Skip to main content
replaced http://mathoverflow.net/ with https://mathoverflow.net/
Source Link

Recently I was thinking on the following problem: find all $\alpha\in R$ such that $\sin\frac{\alpha}{3}$ has an algebraic expression involving only rational powers over rational constants and "$\sin\alpha$". This question is related to the one asked by Hugo Chapdelaine and discussed herehere (a question about algebraic expressions for $\sqrt[n]{a+ib}$).

For example, it can be shown that $\sin\frac{\pi}{9}$ can't be expressed in real radicals, therefore it can't be expressed in terms of $\sin\frac{\pi}{3}=\frac{\sqrt3}{2}$ too. Using the well-known formula for $\sin(3\alpha)$ we can formulate this question in the following way: find all $\alpha$ such that the equation $3x-4x^3 =\sin\alpha$ has a root of form $x=f(\sin\alpha)$, where function $f$ is a composition of rational powers and algebraic operations. Maybe someone came along with such problems? For example, if $\alpha=1$, can we obtain such a representation for $\sin\frac{1}{3}$, or can we somehow prove that it does not exist?

Recently I was thinking on the following problem: find all $\alpha\in R$ such that $\sin\frac{\alpha}{3}$ has an algebraic expression involving only rational powers over rational constants and "$\sin\alpha$". This question is related to the one asked by Hugo Chapdelaine and discussed here (a question about algebraic expressions for $\sqrt[n]{a+ib}$).

For example, it can be shown that $\sin\frac{\pi}{9}$ can't be expressed in real radicals, therefore it can't be expressed in terms of $\sin\frac{\pi}{3}=\frac{\sqrt3}{2}$ too. Using the well-known formula for $\sin(3\alpha)$ we can formulate this question in the following way: find all $\alpha$ such that the equation $3x-4x^3 =\sin\alpha$ has a root of form $x=f(\sin\alpha)$, where function $f$ is a composition of rational powers and algebraic operations. Maybe someone came along with such problems? For example, if $\alpha=1$, can we obtain such a representation for $\sin\frac{1}{3}$, or can we somehow prove that it does not exist?

Recently I was thinking on the following problem: find all $\alpha\in R$ such that $\sin\frac{\alpha}{3}$ has an algebraic expression involving only rational powers over rational constants and "$\sin\alpha$". This question is related to the one asked by Hugo Chapdelaine and discussed here (a question about algebraic expressions for $\sqrt[n]{a+ib}$).

For example, it can be shown that $\sin\frac{\pi}{9}$ can't be expressed in real radicals, therefore it can't be expressed in terms of $\sin\frac{\pi}{3}=\frac{\sqrt3}{2}$ too. Using the well-known formula for $\sin(3\alpha)$ we can formulate this question in the following way: find all $\alpha$ such that the equation $3x-4x^3 =\sin\alpha$ has a root of form $x=f(\sin\alpha)$, where function $f$ is a composition of rational powers and algebraic operations. Maybe someone came along with such problems? For example, if $\alpha=1$, can we obtain such a representation for $\sin\frac{1}{3}$, or can we somehow prove that it does not exist?

added 5 characters in body
Source Link

Recently I was thinking on the following problem: find all $\alpha\in R$ such that $\sin\frac{\alpha}{3}$ has an algebraic expression involving only rational powers over rational constants and "$\sin\alpha$". This question is related to the one asked by Hugo Chapdelaine and discussed here (a question about algebraic expressions for $\sqrt[n]{a+ib}$).

For example, it can be shown that $\sin\frac{\pi}{9}$ can't be expressed in real radicals, therefore it can't be expressed in terms of $\sin\frac{\pi}{3}=\frac{\sqrt3}{2}$ too. Using the well-known formula for $\sin(3\alpha)$ we can formulate this question in the following way: find all $\alpha$ such that the equation $3x-4x^3 =\sin\alpha$ has a root of form $x=f(\sin\alpha)$, where function $f$ is a composition of rational powers and algebraic operations. Maybe someone came along with such problems? For example, if $\alpha=1$, can we obtain such a representation for $\sin\frac{1}{3}$, or can we somehow prove that it does not exist?

Recently I was thinking on the following problem: find all $\alpha\in R$ such that $\sin\frac{\alpha}{3}$ has an algebraic expression involving only rational powers over rational constants and "$\sin\alpha$". This question is related to the one asked by Hugo Chapdelaine and discussed here (a question about algebraic expressions for $\sqrt[n]{a+ib}$).

For example, it can be shown that $\sin\frac{\pi}{9}$ can't be expressed in radicals, therefore it can't be expressed in terms of $\sin\frac{\pi}{3}=\frac{\sqrt3}{2}$ too. Using the well-known formula for $\sin(3\alpha)$ we can formulate this question in the following way: find all $\alpha$ such that the equation $3x-4x^3 =\sin\alpha$ has a root of form $x=f(\sin\alpha)$, where function $f$ is a composition of rational powers and algebraic operations. Maybe someone came along with such problems? For example, if $\alpha=1$, can we obtain such a representation for $\sin\frac{1}{3}$, or can we somehow prove that it does not exist?

Recently I was thinking on the following problem: find all $\alpha\in R$ such that $\sin\frac{\alpha}{3}$ has an algebraic expression involving only rational powers over rational constants and "$\sin\alpha$". This question is related to the one asked by Hugo Chapdelaine and discussed here (a question about algebraic expressions for $\sqrt[n]{a+ib}$).

For example, it can be shown that $\sin\frac{\pi}{9}$ can't be expressed in real radicals, therefore it can't be expressed in terms of $\sin\frac{\pi}{3}=\frac{\sqrt3}{2}$ too. Using the well-known formula for $\sin(3\alpha)$ we can formulate this question in the following way: find all $\alpha$ such that the equation $3x-4x^3 =\sin\alpha$ has a root of form $x=f(\sin\alpha)$, where function $f$ is a composition of rational powers and algebraic operations. Maybe someone came along with such problems? For example, if $\alpha=1$, can we obtain such a representation for $\sin\frac{1}{3}$, or can we somehow prove that it does not exist?

Post Closed as "Not suitable for this site" by Andrés E. Caicedo, Michael Renardy, Stefan Kohl, Dima Pasechnik, Andy Putman
Source Link

Explicit formula for $\sin\frac{\alpha}{3}$

Recently I was thinking on the following problem: find all $\alpha\in R$ such that $\sin\frac{\alpha}{3}$ has an algebraic expression involving only rational powers over rational constants and "$\sin\alpha$". This question is related to the one asked by Hugo Chapdelaine and discussed here (a question about algebraic expressions for $\sqrt[n]{a+ib}$).

For example, it can be shown that $\sin\frac{\pi}{9}$ can't be expressed in radicals, therefore it can't be expressed in terms of $\sin\frac{\pi}{3}=\frac{\sqrt3}{2}$ too. Using the well-known formula for $\sin(3\alpha)$ we can formulate this question in the following way: find all $\alpha$ such that the equation $3x-4x^3 =\sin\alpha$ has a root of form $x=f(\sin\alpha)$, where function $f$ is a composition of rational powers and algebraic operations. Maybe someone came along with such problems? For example, if $\alpha=1$, can we obtain such a representation for $\sin\frac{1}{3}$, or can we somehow prove that it does not exist?