Skip to main content
fix TeX
Source Link
Emil Jeřábek
  • 47.5k
  • 4
  • 150
  • 209

The proof is by contradiction. Assume $f$ is not a polynomial.

Consider the following closed sets: $$ S_n = \{x: f^{(n)}(x) = 0\}. $$$$ S_n = \{x: f^{(n)}(x) = 0\} $$ and $$ X = \{x: \forall (a,b)\ni x:\; f|_{(a,b)}\; is\; not\; a \;polynomial \}. $$$$ X = \{x: \forall (a,b)\ni x: f\restriction_{(a,b)}\text{ is not a polynomial} \}. $$

It is clear that $X$ is a non-empty closed set without isolated points. Applying Baire category theorem to the covering $\{X\cap S_n\}$ of $X$ we get that there exists an interval $(a,b)$ such that $(a,b)\cap X$ is non-empty and $$ (a,b)\cap X\subset S_n $$ for some $n$. Since every $x\in (a,b)\cap X$ is an accumulation point we also have that $x\in S_m$ for all $m\ge n$ and $x\in (a,b)\cap X$.

Now consider any maximal interval $(c,e)\subset ((a,b)-X)$. Recall that $f$ is a polynomial of some degree $d$ on $(c,e)$. Therefore $f^{(d)}=const\neq 0$$f^{(d)}=\mathrm{const}\neq 0$ on $[c,e]$. Hence $d< n$. (Since either $c$ or $e$ is in $X$.)

So we get that $f^{(n)}=0$ on $(a,b)$ which is in contradiction with $(a,b)\cap X$ being non-empty.

The proof is by contradiction. Assume $f$ is not a polynomial.

Consider the following closed sets $$ S_n = \{x: f^{(n)}(x) = 0\}. $$ and $$ X = \{x: \forall (a,b)\ni x:\; f|_{(a,b)}\; is\; not\; a \;polynomial \}. $$

It is clear that $X$ is a non-empty closed set without isolated points. Applying Baire category theorem to the covering $\{X\cap S_n\}$ of $X$ we get that there exists an interval $(a,b)$ such that $(a,b)\cap X$ is non-empty and $$ (a,b)\cap X\subset S_n $$ for some $n$. Since every $x\in (a,b)\cap X$ is an accumulation point we also have that $x\in S_m$ for all $m\ge n$ and $x\in (a,b)\cap X$.

Now consider any maximal interval $(c,e)\subset ((a,b)-X)$. Recall that $f$ is a polynomial of some degree $d$ on $(c,e)$. Therefore $f^{(d)}=const\neq 0$ on $[c,e]$. Hence $d< n$. (Since either $c$ or $e$ is in $X$.)

So we get that $f^{(n)}=0$ on $(a,b)$ which is in contradiction with $(a,b)\cap X$ being non-empty.

The proof is by contradiction. Assume $f$ is not a polynomial.

Consider the following closed sets: $$ S_n = \{x: f^{(n)}(x) = 0\} $$ and $$ X = \{x: \forall (a,b)\ni x: f\restriction_{(a,b)}\text{ is not a polynomial} \}. $$

It is clear that $X$ is a non-empty closed set without isolated points. Applying Baire category theorem to the covering $\{X\cap S_n\}$ of $X$ we get that there exists an interval $(a,b)$ such that $(a,b)\cap X$ is non-empty and $$ (a,b)\cap X\subset S_n $$ for some $n$. Since every $x\in (a,b)\cap X$ is an accumulation point we also have that $x\in S_m$ for all $m\ge n$ and $x\in (a,b)\cap X$.

Now consider any maximal interval $(c,e)\subset ((a,b)-X)$. Recall that $f$ is a polynomial of some degree $d$ on $(c,e)$. Therefore $f^{(d)}=\mathrm{const}\neq 0$ on $[c,e]$. Hence $d< n$. (Since either $c$ or $e$ is in $X$.)

So we get that $f^{(n)}=0$ on $(a,b)$ which is in contradiction with $(a,b)\cap X$ being non-empty.

added 101 characters in body
Source Link
Andrey Gogolev
  • 4.2k
  • 1
  • 22
  • 26

The proof is by contradiction. Assume $f$ is not a polynomial.

Consider the following closed sets $$ S_n = \{x: f^{(n)}(x) = 0\}. $$ and $$ X = \{x: \forall (a,b)\ni x:\; f|_{(a,b)}\; is\; not\; a \;polynomial \}. $$

It is clear that $X$ is a non-empty closed set without isolated points. Applying Baire category theorem to the covering $\{X\cap S_n\}$ of $X$ we get that there exists an interval $(a,b)$ such that $(a,b)\cap X$ is non-empty and $$ (a,b)\cap X\subset S_n $$ for some $n$. Since every $x\in (a,b)\cap X$ is an accumulation point we also have that $x\in S_m$ for all $m\ge n$ and $x$$x\in (a,b)\cap X$.

Now consider and any maximal interval $(c,e)\subset ((a,b)-X)$. Recall that $f$ is a polynomial of some degree $d$ on $(c,e)$. Therefore $f^{(d)}\neq 0$$f^{(d)}=const\neq 0$ on $[c,e]$. Hence $d< n$. (Since either $c$ or $e$ is in $X$.)

So we get that $f^{(n)}=0$ on $(a,b)$ which contradicts the definition ofis in contradiction with $X$$(a,b)\cap X$ being non-empty.

The proof is by contradiction. Assume $f$ is not a polynomial.

Consider the following sets $$ S_n = \{x: f^{(n)}(x) = 0\}. $$ $$ X = \{x: \forall (a,b)\ni x:\; f|_{(a,b)}\; is\; not\; a \;polynomial \}. $$

It is clear that $X$ is a non-empty closed set without isolated points. Applying Baire category theorem to $X$ we get that there exists $(a,b)$ such that $(a,b)\cap X$ is non-empty and $$ (a,b)\cap X\subset S_n $$ for some $n$. Since every $x\in (a,b)\cap X$ is an accumulation point we have that $x\in S_m$ for all $m\ge n$ and $x$.

Now consider and any maximal interval $(c,e)\subset ((a,b)-X)$. Recall that $f$ is a polynomial of some degree $d$ on $(c,e)$. Therefore $f^{(d)}\neq 0$ on $[c,e]$. Hence $d< n$. (Since either $c$ or $e$ is in $X$.)

So we get that $f^{(n)}=0$ on $(a,b)$ which contradicts the definition of $X$.

The proof is by contradiction. Assume $f$ is not a polynomial.

Consider the following closed sets $$ S_n = \{x: f^{(n)}(x) = 0\}. $$ and $$ X = \{x: \forall (a,b)\ni x:\; f|_{(a,b)}\; is\; not\; a \;polynomial \}. $$

It is clear that $X$ is a non-empty closed set without isolated points. Applying Baire category theorem to the covering $\{X\cap S_n\}$ of $X$ we get that there exists an interval $(a,b)$ such that $(a,b)\cap X$ is non-empty and $$ (a,b)\cap X\subset S_n $$ for some $n$. Since every $x\in (a,b)\cap X$ is an accumulation point we also have that $x\in S_m$ for all $m\ge n$ and $x\in (a,b)\cap X$.

Now consider any maximal interval $(c,e)\subset ((a,b)-X)$. Recall that $f$ is a polynomial of some degree $d$ on $(c,e)$. Therefore $f^{(d)}=const\neq 0$ on $[c,e]$. Hence $d< n$. (Since either $c$ or $e$ is in $X$.)

So we get that $f^{(n)}=0$ on $(a,b)$ which is in contradiction with $(a,b)\cap X$ being non-empty.

Source Link
Andrey Gogolev
  • 4.2k
  • 1
  • 22
  • 26

The proof is by contradiction. Assume $f$ is not a polynomial.

Consider the following sets $$ S_n = \{x: f^{(n)}(x) = 0\}. $$ $$ X = \{x: \forall (a,b)\ni x:\; f|_{(a,b)}\; is\; not\; a \;polynomial \}. $$

It is clear that $X$ is a non-empty closed set without isolated points. Applying Baire category theorem to $X$ we get that there exists $(a,b)$ such that $(a,b)\cap X$ is non-empty and $$ (a,b)\cap X\subset S_n $$ for some $n$. Since every $x\in (a,b)\cap X$ is an accumulation point we have that $x\in S_m$ for all $m\ge n$ and $x$.

Now consider and any maximal interval $(c,e)\subset ((a,b)-X)$. Recall that $f$ is a polynomial of some degree $d$ on $(c,e)$. Therefore $f^{(d)}\neq 0$ on $[c,e]$. Hence $d< n$. (Since either $c$ or $e$ is in $X$.)

So we get that $f^{(n)}=0$ on $(a,b)$ which contradicts the definition of $X$.