Skip to main content
added 2768 characters in body
Source Link
Vinteuil
  • 754
  • 3
  • 11

Q3Edit. Finally the proof was not so long, so I include it complete:

Question 3. Embedding codimension (sometimes simply codimension).

Q1. Edit: Yes when $R$ is complete: choose a regular local ring $S$ with the same embedding dimension of $R$ such that $R=S/I$ and localize. I don't know in generalQuestion 1. I don't have access here to "Lech, Inequalities related to certain couples of local rings, Acta math. 112 (1964), 69-89", but maybe that paper will answer it better, I can't remember. However, here is a proof when $A$ is quasi-excellent:

Q2Notation: dim = Krull dimension, edim = embedding dimension, codim = edim - dim = embedding codimension.

Lemma 1. Let $(A,m) \to (B,n)$ be a flat homomorphism of noetherian local rings. Then dim $A$ + dim $B/mB$ = dim $B$.

Lemma 2. Let $(A,m) \to (B,n)$ be a flat homomorphism of noetherian local rings with regular closed fiber $B/mB$. Then edim $A$ + edim $B/mB$ = edim $B$.

Deduction of Lemma 2 from Andre-Quillen homology (references (x.y) are to Result y from Chapter x in Andre, Homologie des algebres commutatives, Springer, 1974): let $f:(A,m,k) \to (B,n,l)$ be a flat homomorphism of noetherian local rings with regular closed fiber. Let $p=n/mB$ be the maximal ideal of $B/mB$. It is sufficient to prove that we have an exact sequence of $l$-vector spaces $$0 \to m/m^2 \otimes_k l \to n/n^2 \to p/p^2 \to 0.$$ But this exact sequence is a part of the Jacobi -Zariski exact sequence in Andre-Quillen homology (5.1) associated to $B \to B/mB \to l$: $$H_2(B/mB,l,l) \to H_1(B,B/mB,l) \to H_1(B,l,l) \to H_1(B/mB,l,l) \to H_0(B,B/mB,l).$$

$H_2(B/mB,l,l)=0$ since $B/mB$ is regular by (6.26).

$H_1(B,B/mB,l)=H_1(A,k,l)= m/m^2 \otimes_k l$ by (4.54) (since $f$ is flat) and (6.1) respectively.

$H_1(B,l,l)= n/n^2$, and $H_1(B/mB,l,l)= p/p^2$ by (6.1).

$H_0(B,B/mB,l)=0$ by (4.60).

Another proof without Andre-Quillen homology can be found in arXiv:1205.2119v3, Lemma 3.1.

Corollary 3. Let $(A,m) \to (B,n)$ be a flat homomorphism of noetherian local rings with regular closed fiber. Then codim $A$ + codim $B/mB$ = codim $B$. In particular, codim $A \leq $ codim $B$. Another (trivial) particular case is codim $A$ = codim $\hat{A}$.

Definition. We say that a noetherian local ring is a G-ring if the completion homomorphism $A \to \hat{A}$ is regular. By Matsumura, Commutative Algebra, (33.C) Theorem 75 page 251 this is equivalent to the usual definition of G-ring, and by Theorems, 73, 76 and 77 this is also equivalent to be quasi-excellent (since it is local).

Corollary 4. Let $A$ be a local G-ring. Then for any prime ideal $p$ of $A$ we have codim $A_p \leq $ codim $A$.

Proof. The result is valid for a complete ring $A$ (choose a regular local ring $S$ with the same embedding dimension of $A$ such that $A=S/I$ and localize), so codim $\hat{A}_q \leq $ codim $\hat{A}$ = codim $A$. Since $A \to \hat{A}$ is faithfully flat, there exists a prime ideal $q$ of $\hat{A}$ contracting to $p$. The local homomorphism $A_p \to \hat{A}_q$ is regular and so by Corollary 3 codim $A_p \leq $ codim $\hat{A}_q$.

Question 2.

For excellent rings. An indirect proof, but short enough to be written here, is as follows. Embedding dimension is the diference between the invariant $\delta_2$ in "Ragusa, On Opennes ..." which is upper semicontinuous by Proposition 3.6 in that paper, and the complete intersection defect which is upper semicontinuous by the main theorem in "Alonso-Rodicio, On the upper ...". So for each $n$ the set of primes $p$ such that codim $A_p > n$ is constructibe. By Corollary 4 it is also stable under specialization. So by Matsumura, Commutative Algebra, (6.G) Lemma, page 46, it is closed.

Q3. Embedding codimension (sometimes simply codimension).

Q1. Edit: Yes when $R$ is complete: choose a regular local ring $S$ with the same embedding dimension of $R$ such that $R=S/I$ and localize. I don't know in general. I don't have access here to "Lech, Inequalities related to certain couples of local rings, Acta math. 112 (1964), 69-89", but maybe that paper will answer it, I can't remember.

Q2. For excellent rings. An indirect proof, but short enough to be written here, is as follows. Embedding dimension is the diference between the invariant $\delta_2$ in "Ragusa, On Opennes ..." which is upper semicontinuous by Proposition 3.6 in that paper, and the complete intersection defect which is upper semicontinuous by the main theorem in "Alonso-Rodicio, On the upper ...".

Edit. Finally the proof was not so long, so I include it complete:

Question 3. Embedding codimension (sometimes simply codimension).

Question 1. I don't have access here to "Lech, Inequalities related to certain couples of local rings, Acta math. 112 (1964), 69-89", but maybe that paper will answer it better, I can't remember. However, here is a proof when $A$ is quasi-excellent:

Notation: dim = Krull dimension, edim = embedding dimension, codim = edim - dim = embedding codimension.

Lemma 1. Let $(A,m) \to (B,n)$ be a flat homomorphism of noetherian local rings. Then dim $A$ + dim $B/mB$ = dim $B$.

Lemma 2. Let $(A,m) \to (B,n)$ be a flat homomorphism of noetherian local rings with regular closed fiber $B/mB$. Then edim $A$ + edim $B/mB$ = edim $B$.

Deduction of Lemma 2 from Andre-Quillen homology (references (x.y) are to Result y from Chapter x in Andre, Homologie des algebres commutatives, Springer, 1974): let $f:(A,m,k) \to (B,n,l)$ be a flat homomorphism of noetherian local rings with regular closed fiber. Let $p=n/mB$ be the maximal ideal of $B/mB$. It is sufficient to prove that we have an exact sequence of $l$-vector spaces $$0 \to m/m^2 \otimes_k l \to n/n^2 \to p/p^2 \to 0.$$ But this exact sequence is a part of the Jacobi -Zariski exact sequence in Andre-Quillen homology (5.1) associated to $B \to B/mB \to l$: $$H_2(B/mB,l,l) \to H_1(B,B/mB,l) \to H_1(B,l,l) \to H_1(B/mB,l,l) \to H_0(B,B/mB,l).$$

$H_2(B/mB,l,l)=0$ since $B/mB$ is regular by (6.26).

$H_1(B,B/mB,l)=H_1(A,k,l)= m/m^2 \otimes_k l$ by (4.54) (since $f$ is flat) and (6.1) respectively.

$H_1(B,l,l)= n/n^2$, and $H_1(B/mB,l,l)= p/p^2$ by (6.1).

$H_0(B,B/mB,l)=0$ by (4.60).

Another proof without Andre-Quillen homology can be found in arXiv:1205.2119v3, Lemma 3.1.

Corollary 3. Let $(A,m) \to (B,n)$ be a flat homomorphism of noetherian local rings with regular closed fiber. Then codim $A$ + codim $B/mB$ = codim $B$. In particular, codim $A \leq $ codim $B$. Another (trivial) particular case is codim $A$ = codim $\hat{A}$.

Definition. We say that a noetherian local ring is a G-ring if the completion homomorphism $A \to \hat{A}$ is regular. By Matsumura, Commutative Algebra, (33.C) Theorem 75 page 251 this is equivalent to the usual definition of G-ring, and by Theorems, 73, 76 and 77 this is also equivalent to be quasi-excellent (since it is local).

Corollary 4. Let $A$ be a local G-ring. Then for any prime ideal $p$ of $A$ we have codim $A_p \leq $ codim $A$.

Proof. The result is valid for a complete ring $A$ (choose a regular local ring $S$ with the same embedding dimension of $A$ such that $A=S/I$ and localize), so codim $\hat{A}_q \leq $ codim $\hat{A}$ = codim $A$. Since $A \to \hat{A}$ is faithfully flat, there exists a prime ideal $q$ of $\hat{A}$ contracting to $p$. The local homomorphism $A_p \to \hat{A}_q$ is regular and so by Corollary 3 codim $A_p \leq $ codim $\hat{A}_q$.

Question 2.

For excellent rings. An indirect proof, but short enough to be written here, is as follows. Embedding dimension is the diference between the invariant $\delta_2$ in "Ragusa, On Opennes ..." which is upper semicontinuous by Proposition 3.6 in that paper, and the complete intersection defect which is upper semicontinuous by the main theorem in "Alonso-Rodicio, On the upper ...". So for each $n$ the set of primes $p$ such that codim $A_p > n$ is constructibe. By Corollary 4 it is also stable under specialization. So by Matsumura, Commutative Algebra, (6.G) Lemma, page 46, it is closed.

added 177 characters in body
Source Link
Vinteuil
  • 754
  • 3
  • 11

Q3. Embedding codimension (sometimes simply codimension).

Q1. Edit: Yes when $R$ is complete: choose a regular local ring $S$ with the same embedding dimension of $R$ such that $R=S/I$ and localize. I don't know in general. I don't have access here to "Lech, Inequalities related to certain couples of local rings, Acta math. 112 (1964), 69-89", but maybe that paper will answer it, I can't remember.

Q2. For excellent rings. An indirect proof, but short enough to be written here, is as follows. Embedding dimension is the diference between the invariant $\delta_2$ in "Ragusa, On Opennes ..." which is upper semicontinuous by Proposition 3.6 in that paper, and the complete intersection defect which is upper semicontinuous by the main theorem in "Alonso-Rodicio, On the upper ...".

Q3. Embedding codimension (sometimes simply codimension).

Q1. Edit: Yes when $R$ is complete: choose a regular local ring $S$ with the same embedding dimension of $R$ such that $R=S/I$ and localize. I don't know in general.

Q2. For excellent rings. An indirect proof, but short enough to be written here, is as follows. Embedding dimension is the diference between the invariant $\delta_2$ in "Ragusa, On Opennes ..." which is upper semicontinuous by Proposition 3.6 in that paper, and the complete intersection defect which is upper semicontinuous by the main theorem in "Alonso-Rodicio, On the upper ...".

Q3. Embedding codimension (sometimes simply codimension).

Q1. Edit: Yes when $R$ is complete: choose a regular local ring $S$ with the same embedding dimension of $R$ such that $R=S/I$ and localize. I don't know in general. I don't have access here to "Lech, Inequalities related to certain couples of local rings, Acta math. 112 (1964), 69-89", but maybe that paper will answer it, I can't remember.

Q2. For excellent rings. An indirect proof, but short enough to be written here, is as follows. Embedding dimension is the diference between the invariant $\delta_2$ in "Ragusa, On Opennes ..." which is upper semicontinuous by Proposition 3.6 in that paper, and the complete intersection defect which is upper semicontinuous by the main theorem in "Alonso-Rodicio, On the upper ...".

added 109 characters in body
Source Link
Vinteuil
  • 754
  • 3
  • 11

Q3. Embedding codimension (sometimes simply codimension).

Q1. Edit: Yes when $R$ is complete: choose a regular local ring $S$ with the same embedding dimension of $R$ such that $R=S/I$ and localize. I think yes, but please let me find some timedon't know in general.

Q2. For excellent rings. An indirect proof, but short enough to be written here, is as follows. Embedding dimension is the diference between the invariant $\delta_2$ in "Ragusa, On Opennes ..." which is upper semicontinuous by Proposition 3.6 in that paper, and the complete intersection defect which is upper semicontinuous by the main theorem in "Alonso-Rodicio, On the upper ...".

Q3. Embedding codimension (sometimes simply codimension).

Q1. Edit: I think yes, but please let me find some time.

Q2. For excellent rings. An indirect proof, but short enough to be written here, is as follows. Embedding dimension is the diference between the invariant $\delta_2$ in "Ragusa, On Opennes ..." which is upper semicontinuous by Proposition 3.6 in that paper, and the complete intersection defect which is upper semicontinuous by the main theorem in "Alonso-Rodicio, On the upper ...".

Q3. Embedding codimension (sometimes simply codimension).

Q1. Edit: Yes when $R$ is complete: choose a regular local ring $S$ with the same embedding dimension of $R$ such that $R=S/I$ and localize. I don't know in general.

Q2. For excellent rings. An indirect proof, but short enough to be written here, is as follows. Embedding dimension is the diference between the invariant $\delta_2$ in "Ragusa, On Opennes ..." which is upper semicontinuous by Proposition 3.6 in that paper, and the complete intersection defect which is upper semicontinuous by the main theorem in "Alonso-Rodicio, On the upper ...".

deleted 161 characters in body
Source Link
Vinteuil
  • 754
  • 3
  • 11
Loading
Source Link
Vinteuil
  • 754
  • 3
  • 11
Loading