Skip to main content
improved clarity
Source Link
Igor Rivin
  • 96.4k
  • 11
  • 153
  • 366

This is already sort of in the comments, but just to say it clearly:

In the paper Enumerating Finite Groups of Given Order Author(s): L. Pyber Source: Annals of Mathematics, Second Series, Vol. 137, No. 1 (Jan., 1993), pp. 203-220

Pyber proves that the number of subgroups of $S_n$ is bounded below by $2^{(1/16 + o(1))n^2}.$ He shows this by noting that $S_n$ contains $C_2^{[\frac{n}2]},$ and the latter has the specified number of subgroups. He then conjectures that the lower bound is, in fact, sharp. In other words, modulo this conjecture, at least morally, the maximalmaximally present order of a subgroup is, indeed, a power of two, and the actual power of two is presumably $2^{[[\frac{n}2]/2]}.$ It seems that Pyber's conjecture is still open.

This is already sort of in the comments, but just to say it clearly:

In the paper Enumerating Finite Groups of Given Order Author(s): L. Pyber Source: Annals of Mathematics, Second Series, Vol. 137, No. 1 (Jan., 1993), pp. 203-220

Pyber proves that the number of subgroups of $S_n$ is bounded below by $2^{(1/16 + o(1))n^2}.$ He shows this by noting that $S_n$ contains $C_2^{[\frac{n}2]},$ and the latter has the specified number of subgroups. He then conjectures that the lower bound is, in fact, sharp. In other words, modulo this conjecture, at least morally, the maximal order of a subgroup is, indeed, a power of two, and the actual power of two is presumably $2^{[[\frac{n}2]/2]}.$ It seems that Pyber's conjecture is still open.

This is already sort of in the comments, but just to say it clearly:

In the paper Enumerating Finite Groups of Given Order Author(s): L. Pyber Source: Annals of Mathematics, Second Series, Vol. 137, No. 1 (Jan., 1993), pp. 203-220

Pyber proves that the number of subgroups of $S_n$ is bounded below by $2^{(1/16 + o(1))n^2}.$ He shows this by noting that $S_n$ contains $C_2^{[\frac{n}2]},$ and the latter has the specified number of subgroups. He then conjectures that the lower bound is, in fact, sharp. In other words, modulo this conjecture, at least morally, the maximally present order of a subgroup is, indeed, a power of two, and the actual power of two is presumably $2^{[[\frac{n}2]/2]}.$ It seems that Pyber's conjecture is still open.

fixed typo
Source Link
Igor Rivin
  • 96.4k
  • 11
  • 153
  • 366

This is already sort of in the comments, but just to say it clearly:

In the paper Enumerating Finite Groups of Given Order Author(s): L. Pyber Source: Annals of Mathematics, Second Series, Vol. 137, No. 1 (Jan., 1993), pp. 203-220

Pyber proves that the number of subgroups of $S_n$ is bounded below by $2^{(1/16 + o(1))n^2}.$ He shows this by noting that $S_n$ contains $C_2^{[\frac{n}2]},$ and the latter has the specified number of subgroups. He then conjectures that the lower bound is, in fact, sharp. In other words, modulo this conjecture, at least morallythemorally, the maximal order of a subgroup is, indeed, a power of two, and the actual power of two is presumably $2^{[[\frac{n}2]/2]}.$ It seems that Pyber's conjecture is still open.

This is already sort of in the comments, but just to say it clearly:

In the paper Enumerating Finite Groups of Given Order Author(s): L. Pyber Source: Annals of Mathematics, Second Series, Vol. 137, No. 1 (Jan., 1993), pp. 203-220

Pyber proves that the number of subgroups of $S_n$ is bounded below by $2^{(1/16 + o(1))n^2}.$ He shows this by noting that $S_n$ contains $C_2^{[\frac{n}2]},$ and the latter has the specified number of subgroups. He then conjectures that the lower bound is, in fact, sharp. In other words, modulo this conjecture, at least morallythe maximal order of a subgroup is, indeed, a power of two, and the actual power of two is presumably $2^{[[\frac{n}2]/2]}.$ It seems that Pyber's conjecture is still open.

This is already sort of in the comments, but just to say it clearly:

In the paper Enumerating Finite Groups of Given Order Author(s): L. Pyber Source: Annals of Mathematics, Second Series, Vol. 137, No. 1 (Jan., 1993), pp. 203-220

Pyber proves that the number of subgroups of $S_n$ is bounded below by $2^{(1/16 + o(1))n^2}.$ He shows this by noting that $S_n$ contains $C_2^{[\frac{n}2]},$ and the latter has the specified number of subgroups. He then conjectures that the lower bound is, in fact, sharp. In other words, modulo this conjecture, at least morally, the maximal order of a subgroup is, indeed, a power of two, and the actual power of two is presumably $2^{[[\frac{n}2]/2]}.$ It seems that Pyber's conjecture is still open.

Source Link
Igor Rivin
  • 96.4k
  • 11
  • 153
  • 366

This is already sort of in the comments, but just to say it clearly:

In the paper Enumerating Finite Groups of Given Order Author(s): L. Pyber Source: Annals of Mathematics, Second Series, Vol. 137, No. 1 (Jan., 1993), pp. 203-220

Pyber proves that the number of subgroups of $S_n$ is bounded below by $2^{(1/16 + o(1))n^2}.$ He shows this by noting that $S_n$ contains $C_2^{[\frac{n}2]},$ and the latter has the specified number of subgroups. He then conjectures that the lower bound is, in fact, sharp. In other words, modulo this conjecture, at least morallythe maximal order of a subgroup is, indeed, a power of two, and the actual power of two is presumably $2^{[[\frac{n}2]/2]}.$ It seems that Pyber's conjecture is still open.