Skip to main content
Notice removed Draw attention by CommunityBot
Bounty Ended with no winning answer by CommunityBot
Notice added Draw attention by Vladimir Reshetnikov
Bounty Started worth 250 reputation by Vladimir Reshetnikov
added 394 characters in body
Source Link

Let's say that a real number has a simple trigonometric representation, if it can be represented as a product of zero or more rational powers of prime numberspositive integers and zero or more (positive or negative) integer powers of $\sin(\cdot)$ at rational multiples of $\pi$ (the number of terms in the product is assumed to be finite, the empty product is taken to be $1$).

Examples:Examples:

  • $\sqrt[3]{\sin\!\left(\frac\pi3\right)}$ has a simple trigonometric representation, because $\sqrt[3]{\sin\!\left(\frac\pi3\right)}=\frac{3^{1/6}}{2^{1/3}}$.
  • $\sqrt{\sin\!\left(\frac\pi{10}\right)}$ has a simple trigonometric representation, because $\sqrt{\sin\!\left(\frac\pi{10}\right)}=\frac{2^{1/2}}{5^{1/4}}\,\sin\!\left(\frac\pi5\right)$.
  • $\pi$ does not have a simple trigonometric representation, because it is not an algebraic number.

Questions:Questions:

  • Do $\sqrt{\sin\!\left(\frac\pi5\right)},\,\sqrt{\sin\!\left(\frac\pi7\right)},\,\sqrt{\sin\!\left(\frac\pi{12}\right)},\,\sqrt{\sin\!\left(\frac\pi{15}\right)},\,\sqrt{\sin\!\left(\frac\pi{20}\right)},\,\sqrt{\sin\!\left(\frac\pi{21}\right)}$$\sqrt{\sin\!\left(\frac\pi5\right)},$ $\sqrt{\sin\!\left(\frac\pi8\right)},$ $\sqrt{\sin\!\left(\frac\pi{12}\right)},$ $\sqrt{\sin\!\left(\frac\pi{15}\right)},$ $\sqrt{\sin\!\left(\frac\pi{20}\right)},$ $\sqrt{\sin\!\left(\frac\pi{24}\right)}$ have a simple trigonometric representationrepresentations?
  • Is there an algorithm that, given a rational power of $\sin(\cdot)$ at a rational multiple of $\pi$, would determine if it has a simple trigonometric representation? If so, could you give (or outline) a concrete example of such an algorithm (efficient, if possible)?
  • More generally, is there an algorithm that, given a real algebraic number (in asome explicit form of, e.g. as its minimal polynomial and a rational isolating interval), would determine if it has a simple trigonometric representation? If so, could you give (or outline) a concrete example of such an algorithm (efficient, if possible)?

Let's say that a number has a simple trigonometric representation, if it can be represented as a product of zero or more rational powers of prime numbers and zero or more integer powers of $\sin(\cdot)$ at rational multiples of $\pi$.

Examples:

  • $\sqrt{\sin\!\left(\frac\pi{10}\right)}$ has a simple trigonometric representation, because $\sqrt{\sin\!\left(\frac\pi{10}\right)}=\frac{2^{1/2}}{5^{1/4}}\,\sin\!\left(\frac\pi5\right)$.
  • $\pi$ does not have a simple trigonometric representation, because it is not an algebraic number.

Questions:

  • Do $\sqrt{\sin\!\left(\frac\pi5\right)},\,\sqrt{\sin\!\left(\frac\pi7\right)},\,\sqrt{\sin\!\left(\frac\pi{12}\right)},\,\sqrt{\sin\!\left(\frac\pi{15}\right)},\,\sqrt{\sin\!\left(\frac\pi{20}\right)},\,\sqrt{\sin\!\left(\frac\pi{21}\right)}$ have a simple trigonometric representation?
  • Is there an algorithm that, given a rational power of $\sin(\cdot)$ at a rational multiple of $\pi$, would determine if it has a simple trigonometric representation? If so, could you give a concrete example of such an algorithm?
  • More generally, is there an algorithm that, given a real algebraic number (in a form of its minimal polynomial and a rational isolating interval), would determine if it has a simple trigonometric representation? If so, could you give a concrete example of such an algorithm?

Let's say that a real number has a simple trigonometric representation, if it can be represented as a product of zero or more rational powers of positive integers and zero or more (positive or negative) integer powers of $\sin(\cdot)$ at rational multiples of $\pi$ (the number of terms in the product is assumed to be finite, the empty product is taken to be $1$).

Examples:

  • $\sqrt[3]{\sin\!\left(\frac\pi3\right)}$ has a simple trigonometric representation, because $\sqrt[3]{\sin\!\left(\frac\pi3\right)}=\frac{3^{1/6}}{2^{1/3}}$.
  • $\sqrt{\sin\!\left(\frac\pi{10}\right)}$ has a simple trigonometric representation, because $\sqrt{\sin\!\left(\frac\pi{10}\right)}=\frac{2^{1/2}}{5^{1/4}}\,\sin\!\left(\frac\pi5\right)$.
  • $\pi$ does not have a simple trigonometric representation, because it is not an algebraic number.

Questions:

  • Do $\sqrt{\sin\!\left(\frac\pi5\right)},$ $\sqrt{\sin\!\left(\frac\pi8\right)},$ $\sqrt{\sin\!\left(\frac\pi{12}\right)},$ $\sqrt{\sin\!\left(\frac\pi{15}\right)},$ $\sqrt{\sin\!\left(\frac\pi{20}\right)},$ $\sqrt{\sin\!\left(\frac\pi{24}\right)}$ have simple trigonometric representations?
  • Is there an algorithm that, given a rational power of $\sin(\cdot)$ at a rational multiple of $\pi$, would determine if it has a simple trigonometric representation? If so, could you give (or outline) a concrete example of such an algorithm (efficient, if possible)?
  • More generally, is there an algorithm that, given a real algebraic number (in some explicit form, e.g. as its minimal polynomial and a rational isolating interval), would determine if it has a simple trigonometric representation? If so, could you give (or outline) a concrete example of such an algorithm (efficient, if possible)?
edited tags
Link
Source Link

On certain representations of algebraic numbers in terms of trigonometric functions

Let's say that a number has a simple trigonometric representation, if it can be represented as a product of zero or more rational powers of prime numbers and zero or more integer powers of $\sin(\cdot)$ at rational multiples of $\pi$.

Examples:

  • $\sqrt{\sin\!\left(\frac\pi{10}\right)}$ has a simple trigonometric representation, because $\sqrt{\sin\!\left(\frac\pi{10}\right)}=\frac{2^{1/2}}{5^{1/4}}\,\sin\!\left(\frac\pi5\right)$.
  • $\pi$ does not have a simple trigonometric representation, because it is not an algebraic number.

Questions:

  • Do $\sqrt{\sin\!\left(\frac\pi5\right)},\,\sqrt{\sin\!\left(\frac\pi7\right)},\,\sqrt{\sin\!\left(\frac\pi{12}\right)},\,\sqrt{\sin\!\left(\frac\pi{15}\right)},\,\sqrt{\sin\!\left(\frac\pi{20}\right)},\,\sqrt{\sin\!\left(\frac\pi{21}\right)}$ have a simple trigonometric representation?
  • Is there an algorithm that, given a rational power of $\sin(\cdot)$ at a rational multiple of $\pi$, would determine if it has a simple trigonometric representation? If so, could you give a concrete example of such an algorithm?
  • More generally, is there an algorithm that, given a real algebraic number (in a form of its minimal polynomial and a rational isolating interval), would determine if it has a simple trigonometric representation? If so, could you give a concrete example of such an algorithm?