Skip to main content
finally fixed! thanks Ycor
Source Link
Suvrit
  • 28.6k
  • 7
  • 82
  • 150

In a recent paper ([1]), Ravichandran and Srivastava (RS) study pavings for collections of matrices. Their main theorem claims to yield an improvement to the bound obtained by Johnson, Ozawa, and Schechtman (JOS). However, as noted by YCor in a comment, RS [1] cite the JOS work as satisfying a bound on $\max(\|B\|,\|C\|)$, instead of a bound on the product $\|B\| \|C\|$ as in Bill Johnson's answer above.

But as YCor notes, so without further assumptionswe can scale $B$ by $\|A\|$ (or both $B$ and $C$ by suitably, e.g., $\sqrt{\|A\|}$), to recover the bounds are differentinequality for the case noted in the OP and in the JOS paper.

In particular, Ravichandran and Srivastava's results imply the following:

Corollary (Corollary 3 in [1]). Every zero trace matrix $A \in M_n(\mathbb{C})$ may be written as $A=[B,C]$ such that $\|B\|$, $\|C\| \le K\log^2(n)\|A\|$ for some universal constant $K$.

(By suitable scaling, this translates into $\|B'\|\|C'\| \le K^2\log^4(n)\|A\|$, for $[B',C']=A$).

[1]. M. Ravichandran and N. Srivastava. Asymptotically Optimal Multi-Paving. arXiv. Jun 2017.

In a recent paper ([1]), Ravichandran and Srivastava (RS) study pavings for collections of matrices. Their main theorem claims to yield an improvement to the bound obtained by Johnson, Ozawa, and Schechtman (JOS). However, as noted by YCor in a comment, RS [1] cite the JOS work as satisfying a bound on $\max(\|B\|,\|C\|)$, instead of a bound on the product $\|B\| \|C\|$ as in Bill Johnson's answer above, so without further assumptions the bounds are different.

In particular, Ravichandran and Srivastava's results imply the following:

Corollary (Corollary 3 in [1]). Every zero trace matrix $A \in M_n(\mathbb{C})$ may be written as $A=[B,C]$ such that $\|B\|$, $\|C\| \le K\log^2(n)\|A\|$ for some universal constant $K$.

[1]. M. Ravichandran and N. Srivastava. Asymptotically Optimal Multi-Paving. arXiv. Jun 2017.

In a recent paper ([1]), Ravichandran and Srivastava (RS) study pavings for collections of matrices. Their main theorem claims to yield an improvement to the bound obtained by Johnson, Ozawa, and Schechtman (JOS). However, as noted by YCor in a comment, RS [1] cite the JOS work as satisfying a bound on $\max(\|B\|,\|C\|)$, instead of a bound on the product $\|B\| \|C\|$ as in Bill Johnson's answer above.

But as YCor notes, we can scale $B$ by $\|A\|$ (or both $B$ and $C$ by suitably, e.g., $\sqrt{\|A\|}$), to recover the inequality for the case noted in the OP and in the JOS paper.

In particular, Ravichandran and Srivastava's results imply the following:

Corollary (Corollary 3 in [1]). Every zero trace matrix $A \in M_n(\mathbb{C})$ may be written as $A=[B,C]$ such that $\|B\|$, $\|C\| \le K\log^2(n)\|A\|$ for some universal constant $K$.

(By suitable scaling, this translates into $\|B'\|\|C'\| \le K^2\log^4(n)\|A\|$, for $[B',C']=A$).

[1]. M. Ravichandran and N. Srivastava. Asymptotically Optimal Multi-Paving. arXiv. Jun 2017.

added a correction and explanation
Source Link
Suvrit
  • 28.6k
  • 7
  • 82
  • 150

In a recent paper ([1]), Ravichandran and Srivastava (RS) study pavings for collections of matrices. Their main theorem yieldsclaims to yield an improvement to the bound obtained by Johnson, Ozawa, and Schechtman (notedJOS). However, as noted by YCor in a comment, RS [1] cite the JOS work as satisfying a bound on $\max(\|B\|,\|C\|)$, instead of a bound on the product $\|B\| \|C\|$ as in Bill Johnson's answer above), so without further assumptions the bounds are different. 

In particular, Ravichandran and Srivastava's work impliesresults imply the following:

Corollary (Corollary 3 in [1]). Every zero trace matrix $A \in M_n(\mathbb{C})$ may be written as $A=[B,C]$ such that $\|B\|$, $\|C\| \le K\log^2(n)\|A\|$ for some universal constant $K$.

[1]. M. Ravichandran and N. Srivastava. Asymptotically Optimal Multi-Paving. arXiv. Jun 2017.

In a recent paper ([1]), Ravichandran and Srivastava study pavings for collections of matrices. Their main theorem yields an improvement to the bound obtained by Johnson, Ozawa, and Schechtman (noted in Bill Johnson's answer above). In particular, Ravichandran and Srivastava's work implies the following:

Corollary (Corollary 3 in [1]). Every zero trace matrix $A \in M_n(\mathbb{C})$ may be written as $A=[B,C]$ such that $\|B\|$, $\|C\| \le K\log^2(n)\|A\|$ for some universal constant $K$.

[1]. M. Ravichandran and N. Srivastava. Asymptotically Optimal Multi-Paving. arXiv. Jun 2017.

In a recent paper ([1]), Ravichandran and Srivastava (RS) study pavings for collections of matrices. Their main theorem claims to yield an improvement to the bound obtained by Johnson, Ozawa, and Schechtman (JOS). However, as noted by YCor in a comment, RS [1] cite the JOS work as satisfying a bound on $\max(\|B\|,\|C\|)$, instead of a bound on the product $\|B\| \|C\|$ as in Bill Johnson's answer above, so without further assumptions the bounds are different. 

In particular, Ravichandran and Srivastava's results imply the following:

Corollary (Corollary 3 in [1]). Every zero trace matrix $A \in M_n(\mathbb{C})$ may be written as $A=[B,C]$ such that $\|B\|$, $\|C\| \le K\log^2(n)\|A\|$ for some universal constant $K$.

[1]. M. Ravichandran and N. Srivastava. Asymptotically Optimal Multi-Paving. arXiv. Jun 2017.

Source Link
Suvrit
  • 28.6k
  • 7
  • 82
  • 150

In a recent paper ([1]), Ravichandran and Srivastava study pavings for collections of matrices. Their main theorem yields an improvement to the bound obtained by Johnson, Ozawa, and Schechtman (noted in Bill Johnson's answer above). In particular, Ravichandran and Srivastava's work implies the following:

Corollary (Corollary 3 in [1]). Every zero trace matrix $A \in M_n(\mathbb{C})$ may be written as $A=[B,C]$ such that $\|B\|$, $\|C\| \le K\log^2(n)\|A\|$ for some universal constant $K$.

[1]. M. Ravichandran and N. Srivastava. Asymptotically Optimal Multi-Paving. arXiv. Jun 2017.