Skip to main content
Math Jaxed
Source Link
Daniele Tampieri
  • 6.4k
  • 7
  • 30
  • 45

There are a truly enormous number of solutions, if one only wants the solution to work on an interval. Indeed, one can find solutions to f(f(x)) = g(x)$f(f(x)) = g(x)$ for any function g$g$ defined on an interval.

Specifically, I claim that if g:[a,b] to R$g:[a,b] \to \Bbb R$, then there are 2|R|$2^{|\Bbb R|}$ many functions f$f$ from R$\Bbb R$ to R$\Bbb R$ with f(f(x)) = g(x)$f(f(x)) = g(x)$ for all x$x$ in [a,b]$[a,b]$.

One such solution f$f$ is obtained as follows. First choose a z$z$ such that [a,b]$[a,b]$ and [a + z, b + z]$[a + z, b + z]$ are disjoint. Now let f(x) = x + z$f(x) = x + z$, for x$x$ in [a,b]$[a,b]$, and f(x) = g(x - z)$f(x) = g(x - z)$, for x$x$ in [a + z, b + z]$[a + z, b + z]$. Thus, f(x)$f(x)$ first translates x$x$ to another interval, when x$x$ is in [a,b]$[a,b]$, and then f$f$ computes g$g$ of the reverse translate, when x$x$ is not in [a,b]$[a,b]$. So f(f(x)) = g(x)$f(f(x)) = g(x)$.

When g$g$ is continuous, then this function f$f$ will be continuous also, and can be made total by linearly extending.

More generally, if h$h$ is bijection of [a,b]$[a,b]$ with another interval [a',b']$[a',b']$ disjoint from [a,b]$[a,b]$, then let f(x) = h(x)$f(x) = h(x)$ for x$x$ in [a,b]$[a,b]$, and f(x) = g(h-1(x))$f(x) = g\big(h^{-1}(x)\big)$ for x$x$ in [a',b']$[a',b']$. It follows that f(f(x)) = g(x)$f(f(x)) = g(x)$. And since there are 2|R|$2^{|\Bbb R|}$ many such functions h$h$, there are similarly many functions f$f$ satisfying the equation.

There are a truly enormous number of solutions, if one only wants the solution to work on an interval. Indeed, one can find solutions to f(f(x)) = g(x) for any function g defined on an interval.

Specifically, I claim that if g:[a,b] to R, then there are 2|R| many functions f from R to R with f(f(x)) = g(x) for all x in [a,b].

One such solution f is obtained as follows. First choose a z such that [a,b] and [a + z, b + z] are disjoint. Now let f(x) = x + z, for x in [a,b], and f(x) = g(x - z), for x in [a + z, b + z]. Thus, f(x) first translates x to another interval, when x is in [a,b], and then f computes g of the reverse translate, when x is not in [a,b]. So f(f(x)) = g(x).

When g is continuous, then this function f will be continuous also, and can be made total by linearly extending.

More generally, if h is bijection of [a,b] with another interval [a',b'] disjoint from [a,b], then let f(x) = h(x) for x in [a,b], and f(x) = g(h-1(x)) for x in [a',b']. It follows that f(f(x)) = g(x). And since there are 2|R| many such functions h, there are similarly many functions f satisfying the equation.

There are a truly enormous number of solutions, if one only wants the solution to work on an interval. Indeed, one can find solutions to $f(f(x)) = g(x)$ for any function $g$ defined on an interval.

Specifically, I claim that if $g:[a,b] \to \Bbb R$, then there are $2^{|\Bbb R|}$ many functions $f$ from $\Bbb R$ to $\Bbb R$ with $f(f(x)) = g(x)$ for all $x$ in $[a,b]$.

One such solution $f$ is obtained as follows. First choose a $z$ such that $[a,b]$ and $[a + z, b + z]$ are disjoint. Now let $f(x) = x + z$, for $x$ in $[a,b]$, and $f(x) = g(x - z)$, for $x$ in $[a + z, b + z]$. Thus, $f(x)$ first translates $x$ to another interval, when $x$ is in $[a,b]$, and then $f$ computes $g$ of the reverse translate, when $x$ is not in $[a,b]$. So $f(f(x)) = g(x)$.

When $g$ is continuous, then this function $f$ will be continuous also, and can be made total by linearly extending.

More generally, if $h$ is bijection of $[a,b]$ with another interval $[a',b']$ disjoint from $[a,b]$, then let $f(x) = h(x)$ for $x$ in $[a,b]$, and $f(x) = g\big(h^{-1}(x)\big)$ for $x$ in $[a',b']$. It follows that $f(f(x)) = g(x)$. And since there are $2^{|\Bbb R|}$ many such functions $h$, there are similarly many functions $f$ satisfying the equation.

Source Link
Joel David Hamkins
  • 236.3k
  • 44
  • 777
  • 1.4k

There are a truly enormous number of solutions, if one only wants the solution to work on an interval. Indeed, one can find solutions to f(f(x)) = g(x) for any function g defined on an interval.

Specifically, I claim that if g:[a,b] to R, then there are 2|R| many functions f from R to R with f(f(x)) = g(x) for all x in [a,b].

One such solution f is obtained as follows. First choose a z such that [a,b] and [a + z, b + z] are disjoint. Now let f(x) = x + z, for x in [a,b], and f(x) = g(x - z), for x in [a + z, b + z]. Thus, f(x) first translates x to another interval, when x is in [a,b], and then f computes g of the reverse translate, when x is not in [a,b]. So f(f(x)) = g(x).

When g is continuous, then this function f will be continuous also, and can be made total by linearly extending.

More generally, if h is bijection of [a,b] with another interval [a',b'] disjoint from [a,b], then let f(x) = h(x) for x in [a,b], and f(x) = g(h-1(x)) for x in [a',b']. It follows that f(f(x)) = g(x). And since there are 2|R| many such functions h, there are similarly many functions f satisfying the equation.