Skip to main content
added 5 characters in body; added 1 characters in body; added 9 characters in body
Source Link

I will work over $\mathbb C$. Although I have not checked, the example below should work for characteristic different from $3$.

To exhibit a degree $d$ projective surface $S \subset \mathbb P^3$ not containing any line you can consider surfaces of the form $t^d = f(x,y,z)$ where $f$ is homogeneous polynomial of degree $d$.

Let $C \subset \mathbb P^2$ be the curve determined by the polynomial $f$ and $\pi: S \to \mathbb P^2$ be athe linear projection from athe point outside $p$. $p=[0:0:0:1]. $ If $\ell$ is a line contained in $S$ then $\pi(\ell)$ is a line tangent to $C$ at a total inflection point $q$, i.e. the contact between $C$ and the line $\pi(\ell)$ at $q$ is of order $d$. For details see Section 6 of Counting lines on surfaces by Boissière and Sarti.

This reduces the problem of finding a surface without lines to the one of finding an algebraic curve without total inflection points. For quartic curves we have not to look much, as Klein determined all the inflections of his famous quartic $$ x^3y + y^3 z+ z^3 x = 0. $$ All its $24$ inflection points are simple, see for instance Jeremy Gray's paper in The Eightfold Way: The Beauty of Klein's Quartic Curve. Thus the surface $$ t^4 - x^3 y - y^3 z - z^3 x =0 $$ has no invariant lines.

It should be possible to pursue this argument further to determine the sought examples.

Edit: The quartic surface above ( as any quartic of the form $\{ t^4- f(x,y,z)=0 \}$ ) has many conics, as the pre-image of a bitangent line (there are $28$) is the union of two conics. On the other hand, the surface $$ t^5 - x^4y - y^4 z - z^4 x =0 $$ seems to be a good candidate for a quintic without lines nor conics.

I will work over $\mathbb C$. Although I have not checked, the example below should work for characteristic different from $3$.

To exhibit a degree $d$ projective surface $S \subset \mathbb P^3$ not containing any line you can consider surfaces of the form $t^d = f(x,y,z)$ where $f$ is homogeneous polynomial of degree $d$.

Let $C \subset \mathbb P^2$ be the curve determined by the polynomial $f$ and $\pi: S \to \mathbb P^2$ be a projection from a point outside $p$. If $\ell$ is a line contained in $S$ then $\pi(\ell)$ is a line tangent to $C$ at a total inflection point $q$, i.e. the contact between $C$ and the line $\pi(\ell)$ at $q$ is of order $d$. For details see Section 6 of Counting lines on surfaces by Boissière and Sarti.

This reduces the problem of finding a surface without lines to the one of finding an algebraic curve without total inflection points. For quartic curves we have not to look much, as Klein determined all the inflections of his famous quartic $$ x^3y + y^3 z+ z^3 x = 0. $$ All its $24$ inflection points are simple, see for instance Jeremy Gray's paper in The Eightfold Way: The Beauty of Klein's Quartic Curve. Thus the surface $$ t^4 - x^3 y - y^3 z - z^3 x =0 $$ has no invariant lines.

It should be possible to pursue this argument further to determine the sought examples.

Edit: The quartic surface above ( as any quartic of the form $\{ t^4- f(x,y,z)=0 \}$ ) has many conics, as the pre-image of a bitangent line (there are $28$) is the union of two conics. On the other hand, the surface $$ t^5 - x^4y - y^4 z - z^4 x =0 $$ seems to be a good candidate for a quintic without lines nor conics.

I will work over $\mathbb C$. Although I have not checked, the example below should work for characteristic different from $3$.

To exhibit a degree $d$ projective surface $S \subset \mathbb P^3$ not containing any line you can consider surfaces of the form $t^d = f(x,y,z)$ where $f$ is homogeneous polynomial of degree $d$.

Let $C \subset \mathbb P^2$ be the curve determined by the polynomial $f$ and $\pi: S \to \mathbb P^2$ be the linear projection from the point $p=[0:0:0:1]. $ If $\ell$ is a line contained in $S$ then $\pi(\ell)$ is a line tangent to $C$ at a total inflection point $q$, i.e. the contact between $C$ and the line $\pi(\ell)$ at $q$ is of order $d$. For details see Section 6 of Counting lines on surfaces by Boissière and Sarti.

This reduces the problem of finding a surface without lines to the one of finding an algebraic curve without total inflection points. For quartic curves we have not to look much, as Klein determined all the inflections of his famous quartic $$ x^3y + y^3 z+ z^3 x = 0. $$ All its $24$ inflection points are simple, see for instance Jeremy Gray's paper in The Eightfold Way: The Beauty of Klein's Quartic Curve. Thus the surface $$ t^4 - x^3 y - y^3 z - z^3 x =0 $$ has no invariant lines.

It should be possible to pursue this argument further to determine the sought examples.

Edit: The quartic surface above ( as any quartic of the form $\{ t^4- f(x,y,z)=0 \}$ ) has many conics, as the pre-image of a bitangent line (there are $28$) is the union of two conics. On the other hand, the surface $$ t^5 - x^4y - y^4 z - z^4 x =0 $$ seems to be a good candidate for a quintic without lines nor conics.

added 286 characters in body; added 57 characters in body; deleted 2 characters in body
Source Link

I will work over $\mathbb C$. Although I have not checked, the example below should work for characteristic different from $3$.

To exhibit a degree $d$ projective surface $S \subset \mathbb P^3$ not containing any line you can consider surfaces of the form $t^d = f(x,y,z)$ where $f$ is homogeneous polynomial of degree $d$.

Let $C \subset \mathbb P^2$ be the curve determined by the polynomial $f$ and $\pi: S \to \mathbb P^2$ be a projection from a point outside $p$. If $\ell$ is a line contained in $S$ then $\pi(\ell)$ is a line tangent to $C$ at a total inflection point $q$, i.e. the contact between $C$ and the line $\pi(\ell)$ at $q$ is of order $d$. For details see Section 6 of Counting lines on surfaces by Boissière and Sarti.

This reduces the problem of finding a surface without lines to the one of finding an algebraic curve without total inflection points. For quartic curves we have not to look much, as Klein determined all the inflections of his famous quartic $$ x^3y + y^3 z+ z^3 x = 0. $$ All its $24$ inflection points are simple, see for instance Jeremy Gray's paper in The Eightfold Way: The Beauty of Klein's Quartic Curve. Thus the surface $$ t^4 - x^3 y - y^3 z - z^3 x =0 $$ has no invariant lines.

It should be possible to pursue this argument further to determine the sought examples.

Edit: The quartic surface above ( as any quartic of the form $\{ t^4- f(x,y,z)=0 \}$ ) has many conics, as the pre-image of a bitangent line (there are $28$) is the union of two conics. On the other hand, the surface $$ t^5 - x^4y - y^4 z - z^4 x =0 $$ seems to be a good candidate for a quintic without lines nor conics.

I will work over $\mathbb C$. Although I have not checked, the example below should work for characteristic different from $3$.

To exhibit a degree $d$ projective surface $S \subset \mathbb P^3$ not containing any line you can consider surfaces of the form $t^d = f(x,y,z)$ where $f$ is homogeneous polynomial of degree $d$.

Let $C \subset \mathbb P^2$ be the curve determined by the polynomial $f$ and $\pi: S \to \mathbb P^2$ be a projection from a point outside $p$. If $\ell$ is a line contained in $S$ then $\pi(\ell)$ is a line tangent to $C$ at a total inflection point $q$, i.e. the contact between $C$ and the line $\pi(\ell)$ at $q$ is of order $d$. For details see Section 6 of Counting lines on surfaces by Boissière and Sarti.

This reduces the problem of finding a surface without lines to the one of finding an algebraic curve without total inflection points. For quartic curves we have not to look much, as Klein determined all the inflections of his famous quartic $$ x^3y + y^3 z+ z^3 x = 0. $$ All its $24$ inflection points are simple, see for instance Jeremy Gray's paper in The Eightfold Way: The Beauty of Klein's Quartic Curve. Thus the surface $$ t^4 - x^3 y - y^3 z - z^3 x =0 $$ has no invariant lines.

It should be possible to pursue this argument further to determine the sought examples.

I will work over $\mathbb C$. Although I have not checked, the example below should work for characteristic different from $3$.

To exhibit a degree $d$ projective surface $S \subset \mathbb P^3$ not containing any line you can consider surfaces of the form $t^d = f(x,y,z)$ where $f$ is homogeneous polynomial of degree $d$.

Let $C \subset \mathbb P^2$ be the curve determined by the polynomial $f$ and $\pi: S \to \mathbb P^2$ be a projection from a point outside $p$. If $\ell$ is a line contained in $S$ then $\pi(\ell)$ is a line tangent to $C$ at a total inflection point $q$, i.e. the contact between $C$ and the line $\pi(\ell)$ at $q$ is of order $d$. For details see Section 6 of Counting lines on surfaces by Boissière and Sarti.

This reduces the problem of finding a surface without lines to the one of finding an algebraic curve without total inflection points. For quartic curves we have not to look much, as Klein determined all the inflections of his famous quartic $$ x^3y + y^3 z+ z^3 x = 0. $$ All its $24$ inflection points are simple, see for instance Jeremy Gray's paper in The Eightfold Way: The Beauty of Klein's Quartic Curve. Thus the surface $$ t^4 - x^3 y - y^3 z - z^3 x =0 $$ has no invariant lines.

It should be possible to pursue this argument further to determine the sought examples.

Edit: The quartic surface above ( as any quartic of the form $\{ t^4- f(x,y,z)=0 \}$ ) has many conics, as the pre-image of a bitangent line (there are $28$) is the union of two conics. On the other hand, the surface $$ t^5 - x^4y - y^4 z - z^4 x =0 $$ seems to be a good candidate for a quintic without lines nor conics.

added 92 characters in body
Source Link

I will work over $\mathbb C$. Although I have not checked, the example below should work for characteristic different from $3$.

To exhibit a degree $d$ projective surface $S \subset \mathbb P^3$ not containing any line you can consider surfaces of the form $t^d = f(x,y,z)$ where $f$ is homogeneous polynomial of degree $d$.

Let $C \subset \mathbb P^2$ be the curve determined by the polynomial $f$ and $\pi: S \to \mathbb P^2$ be a projection from a point outside $p$. If $\ell$ is a line contained in $S$ then $\pi(\ell)$ is a line tangent to $C$ at a total inflection point $q$, i.e. the contact between $C$ and the line $\pi(\ell)$ at $q$ is of order $d$. For details see Section 6 of Counting lines on surfaces by Boissière and Sarti.

This reduces the problem of finding a surface without lines to the one of finding an algebraic curve without total inflection points. For quartic curves we have not to look much, as Klein determined all the inflections of his famous quartic $$ x^3y + y^3 z+ z^3 x = 0. $$ All its $24$ inflection points are simple, see for instance Jeremy Gray's paper in The Eightfold Way: The Beauty of Klein's Quartic Curve. Thus the surface $$ t^4 - x^3 y - y^3 z - z^3 x =0 $$ has no invariant lines.

It should be possible to pursue this argument further to determine the sought examples.

I will work over $\mathbb C$. Although I have not checked, the example below should work for characteristic different from $3$.

To exhibit a degree $d$ projective surface $S \subset \mathbb P^3$ not containing any line you can consider surfaces of the form $t^d = f(x,y,z)$ where $f$ is homogeneous polynomial of degree $d$.

Let $C \subset \mathbb P^2$ be the curve determined by the polynomial $f$ and $\pi: S \to \mathbb P^2$ be a projection from a point outside $p$. If $\ell$ is a line contained in $S$ then $\pi(\ell)$ is a line tangent to $C$ at a total inflection point $q$, i.e. the contact between $C$ and the line $\pi(\ell)$ at $q$ is of order $d$. For details see Section 6 of Counting lines on surfaces by Boissière and Sarti.

This reduces the problem of finding a surface without lines to the one of finding an algebraic curve without total inflection points. For quartic curves we have not to look much, as Klein determined all the inflections of his famous quartic $$ x^3y + y^3 z+ z^3 x = 0. $$ All its $24$ inflection points are simple, see for instance Jeremy Gray's paper in The Eightfold Way: The Beauty of Klein's Quartic Curve. Thus the surface $$ t^4 - x^3 y - y^3 z - z^3 x =0 $$ has no invariant lines.

I will work over $\mathbb C$. Although I have not checked, the example below should work for characteristic different from $3$.

To exhibit a degree $d$ projective surface $S \subset \mathbb P^3$ not containing any line you can consider surfaces of the form $t^d = f(x,y,z)$ where $f$ is homogeneous polynomial of degree $d$.

Let $C \subset \mathbb P^2$ be the curve determined by the polynomial $f$ and $\pi: S \to \mathbb P^2$ be a projection from a point outside $p$. If $\ell$ is a line contained in $S$ then $\pi(\ell)$ is a line tangent to $C$ at a total inflection point $q$, i.e. the contact between $C$ and the line $\pi(\ell)$ at $q$ is of order $d$. For details see Section 6 of Counting lines on surfaces by Boissière and Sarti.

This reduces the problem of finding a surface without lines to the one of finding an algebraic curve without total inflection points. For quartic curves we have not to look much, as Klein determined all the inflections of his famous quartic $$ x^3y + y^3 z+ z^3 x = 0. $$ All its $24$ inflection points are simple, see for instance Jeremy Gray's paper in The Eightfold Way: The Beauty of Klein's Quartic Curve. Thus the surface $$ t^4 - x^3 y - y^3 z - z^3 x =0 $$ has no invariant lines.

It should be possible to pursue this argument further to determine the sought examples.

deleted 5 characters in body
Source Link
Loading
Source Link
Loading