Skip to main content
replaced http://mathoverflow.net/ with https://mathoverflow.net/
Source Link

In thisthis MO question it was mentioned that the following fact seems to be true:

If $G$ is doubly transitive on $X$ and the one-point stabilizer $G_x$ has a non-trivial center, then $G$ is of affine type, that is, the socle is elementary abelian.

Does anyone know if it is true?

I checked it with GAP for all 2-transitive groups up to degree 2499 and I no counterexamples appeared. Here is the code for groups with maximun degree of transitivity equal to two:

for gr in AllPrimitiveGroups(NrMovedPoints, [1..2499], Transitivity, 2) do
  stab := Stabilizer(gr, 1);
  if not IsTrivial(Center(stab)) then
    soc := Socle(gr);
    if not IsAbelian(soc) then 
      Print("Counterexample of degree ", NrMovedPoints(gr), "\n");
    fi;
  fi;
od;

I am mainly interested in the following question:

Is it true that if $G$ is a 2-transitive group with simple socle then $Z(G_x)=1$?

I need only to consider groups with maximum degree of transitivity equal to two. Further, many of the groups appearing in the classification of 2-transitive groups with simple socle are easy to handle. However, I cannot prove the fact in the following cases:

  1. Socle $PSL(d,q)$, degree $\frac{q^d-1}{q-1}$, and $d\geq3$ (two actions).
  2. Socle $PSU(3,q)$, degree $q^3+1$ and $q\geq3$.
  3. Socle $Sz(q)$, degree $q^2+1$ and $q=2^{2d+1}>2$.
  4. Socle $Ree(q)$, degree $q^3+1$ and $q=3^{2d+1}>3$.

Is it true that if $G$ is a 2-transitive almost simple group with simple socle isomorphic to $PSL(d,q)$, $PSU(3,q)$, $Sz(q)$ or $Ree(q)$, then $Z(G_x)=1$?

References:

  • Cameron, Peter J. Finite permutation groups and finite simple groups. Bull. London Math. Soc. 13 (1981), no. 1, 1--22. MR0599634 (83m:20008). The table with the classification of 2-transitive groups with simple socle appears in page 157, see google books)

In this MO question it was mentioned that the following fact seems to be true:

If $G$ is doubly transitive on $X$ and the one-point stabilizer $G_x$ has a non-trivial center, then $G$ is of affine type, that is, the socle is elementary abelian.

Does anyone know if it is true?

I checked it with GAP for all 2-transitive groups up to degree 2499 and I no counterexamples appeared. Here is the code for groups with maximun degree of transitivity equal to two:

for gr in AllPrimitiveGroups(NrMovedPoints, [1..2499], Transitivity, 2) do
  stab := Stabilizer(gr, 1);
  if not IsTrivial(Center(stab)) then
    soc := Socle(gr);
    if not IsAbelian(soc) then 
      Print("Counterexample of degree ", NrMovedPoints(gr), "\n");
    fi;
  fi;
od;

I am mainly interested in the following question:

Is it true that if $G$ is a 2-transitive group with simple socle then $Z(G_x)=1$?

I need only to consider groups with maximum degree of transitivity equal to two. Further, many of the groups appearing in the classification of 2-transitive groups with simple socle are easy to handle. However, I cannot prove the fact in the following cases:

  1. Socle $PSL(d,q)$, degree $\frac{q^d-1}{q-1}$, and $d\geq3$ (two actions).
  2. Socle $PSU(3,q)$, degree $q^3+1$ and $q\geq3$.
  3. Socle $Sz(q)$, degree $q^2+1$ and $q=2^{2d+1}>2$.
  4. Socle $Ree(q)$, degree $q^3+1$ and $q=3^{2d+1}>3$.

Is it true that if $G$ is a 2-transitive almost simple group with simple socle isomorphic to $PSL(d,q)$, $PSU(3,q)$, $Sz(q)$ or $Ree(q)$, then $Z(G_x)=1$?

References:

  • Cameron, Peter J. Finite permutation groups and finite simple groups. Bull. London Math. Soc. 13 (1981), no. 1, 1--22. MR0599634 (83m:20008). The table with the classification of 2-transitive groups with simple socle appears in page 157, see google books)

In this MO question it was mentioned that the following fact seems to be true:

If $G$ is doubly transitive on $X$ and the one-point stabilizer $G_x$ has a non-trivial center, then $G$ is of affine type, that is, the socle is elementary abelian.

Does anyone know if it is true?

I checked it with GAP for all 2-transitive groups up to degree 2499 and I no counterexamples appeared. Here is the code for groups with maximun degree of transitivity equal to two:

for gr in AllPrimitiveGroups(NrMovedPoints, [1..2499], Transitivity, 2) do
  stab := Stabilizer(gr, 1);
  if not IsTrivial(Center(stab)) then
    soc := Socle(gr);
    if not IsAbelian(soc) then 
      Print("Counterexample of degree ", NrMovedPoints(gr), "\n");
    fi;
  fi;
od;

I am mainly interested in the following question:

Is it true that if $G$ is a 2-transitive group with simple socle then $Z(G_x)=1$?

I need only to consider groups with maximum degree of transitivity equal to two. Further, many of the groups appearing in the classification of 2-transitive groups with simple socle are easy to handle. However, I cannot prove the fact in the following cases:

  1. Socle $PSL(d,q)$, degree $\frac{q^d-1}{q-1}$, and $d\geq3$ (two actions).
  2. Socle $PSU(3,q)$, degree $q^3+1$ and $q\geq3$.
  3. Socle $Sz(q)$, degree $q^2+1$ and $q=2^{2d+1}>2$.
  4. Socle $Ree(q)$, degree $q^3+1$ and $q=3^{2d+1}>3$.

Is it true that if $G$ is a 2-transitive almost simple group with simple socle isomorphic to $PSL(d,q)$, $PSU(3,q)$, $Sz(q)$ or $Ree(q)$, then $Z(G_x)=1$?

References:

  • Cameron, Peter J. Finite permutation groups and finite simple groups. Bull. London Math. Soc. 13 (1981), no. 1, 1--22. MR0599634 (83m:20008). The table with the classification of 2-transitive groups with simple socle appears in page 157, see google books)
deleted 4 characters in body
Source Link
Leandro Vendramin
  • 3.1k
  • 1
  • 23
  • 32

In this MO question it was mentioned that the following fact seems to be true:

If $G$ is doubly transitive on $X$ and the one-point stabilizer $G_x$ has a non-trivial center, then $G$ is of affine type, that is, the socle is elementary abelian.

Does anyone know if it is true?

I checked it with GAP for all 2-transitive groups up to degree 2499 and I no counterexamples appeared. Here is the code for groups with maximun degree of transitivity equal to two:

for gr in AllPrimitiveGroups(NrMovedPoints, [1..2499], Transitivity, 2) do
  stab := Stabilizer(gr, 1);
  if not IsTrivial(Center(stab)) then
    soc := Socle(gr);
    if not IsAbelian(soc) then 
      Print("Counterexample of degree ", NrMovedPoints(gr), "\n");
    fi;
  fi;
od;

I am mainly interested in the following question:

Is it true that if $G$ is a 2-transitive group with simple socle then $Z(G_x)\ne1$$Z(G_x)=1$?

I need only to consider groups with maximum degree of transitivity equal to two. Further, many of the groups appearing in the classification of 2-transitive groups with simple socle are easy to handle. However, I cannot prove the fact in the following cases:

  1. Socle $PSL(d,q)$, degree $\frac{q^d-1}{q-1}$, and $d\geq3$ (two actions).
  2. Socle $PSU(3,q)$, degree $q^3+1$ and $q\geq3$.
  3. Socle $Sz(q)$, degree $q^2+1$ and $q=2^{2d+1}>2$.
  4. Socle $Ree(q)$, degree $q^3+1$ and $q=3^{2d+1}>3$.

Is it true that if $G$ is a 2-transitive almost simple group with simple socle isomorphic to $PSL(d,q)$, $PSU(3,q)$, $Sz(q)$ or $Ree(q)$, then $Z(G_x)\ne1$$Z(G_x)=1$?

References:

  • Cameron, Peter J. Finite permutation groups and finite simple groups. Bull. London Math. Soc. 13 (1981), no. 1, 1--22. MR0599634 (83m:20008). The table with the classification of 2-transitive groups with simple socle appears in page 157, see google books)

In this MO question it was mentioned that the following fact seems to be true:

If $G$ is doubly transitive on $X$ and the one-point stabilizer $G_x$ has a non-trivial center, then $G$ is of affine type, that is, the socle is elementary abelian.

Does anyone know if it is true?

I checked it with GAP for all 2-transitive groups up to degree 2499 and I no counterexamples appeared. Here is the code for groups with maximun degree of transitivity equal to two:

for gr in AllPrimitiveGroups(NrMovedPoints, [1..2499], Transitivity, 2) do
  stab := Stabilizer(gr, 1);
  if not IsTrivial(Center(stab)) then
    soc := Socle(gr);
    if not IsAbelian(soc) then 
      Print("Counterexample of degree ", NrMovedPoints(gr), "\n");
    fi;
  fi;
od;

I am mainly interested in the following question:

Is it true that if $G$ is a 2-transitive group with simple socle then $Z(G_x)\ne1$?

I need only to consider groups with maximum degree of transitivity equal to two. Further, many of the groups appearing in the classification of 2-transitive groups with simple socle are easy to handle. However, I cannot prove the fact in the following cases:

  1. Socle $PSL(d,q)$, degree $\frac{q^d-1}{q-1}$, and $d\geq3$ (two actions).
  2. Socle $PSU(3,q)$, degree $q^3+1$ and $q\geq3$.
  3. Socle $Sz(q)$, degree $q^2+1$ and $q=2^{2d+1}>2$.
  4. Socle $Ree(q)$, degree $q^3+1$ and $q=3^{2d+1}>3$.

Is it true that if $G$ is a 2-transitive almost simple group with simple socle isomorphic to $PSL(d,q)$, $PSU(3,q)$, $Sz(q)$ or $Ree(q)$, then $Z(G_x)\ne1$?

References:

  • Cameron, Peter J. Finite permutation groups and finite simple groups. Bull. London Math. Soc. 13 (1981), no. 1, 1--22. MR0599634 (83m:20008). The table with the classification of 2-transitive groups with simple socle appears in page 157, see google books)

In this MO question it was mentioned that the following fact seems to be true:

If $G$ is doubly transitive on $X$ and the one-point stabilizer $G_x$ has a non-trivial center, then $G$ is of affine type, that is, the socle is elementary abelian.

Does anyone know if it is true?

I checked it with GAP for all 2-transitive groups up to degree 2499 and I no counterexamples appeared. Here is the code for groups with maximun degree of transitivity equal to two:

for gr in AllPrimitiveGroups(NrMovedPoints, [1..2499], Transitivity, 2) do
  stab := Stabilizer(gr, 1);
  if not IsTrivial(Center(stab)) then
    soc := Socle(gr);
    if not IsAbelian(soc) then 
      Print("Counterexample of degree ", NrMovedPoints(gr), "\n");
    fi;
  fi;
od;

I am mainly interested in the following question:

Is it true that if $G$ is a 2-transitive group with simple socle then $Z(G_x)=1$?

I need only to consider groups with maximum degree of transitivity equal to two. Further, many of the groups appearing in the classification of 2-transitive groups with simple socle are easy to handle. However, I cannot prove the fact in the following cases:

  1. Socle $PSL(d,q)$, degree $\frac{q^d-1}{q-1}$, and $d\geq3$ (two actions).
  2. Socle $PSU(3,q)$, degree $q^3+1$ and $q\geq3$.
  3. Socle $Sz(q)$, degree $q^2+1$ and $q=2^{2d+1}>2$.
  4. Socle $Ree(q)$, degree $q^3+1$ and $q=3^{2d+1}>3$.

Is it true that if $G$ is a 2-transitive almost simple group with simple socle isomorphic to $PSL(d,q)$, $PSU(3,q)$, $Sz(q)$ or $Ree(q)$, then $Z(G_x)=1$?

References:

  • Cameron, Peter J. Finite permutation groups and finite simple groups. Bull. London Math. Soc. 13 (1981), no. 1, 1--22. MR0599634 (83m:20008). The table with the classification of 2-transitive groups with simple socle appears in page 157, see google books)
Source Link
Leandro Vendramin
  • 3.1k
  • 1
  • 23
  • 32

Center of one-point stabilizer in 2-transitive groups

In this MO question it was mentioned that the following fact seems to be true:

If $G$ is doubly transitive on $X$ and the one-point stabilizer $G_x$ has a non-trivial center, then $G$ is of affine type, that is, the socle is elementary abelian.

Does anyone know if it is true?

I checked it with GAP for all 2-transitive groups up to degree 2499 and I no counterexamples appeared. Here is the code for groups with maximun degree of transitivity equal to two:

for gr in AllPrimitiveGroups(NrMovedPoints, [1..2499], Transitivity, 2) do
  stab := Stabilizer(gr, 1);
  if not IsTrivial(Center(stab)) then
    soc := Socle(gr);
    if not IsAbelian(soc) then 
      Print("Counterexample of degree ", NrMovedPoints(gr), "\n");
    fi;
  fi;
od;

I am mainly interested in the following question:

Is it true that if $G$ is a 2-transitive group with simple socle then $Z(G_x)\ne1$?

I need only to consider groups with maximum degree of transitivity equal to two. Further, many of the groups appearing in the classification of 2-transitive groups with simple socle are easy to handle. However, I cannot prove the fact in the following cases:

  1. Socle $PSL(d,q)$, degree $\frac{q^d-1}{q-1}$, and $d\geq3$ (two actions).
  2. Socle $PSU(3,q)$, degree $q^3+1$ and $q\geq3$.
  3. Socle $Sz(q)$, degree $q^2+1$ and $q=2^{2d+1}>2$.
  4. Socle $Ree(q)$, degree $q^3+1$ and $q=3^{2d+1}>3$.

Is it true that if $G$ is a 2-transitive almost simple group with simple socle isomorphic to $PSL(d,q)$, $PSU(3,q)$, $Sz(q)$ or $Ree(q)$, then $Z(G_x)\ne1$?

References:

  • Cameron, Peter J. Finite permutation groups and finite simple groups. Bull. London Math. Soc. 13 (1981), no. 1, 1--22. MR0599634 (83m:20008). The table with the classification of 2-transitive groups with simple socle appears in page 157, see google books)