Skip to main content
Post Made Community Wiki by Todd Trimble

I'm writing an article. I suppose that I'll submit it to a more or less decent journal (in English). I have doubts about the following: I have a lemma (with quite a trivial proof). I don't want to include this lemma with complete proof due to its triviality and because it has been already proved before in my Ph.D. thesis.

So I may either prove the lemma in the article (this certainly will not be very good) or simply include a citation of my dissertation instead of proof. But the thesis is in Ukrainian and it's not even available freely via the Internet. Which of the two alternatives would you choose?

Do there exist other ways to do this well?

Thanks in advance.

Best wishes, Ievgen.

I'm writing an article. I suppose that I'll submit it to a more or less decent journal (in English). I have doubts about the following: I have a lemma (with quite a trivial proof). I don't want to include this lemma with complete proof due to its triviality and because it has been already proved before in my Ph.D. thesis.

So I may either prove the lemma in the article (this certainly will not be very good) or simply include a citation of my dissertation instead of proof. But the thesis is in Ukrainian and it's not even available freely via the Internet. Which of the two alternatives would you choose?

Do there exist other ways to do this well?

Thanks in advance.

Best wishes, Ievgen.

I'm writing an article. I suppose that I'll submit it to a more or less decent journal (in English). I have doubts about the following: I have a lemma (with quite a trivial proof). I don't want to include this lemma with complete proof due to its triviality and because it has been already proved before in my Ph.D. thesis.

So I may either prove the lemma in the article (this certainly will not be very good) or simply include a citation of my dissertation instead of proof. But the thesis is in Ukrainian and it's not even available freely via the Internet. Which of the two alternatives would you choose?

Do there exist other ways to do this well?

Source Link
Ievgen
  • 195
  • 9

Proof or citation?

I'm writing an article. I suppose that I'll submit it to a more or less decent journal (in English). I have doubts about the following: I have a lemma (with quite a trivial proof). I don't want to include this lemma with complete proof due to its triviality and because it has been already proved before in my Ph.D. thesis.

So I may either prove the lemma in the article (this certainly will not be very good) or simply include a citation of my dissertation instead of proof. But the thesis is in Ukrainian and it's not even available freely via the Internet. Which of the two alternatives would you choose?

Do there exist other ways to do this well?

Thanks in advance.

Best wishes, Ievgen.