Skip to main content
OP pointed out in a comment that $www$ should be $xxx$
Source Link

Lemma: Someone only able to speak an infinite cubefree word can convey information at least $1/24$ of the speed of an ordinary person able to speak an arbitrary binary sequence.

Proof: Consider the following period-$12$ sequence over the alphabet $\{ 0, 1, ?\}$:

$S = (001?010?1011)^{\infty}$

Now suppose $T$ is a sequence derived from $S$ by replacing each $?$ with a $0$ or $1$.

  • $T$ clearly has no words of the form $xxx$ for a single digit $x$.

If we take alternate digits in $T$, we obtain $(010011)^{\infty}$. The only cubes in this sequence have length a multiple of $6$, hence:

  • If $T$ contains a word of the form $WWW$, where $W$ has even length, then $W$ has length divisible by 12.

  • Also, $T$ contains a word of the form $WWW$ where $W$ has length $3$ if and only if two question marks in the same dodecad $(001?010?1011)$ are both zero. Assert that this will not happen.

  • If $T$ contains a word of the form $WWW$, where $W$ has length divisible by $3$, then $W$ has length divisible by $12$.

Hence we are only worried about words of length coprime to or divisible by $12$.

  • If the length of $W$ is $\pm 1 \mod 12$, then the existence of $WWW$ is ruled out by the proof of the non-existence of $www$$xxx$.

  • Similarly, it is easy to observe that there are none of length $\pm 5 \mod 12$.

So any word of the form $WWW$ in $T$ requires $W$ to have length divisible by $12$.


Now begin with any tripleless sequence over $\{A, B\}$ (such as the Thue-Morse sequence) and apply the substitution rules:

$A \mapsto (001001011011)$

$B \mapsto (0011010?1011)$

Then we obtain an infinite word over $\{0, 1, ?\}$ such that:

  • Every replacement of the question marks with digits yields an infinite cubefree word.
  • Every icositetrad contains one question mark.

The result follows.

Lemma: Someone only able to speak an infinite cubefree word can convey information at least $1/24$ of the speed of an ordinary person able to speak an arbitrary binary sequence.

Proof: Consider the following period-$12$ sequence over the alphabet $\{ 0, 1, ?\}$:

$S = (001?010?1011)^{\infty}$

Now suppose $T$ is a sequence derived from $S$ by replacing each $?$ with a $0$ or $1$.

  • $T$ clearly has no words of the form $xxx$ for a single digit $x$.

If we take alternate digits in $T$, we obtain $(010011)^{\infty}$. The only cubes in this sequence have length a multiple of $6$, hence:

  • If $T$ contains a word of the form $WWW$, where $W$ has even length, then $W$ has length divisible by 12.

  • Also, $T$ contains a word of the form $WWW$ where $W$ has length $3$ if and only if two question marks in the same dodecad $(001?010?1011)$ are both zero. Assert that this will not happen.

  • If $T$ contains a word of the form $WWW$, where $W$ has length divisible by $3$, then $W$ has length divisible by $12$.

Hence we are only worried about words of length coprime to or divisible by $12$.

  • If the length of $W$ is $\pm 1 \mod 12$, then the existence of $WWW$ is ruled out by the proof of the non-existence of $www$.

  • Similarly, it is easy to observe that there are none of length $\pm 5 \mod 12$.

So any word of the form $WWW$ in $T$ requires $W$ to have length divisible by $12$.


Now begin with any tripleless sequence over $\{A, B\}$ (such as the Thue-Morse sequence) and apply the substitution rules:

$A \mapsto (001001011011)$

$B \mapsto (0011010?1011)$

Then we obtain an infinite word over $\{0, 1, ?\}$ such that:

  • Every replacement of the question marks with digits yields an infinite cubefree word.
  • Every icositetrad contains one question mark.

The result follows.

Lemma: Someone only able to speak an infinite cubefree word can convey information at least $1/24$ of the speed of an ordinary person able to speak an arbitrary binary sequence.

Proof: Consider the following period-$12$ sequence over the alphabet $\{ 0, 1, ?\}$:

$S = (001?010?1011)^{\infty}$

Now suppose $T$ is a sequence derived from $S$ by replacing each $?$ with a $0$ or $1$.

  • $T$ clearly has no words of the form $xxx$ for a single digit $x$.

If we take alternate digits in $T$, we obtain $(010011)^{\infty}$. The only cubes in this sequence have length a multiple of $6$, hence:

  • If $T$ contains a word of the form $WWW$, where $W$ has even length, then $W$ has length divisible by 12.

  • Also, $T$ contains a word of the form $WWW$ where $W$ has length $3$ if and only if two question marks in the same dodecad $(001?010?1011)$ are both zero. Assert that this will not happen.

  • If $T$ contains a word of the form $WWW$, where $W$ has length divisible by $3$, then $W$ has length divisible by $12$.

Hence we are only worried about words of length coprime to or divisible by $12$.

  • If the length of $W$ is $\pm 1 \mod 12$, then the existence of $WWW$ is ruled out by the proof of the non-existence of $xxx$.

  • Similarly, it is easy to observe that there are none of length $\pm 5 \mod 12$.

So any word of the form $WWW$ in $T$ requires $W$ to have length divisible by $12$.


Now begin with any tripleless sequence over $\{A, B\}$ (such as the Thue-Morse sequence) and apply the substitution rules:

$A \mapsto (001001011011)$

$B \mapsto (0011010?1011)$

Then we obtain an infinite word over $\{0, 1, ?\}$ such that:

  • Every replacement of the question marks with digits yields an infinite cubefree word.
  • Every icositetrad contains one question mark.

The result follows.

Source Link
Adam P. Goucher
  • 12.4k
  • 2
  • 54
  • 105

Lemma: Someone only able to speak an infinite cubefree word can convey information at least $1/24$ of the speed of an ordinary person able to speak an arbitrary binary sequence.

Proof: Consider the following period-$12$ sequence over the alphabet $\{ 0, 1, ?\}$:

$S = (001?010?1011)^{\infty}$

Now suppose $T$ is a sequence derived from $S$ by replacing each $?$ with a $0$ or $1$.

  • $T$ clearly has no words of the form $xxx$ for a single digit $x$.

If we take alternate digits in $T$, we obtain $(010011)^{\infty}$. The only cubes in this sequence have length a multiple of $6$, hence:

  • If $T$ contains a word of the form $WWW$, where $W$ has even length, then $W$ has length divisible by 12.

  • Also, $T$ contains a word of the form $WWW$ where $W$ has length $3$ if and only if two question marks in the same dodecad $(001?010?1011)$ are both zero. Assert that this will not happen.

  • If $T$ contains a word of the form $WWW$, where $W$ has length divisible by $3$, then $W$ has length divisible by $12$.

Hence we are only worried about words of length coprime to or divisible by $12$.

  • If the length of $W$ is $\pm 1 \mod 12$, then the existence of $WWW$ is ruled out by the proof of the non-existence of $www$.

  • Similarly, it is easy to observe that there are none of length $\pm 5 \mod 12$.

So any word of the form $WWW$ in $T$ requires $W$ to have length divisible by $12$.


Now begin with any tripleless sequence over $\{A, B\}$ (such as the Thue-Morse sequence) and apply the substitution rules:

$A \mapsto (001001011011)$

$B \mapsto (0011010?1011)$

Then we obtain an infinite word over $\{0, 1, ?\}$ such that:

  • Every replacement of the question marks with digits yields an infinite cubefree word.
  • Every icositetrad contains one question mark.

The result follows.