Skip to main content
Bumped by Community user
Bumped by Community user
Bumped by Community user
Bumped by Community user
Bumped by Community user
Bumped by Community user
Bumped by Community user
Bumped by Community user
Bumped by Community user
Bumped by Community user
Bumped by Community user
Bumped by Community user
Bumped by Community user
Bumped by Community user
Bumped by Community user
Bumped by Community user
Bumped by Community user
Bumped by Community user
Bumped by Community user
Bumped by Community user

Fix sets $T_1,\ldots T_m$ as a $k$-partition of $[m\cdot k]=\{1,2,\ldots,m\cdot k\}$, so that $|T_i|=k$ and $|T_i\cap T_\ell|=0$.

  1. For any $j\le k$, how many sets $C\subset [m\cdot k]$ are there such that $|C|=k$ and $\max_{i}|T_i\cap C| = j$? Call this number $n(m,k,j)$ and call $N(m,k,j)$ the cumulative version where $\max_{i}|T_i\cap C| \le j$ $N(m,k,j)$.

  2. More generally, how many sets of the form $\{C_1,\ldots,C_m\}$ are there such that $C_1,\ldots,C_m$ is a $k$-partition of $[k\cdot m]$ where $\max_{i,\ell} |T_i\cap C_\ell| = j$?

Are asymptotic answers known/obvious for either of these two questions?

Note for the first question, an exact but clunky formula is given by the recursion: $$N(m,k,j) = \begin{cases} 0 & j < k/m \\ \binom{m}{k}k^k & j=1\text{ and }m\ge k\\ \sum_{i=0}^{\left\lfloor\frac{k}{j}\right\rfloor} \binom{m}{i} \binom{k}{j}^i N(m-i,k-ji,j-1) & \text{ otherwise} \end{cases}$$ (Choose the $T_i$'s that get exactly $j$ elements of $C$, then the locations of the $j$ elements in each of the chosen $T_i$'s, then choose the rest.)

In addition, the probability that a (uniformly) random set will have intersection more than the mean $k/m$ can be lower-bounded by choosing each element of $C$ independently, then using Chernoff and union bounds: $P[\max_i(T_i\cap C)-k/m > t] \le k e^{-2t^2/k}$. Then $$N(m,k,j) \ge N(m,k,k)(1-k e^{-2(j-\frac{k}{m})^2/k}).$$ A similar result can be shown for the second problem as well. Is this bound asymptotically tight?

Fix sets $T_1,\ldots T_m$ as a $k$-partition of $[m\cdot k]=\{1,2,\ldots,m\cdot k\}$, so that $|T_i|=k$ and $|T_i\cap T_\ell|=0$.

  1. For any $j\le k$, how many sets $C\subset [m\cdot k]$ are there such that $|C|=k$ and $\max_{i}|T_i\cap C| = j$? Call this number $n(m,k,j)$ and the cumulative version where $\max_{i}|T_i\cap C| \le j$ $N(m,k,j)$.

  2. More generally, how many sets of the form $\{C_1,\ldots,C_m\}$ are there such that $C_1,\ldots,C_m$ is a $k$-partition of $[k\cdot m]$ where $\max_{i,\ell} |T_i\cap C_\ell| = j$?

Are asymptotic answers known/obvious for either of these two questions?

Note for the first question, an exact but clunky formula is given by the recursion: $$N(m,k,j) = \begin{cases} 0 & j < k/m \\ \binom{m}{k}k^k & j=1\text{ and }m\ge k\\ \sum_{i=0}^{\left\lfloor\frac{k}{j}\right\rfloor} \binom{m}{i} \binom{k}{j}^i N(m-i,k-ji,j-1) & \text{ otherwise} \end{cases}$$ (Choose the $T_i$'s that get exactly $j$ elements of $C$, then the locations of the $j$ elements in each of the chosen $T_i$'s, then choose the rest.)

In addition, the probability that a (uniformly) random set will have intersection more than the mean $k/m$ can be lower-bounded by choosing each element of $C$ independently, then using Chernoff and union bounds: $P[\max_i(T_i\cap C)-k/m > t] \le k e^{-2t^2/k}$. Then $$N(m,k,j) \ge N(m,k,k)(1-k e^{-2(j-\frac{k}{m})^2/k}).$$ A similar result can be shown for the second problem as well. Is this bound asymptotically tight?

Fix sets $T_1,\ldots T_m$ as a $k$-partition of $[m\cdot k]=\{1,2,\ldots,m\cdot k\}$, so that $|T_i|=k$ and $|T_i\cap T_\ell|=0$.

  1. For any $j\le k$, how many sets $C\subset [m\cdot k]$ are there such that $|C|=k$ and $\max_{i}|T_i\cap C| = j$? Call this number $n(m,k,j)$ and call $N(m,k,j)$ the cumulative version where $\max_{i}|T_i\cap C| \le j$.

  2. More generally, how many sets of the form $\{C_1,\ldots,C_m\}$ are there such that $C_1,\ldots,C_m$ is a $k$-partition of $[k\cdot m]$ where $\max_{i,\ell} |T_i\cap C_\ell| = j$?

Are asymptotic answers known/obvious for either of these two questions?

Note for the first question, an exact but clunky formula is given by the recursion: $$N(m,k,j) = \begin{cases} 0 & j < k/m \\ \binom{m}{k}k^k & j=1\text{ and }m\ge k\\ \sum_{i=0}^{\left\lfloor\frac{k}{j}\right\rfloor} \binom{m}{i} \binom{k}{j}^i N(m-i,k-ji,j-1) & \text{ otherwise} \end{cases}$$ (Choose the $T_i$'s that get exactly $j$ elements of $C$, then the locations of the $j$ elements in each of the chosen $T_i$'s, then choose the rest.)

In addition, the probability that a (uniformly) random set will have intersection more than the mean $k/m$ can be lower-bounded by choosing each element of $C$ independently, then using Chernoff and union bounds: $P[\max_i(T_i\cap C)-k/m > t] \le k e^{-2t^2/k}$. Then $$N(m,k,j) \ge N(m,k,k)(1-k e^{-2(j-\frac{k}{m})^2/k}).$$ A similar result can be shown for the second problem as well. Is this bound asymptotically tight?

typo
Source Link

Fix sets $T_1,\ldots T_m$ as a $k$-partition of $[m\cdot k]=\{1,2,\ldots,m\cdot k\}$, so that $|T_i|=k$ and $|T_i\cap T_\ell|=0$.

  1. For any $j\le k$, how many sets $C\subset\{m\cdot k\}$$C\subset [m\cdot k]$ are there such that $|C|=k$ and $\max_{i}|T_i\cap C| = j$? Call this number $n(m,k,j)$ and the cumulative version where $\max_{i}|T_i\cap C| \le j$ $N(m,k,j)$.

  2. More generally, how many sets of the form $\{C_1,\ldots,C_m\}$ are there such that $C_1,\ldots,C_m$ is a $k$-partition of $[k\cdot m]$ where $\max_{i,\ell} |T_i\cap C_\ell| = j$?

Are asymptotic answers known/obvious for either of these two questions?

Note for the first question, an exact but clunky formula is given by the recursion: $$N(m,k,j) = \begin{cases} 0 & j < k/m \\ \binom{m}{k}k^k & j=1\text{ and }m\ge k\\ \sum_{i=0}^{\left\lfloor\frac{k}{j}\right\rfloor} \binom{m}{i} \binom{k}{j}^i N(m-i,k-ji,j-1) & \text{ otherwise} \end{cases}$$ (Choose the $T_i$'s that get exactly $j$ elements of $C$, then the locations of the $j$ elements in each of the chosen $T_i$'s, then choose the rest.)

In addition, the probability that a (uniformly) random set will have intersection more than the mean $k/m$ can be lower-bounded by choosing each element of $C$ independently, then using Chernoff and union bounds: $P[\max_i(T_i\cap C)-k/m > t] \le k e^{-2t^2/k}$. Then $$N(m,k,j) \ge N(m,k,k)(1-k e^{-2(j-\frac{k}{m})^2/k}).$$ A similar result can be shown for the second problem as well. Is this bound asymptotically tight?

Fix sets $T_1,\ldots T_m$ as a $k$-partition of $[m\cdot k]=\{1,2,\ldots,m\cdot k\}$, so that $|T_i|=k$ and $|T_i\cap T_\ell|=0$.

  1. For any $j\le k$, how many sets $C\subset\{m\cdot k\}$ are there such that $|C|=k$ and $\max_{i}|T_i\cap C| = j$? Call this number $n(m,k,j)$ and the cumulative version where $\max_{i}|T_i\cap C| \le j$ $N(m,k,j)$.

  2. More generally, how many sets of the form $\{C_1,\ldots,C_m\}$ are there such that $C_1,\ldots,C_m$ is a $k$-partition of $[k\cdot m]$ where $\max_{i,\ell} |T_i\cap C_\ell| = j$?

Are asymptotic answers known/obvious for either of these two questions?

Note for the first question, an exact but clunky formula is given by the recursion: $$N(m,k,j) = \begin{cases} 0 & j < k/m \\ \binom{m}{k}k^k & j=1\text{ and }m\ge k\\ \sum_{i=0}^{\left\lfloor\frac{k}{j}\right\rfloor} \binom{m}{i} \binom{k}{j}^i N(m-i,k-ji,j-1) & \text{ otherwise} \end{cases}$$ (Choose the $T_i$'s that get exactly $j$ elements of $C$, then the locations of the $j$ elements in each of the chosen $T_i$'s, then choose the rest.)

In addition, the probability that a (uniformly) random set will have intersection more than the mean $k/m$ can be lower-bounded by choosing each element of $C$ independently, then using Chernoff and union bounds: $P[\max_i(T_i\cap C)-k/m > t] \le k e^{-2t^2/k}$. Then $$N(m,k,j) \ge N(m,k,k)(1-k e^{-2(j-\frac{k}{m})^2/k}).$$ A similar result can be shown for the second problem as well. Is this bound asymptotically tight?

Fix sets $T_1,\ldots T_m$ as a $k$-partition of $[m\cdot k]=\{1,2,\ldots,m\cdot k\}$, so that $|T_i|=k$ and $|T_i\cap T_\ell|=0$.

  1. For any $j\le k$, how many sets $C\subset [m\cdot k]$ are there such that $|C|=k$ and $\max_{i}|T_i\cap C| = j$? Call this number $n(m,k,j)$ and the cumulative version where $\max_{i}|T_i\cap C| \le j$ $N(m,k,j)$.

  2. More generally, how many sets of the form $\{C_1,\ldots,C_m\}$ are there such that $C_1,\ldots,C_m$ is a $k$-partition of $[k\cdot m]$ where $\max_{i,\ell} |T_i\cap C_\ell| = j$?

Are asymptotic answers known/obvious for either of these two questions?

Note for the first question, an exact but clunky formula is given by the recursion: $$N(m,k,j) = \begin{cases} 0 & j < k/m \\ \binom{m}{k}k^k & j=1\text{ and }m\ge k\\ \sum_{i=0}^{\left\lfloor\frac{k}{j}\right\rfloor} \binom{m}{i} \binom{k}{j}^i N(m-i,k-ji,j-1) & \text{ otherwise} \end{cases}$$ (Choose the $T_i$'s that get exactly $j$ elements of $C$, then the locations of the $j$ elements in each of the chosen $T_i$'s, then choose the rest.)

In addition, the probability that a (uniformly) random set will have intersection more than the mean $k/m$ can be lower-bounded by choosing each element of $C$ independently, then using Chernoff and union bounds: $P[\max_i(T_i\cap C)-k/m > t] \le k e^{-2t^2/k}$. Then $$N(m,k,j) \ge N(m,k,k)(1-k e^{-2(j-\frac{k}{m})^2/k}).$$ A similar result can be shown for the second problem as well. Is this bound asymptotically tight?

Source Link

Set counting problem with a cap on the intersection between the set and a fixed partition

Fix sets $T_1,\ldots T_m$ as a $k$-partition of $[m\cdot k]=\{1,2,\ldots,m\cdot k\}$, so that $|T_i|=k$ and $|T_i\cap T_\ell|=0$.

  1. For any $j\le k$, how many sets $C\subset\{m\cdot k\}$ are there such that $|C|=k$ and $\max_{i}|T_i\cap C| = j$? Call this number $n(m,k,j)$ and the cumulative version where $\max_{i}|T_i\cap C| \le j$ $N(m,k,j)$.

  2. More generally, how many sets of the form $\{C_1,\ldots,C_m\}$ are there such that $C_1,\ldots,C_m$ is a $k$-partition of $[k\cdot m]$ where $\max_{i,\ell} |T_i\cap C_\ell| = j$?

Are asymptotic answers known/obvious for either of these two questions?

Note for the first question, an exact but clunky formula is given by the recursion: $$N(m,k,j) = \begin{cases} 0 & j < k/m \\ \binom{m}{k}k^k & j=1\text{ and }m\ge k\\ \sum_{i=0}^{\left\lfloor\frac{k}{j}\right\rfloor} \binom{m}{i} \binom{k}{j}^i N(m-i,k-ji,j-1) & \text{ otherwise} \end{cases}$$ (Choose the $T_i$'s that get exactly $j$ elements of $C$, then the locations of the $j$ elements in each of the chosen $T_i$'s, then choose the rest.)

In addition, the probability that a (uniformly) random set will have intersection more than the mean $k/m$ can be lower-bounded by choosing each element of $C$ independently, then using Chernoff and union bounds: $P[\max_i(T_i\cap C)-k/m > t] \le k e^{-2t^2/k}$. Then $$N(m,k,j) \ge N(m,k,k)(1-k e^{-2(j-\frac{k}{m})^2/k}).$$ A similar result can be shown for the second problem as well. Is this bound asymptotically tight?