Skip to main content
replaced http://mathoverflow.net/ with https://mathoverflow.net/
Source Link

The question directly asked, the density of the reciprocal of the squares, remains unanswered. Paul Monsky has introduced a new (to me, at least) approach, and has made striking progress both in the answer below and in his answer to this questionthis question.

The question directly asked, the density of the reciprocal of the squares, remains unanswered. Paul Monsky has introduced a new (to me, at least) approach, and has made striking progress both in the answer below and in his answer to this question.

The question directly asked, the density of the reciprocal of the squares, remains unanswered. Paul Monsky has introduced a new (to me, at least) approach, and has made striking progress both in the answer below and in his answer to this question.

added 9 characters in body
Source Link
Tom Goodwillie
  • 55.9k
  • 7
  • 151
  • 240

There is a unique nonempty set $B$ of nonnegative integers such that every positive integer can be written in the form $$b + s^2, b\in B, s\ge0$$ in an even number of ways.

There is a unique set $B$ of nonnegative integers such that every positive integer can be written in the form $$b + s^2, b\in B, s\ge0$$ in an even number of ways.

There is a unique nonempty set $B$ of nonnegative integers such that every positive integer can be written in the form $$b + s^2, b\in B, s\ge0$$ in an even number of ways.

added some more data
Source Link
Kevin O'Bryant
  • 9.8k
  • 6
  • 57
  • 84

Here are some computational counts of the number of elements of $B\cap[0,2^{23}]$ in particular congruence classes.

(1 mod 4, 371867), (3 mod 4, 760697)
(1 mod 8, 185336), (5 mod 8, 186531), (3 mod 8, 294045), (7 mod 8, 466652)
(1 mod 16, 92703), (5 mod 16, 93236), (9 mod 16, 92633), (13 mod 16, 93295),
(3 mod 16, 147232), (11 mod 16, 146813),
(7 mod 16, 204808), (15 mod 16, 261844)
(7 mod 32, 102487), (23 mod 32, 102321), 
(15 mod 32, 130895), (31 mod 32, 130949)

Since there was a specific request for 15 mod 32 data, here are the first 10 such numbers in $B$: (47,79,271,559,623,687,719,815,879,911). Here are the last 10 that I've computed: (8388539, 8388551, 8388559, 8388563, 8388567, 8388571, 8388581, 8388591, 8388593, 8388603, 8388607)

Here are some computational counts of the number of elements of $B\cap[0,2^{23}]$ in particular congruence classes.

(1 mod 4, 371867), (3 mod 4, 760697)
(1 mod 8, 185336), (5 mod 8, 186531), (3 mod 8, 294045), (7 mod 8, 466652)
(1 mod 16, 92703), (5 mod 16, 93236), (9 mod 16, 92633), (13 mod 16, 93295),
(3 mod 16, 147232), (11 mod 16, 146813),
(7 mod 16, 204808), (15 mod 16, 261844)
(7 mod 32, 102487), (23 mod 32, 102321), 
(15 mod 32, 130895), (31 mod 32, 130949)

Since there was a specific request for 15 mod 32 data, here are the first 10 such numbers in $B$: (47,79,271,559,623,687,719,815,879,911). Here are the last 10 that I've computed: (8388539, 8388551, 8388559, 8388563, 8388567, 8388571, 8388581, 8388591, 8388593, 8388603, 8388607)

Fixed statement of Conjecture, added "update" summarizing my opinion of the two posted answers
Source Link
Kevin O'Bryant
  • 9.8k
  • 6
  • 57
  • 84
Loading
restated problem for pithiness
Source Link
Kevin O'Bryant
  • 9.8k
  • 6
  • 57
  • 84
Loading
Source Link
Kevin O'Bryant
  • 9.8k
  • 6
  • 57
  • 84
Loading