensor product of vector bundles are compatible with the Wu formula, so that $W$ is a commutative ring using (i) for addition and (ii) for multiplication.

(b) Is $W$ a polynomial algebra on whichever generators from (a) do exist?


Question 2: What restrictions beyond the Wu formula are there restricting the Stiefel-Whitney classes of a vector bundle $E$ on a CW complex $X$? This is a genuinely topological question.

Over here Mark Grant describes one such restriction, but ideally I'd like a more systematic discussion.


If it simplifies matters to assume that $X$ is finite, or even a compact manifold, then that's fine.

Let $X$ be a CW complex. If $E$ is a vector bundle over $X$, then it's well-known that the Stiefel-Whitney classes $w_j(E) \in H^j(X,\mathbb F_2)$ of $E$ are determined from the classes $w_{2^k}(E)$ (for $2^k \leq j$) via the Wu formula, using the cup product and the action of the Steenrod algebra.


Question 1: Does the Wu formula imply any further relations? This is a purely algebraic question which I make more precise in (a) and (b) below.

That is, let $H$ be a nonnegatively-graded $\mathbb F_2$-algebra with an unstable action of the Steenrod algebra satisfying the Cartan formula and $Sq^{|x|}(x) = x^2$ for all homogenenous $x \in H$. Let $W$ be the set of sequences $(w_j \in H^j)_{j \in \mathbb N}$ with $w_0 = 1$ and satisfying the Wu formla.

(a) For any sequence $(v_{2^k} \in H^{2^k})_{k \in \mathbb N}$, does there exist $w \in W$ (necessarily unique) with $w_{2^k} = v_{2^k}$ for all $k \in \mathbb N$?

Presumably (i) the Whitney sum formula and (ii) the universal formula for the Stiefel-Whitney classes of a tensor product of vector bundles are compatible with the Wu formula, so that $W$ is a commutative ring using (i) for addition and (ii) for multiplication.

(b) Is $W$ a polynomial algebra on whichever generators from (a) do exist?


Question 2: What restrictions beyond the Wu formula are there restricting the Stiefel-Whitney classes of a vector bundle $E$ on a CW complex $X$? This is a genuinely topological question.

Over here Mark Grant describes one such restriction, but ideally I'd like a more systematic discussion.


If it simplifies matters to assume that $X$ is finite, or even a compact manifold, then that's fine.

added 208 characters in body
Source Link
Tim Campion
  • 63.9k
  • 13
  • 143
  • 384

Let $X$ be a CW complex. If $E$ is a vector bundle over If $E$ is a vector bundle over $X$, then it's well-known that the Stiefel-Whitney classes $w_j(E) \in H^j(X,\mathbb F_2)$ of $E$ are determined from the classes $w_{2^k}(E)$ (for $2^k \leq j$) via the Wu formula, using the cup product and the action of the Steenrod algebra. $X$, then it's well-knownEDIT: I currently understand that The Wu formula need only be satisfied by the Stiefel-Whitney classes $w_j(E) \in H^j(X,\mathbb F_2)$ of $E$ are determined from the classes $w_{2^k}(E)$ (for $2^k \leq j$) via the Wu formula, using the cup product and the actiontangent bundle of the Steenrod algebraa smooth manifold -- not by an arbitrary vector bundle.


Question 1: Does the Wu formula imply any further relations? This is a purely algebraic question which I make more precise in (a) and (b) below.

That is, let $H$ be a nonnegatively-graded $\mathbb F_2$-algebra with an unstable action of the Steenrod algebra satisfying the Cartan formula and $Sq^{|x|}(x) = x^2$ for all homogenenous $x \in H$. Let $W$ be the set of sequences $(w_j \in H^j)_{j \in \mathbb N}$ with $w_0 = 1$ and satisfying the Wu formla.

(a) For any sequence $(v_{2^k} \in H^{2^k})_{k \in \mathbb N}$, does there exist $w \in W$ (necessarily unique) with $w_{2^k} = v_{2^k}$ for all $k \in \mathbb N$?

Presumably (i) the Whitney sum formula and (ii) the universal formula for the Stiefel-Whitney classes of a tensor product of vector bundles are compatible with the Wu formula, so that $W$ is a commutative ring using (i) for addition and (ii) for multiplication.

(b) Is $W$ a polynomial algebra on whichever generators from (a) do exist?


Question 2: What restrictions beyond the Wu formula are there restricting the Stiefel-Whitney classes of a vector bundle $E$ on a CW complex $X$? This is a genuinely topological question.

Over here Mark Grant describes one such restriction, but ideally I'd like a more systematic discussion.


If it simplifies matters to assume that $X$ is finite, or even a compact manifold, then that's fine.

Let $X$ be a CW complex. If $E$ is a vector bundle over $X$, then it's well-known that the Stiefel-Whitney classes $w_j(E) \in H^j(X,\mathbb F_2)$ of $E$ are determined from the classes $w_{2^k}(E)$ (for $2^k \leq j$) via the Wu formula, using the cup product and the action of the Steenrod algebra.


Question 1: Does the Wu formula imply any further relations? This is a purely algebraic question which I make more precise in (a) and (b) below.

That is, let $H$ be a nonnegatively-graded $\mathbb F_2$-algebra with an unstable action of the Steenrod algebra satisfying the Cartan formula and $Sq^{|x|}(x) = x^2$ for all homogenenous $x \in H$. Let $W$ be the set of sequences $(w_j \in H^j)_{j \in \mathbb N}$ with $w_0 = 1$ and satisfying the Wu formla.

(a) For any sequence $(v_{2^k} \in H^{2^k})_{k \in \mathbb N}$, does there exist $w \in W$ (necessarily unique) with $w_{2^k} = v_{2^k}$ for all $k \in \mathbb N$?

Presumably (i) the Whitney sum formula and (ii) the universal formula for the Stiefel-Whitney classes of a tensor product of vector bundles are compatible with the Wu formula, so that $W$ is a commutative ring using (i) for addition and (ii) for multiplication.

(b) Is $W$ a polynomial algebra on whichever generators from (a) do exist?


Question 2: What restrictions beyond the Wu formula are there restricting the Stiefel-Whitney classes of a vector bundle $E$ on a CW complex $X$? This is a genuinely topological question.

Over here Mark Grant describes one such restriction, but ideally I'd like a more systematic discussion.


If it simplifies matters to assume that $X$ is finite, or even a compact manifold, then that's fine.

Let $X$ be a CW complex. If $E$ is a vector bundle over $X$, then it's well-known that the Stiefel-Whitney classes $w_j(E) \in H^j(X,\mathbb F_2)$ of $E$ are determined from the classes $w_{2^k}(E)$ (for $2^k \leq j$) via the Wu formula, using the cup product and the action of the Steenrod algebra. EDIT: I currently understand that The Wu formula need only be satisfied by the Stiefel-Whitney classes of the tangent bundle of a smooth manifold -- not by an arbitrary vector bundle.


Question 1: Does the Wu formula imply any further relations? This is a purely algebraic question which I make more precise in (a) and (b) below.

That is, let $H$ be a nonnegatively-graded $\mathbb F_2$-algebra with an unstable action of the Steenrod algebra satisfying the Cartan formula and $Sq^{|x|}(x) = x^2$ for all homogenenous $x \in H$. Let $W$ be the set of sequences $(w_j \in H^j)_{j \in \mathbb N}$ with $w_0 = 1$ and satisfying the Wu formla.

(a) For any sequence $(v_{2^k} \in H^{2^k})_{k \in \mathbb N}$, does there exist $w \in W$ (necessarily unique) with $w_{2^k} = v_{2^k}$ for all $k \in \mathbb N$?

Presumably (i) the Whitney sum formula and (ii) the universal formula for the Stiefel-Whitney classes of a tensor product of vector bundles are compatible with the Wu formula, so that $W$ is a commutative ring using (i) for addition and (ii) for multiplication.

(b) Is $W$ a polynomial algebra on whichever generators from (a) do exist?


Question 2: What restrictions beyond the Wu formula are there restricting the Stiefel-Whitney classes of a vector bundle $E$ on a CW complex $X$? This is a genuinely topological question.

Over here Mark Grant describes one such restriction, but ideally I'd like a more systematic discussion.


If it simplifies matters to assume that $X$ is finite, or even a compact manifold, then that's fine.

Source Link
Tim Campion
  • 63.9k
  • 13
  • 143
  • 384

Realizing Stiefel-Whitney classes via vector bundles

Let $X$ be a CW complex. If $E$ is a vector bundle over $X$, then it's well-known that the Stiefel-Whitney classes $w_j(E) \in H^j(X,\mathbb F_2)$ of $E$ are determined from the classes $w_{2^k}(E)$ (for $2^k \leq j$) via the Wu formula, using the cup product and the action of the Steenrod algebra.


Question 1: Does the Wu formula imply any further relations? This is a purely algebraic question which I make more precise in (a) and (b) below.

That is, let $H$ be a nonnegatively-graded $\mathbb F_2$-algebra with an unstable action of the Steenrod algebra satisfying the Cartan formula and $Sq^{|x|}(x) = x^2$ for all homogenenous $x \in H$. Let $W$ be the set of sequences $(w_j \in H^j)_{j \in \mathbb N}$ with $w_0 = 1$ and satisfying the Wu formla.

(a) For any sequence $(v_{2^k} \in H^{2^k})_{k \in \mathbb N}$, does there exist $w \in W$ (necessarily unique) with $w_{2^k} = v_{2^k}$ for all $k \in \mathbb N$?

Presumably (i) the Whitney sum formula and (ii) the universal formula for the Stiefel-Whitney classes of a tensor product of vector bundles are compatible with the Wu formula, so that $W$ is a commutative ring using (i) for addition and (ii) for multiplication.

(b) Is $W$ a polynomial algebra on whichever generators from (a) do exist?


Question 2: What restrictions beyond the Wu formula are there restricting the Stiefel-Whitney classes of a vector bundle $E$ on a CW complex $X$? This is a genuinely topological question.

Over here Mark Grant describes one such restriction, but ideally I'd like a more systematic discussion.


If it simplifies matters to assume that $X$ is finite, or even a compact manifold, then that's fine.