Skip to main content
Source Link
Paul Siegel
  • 29.2k
  • 19
  • 134
  • 200

Euclidean geometry is still taught in American high schools, but I am strongly against it. I think it should be replaced with linear algebra.

Arguments against Euclidean geometry:

  • Most of what you prove in a high school Euclidean geometry class seems pretty obvious until you learn about non-Euclidean geometry. It makes students think that proofs are pedantry for its own sake.

  • Euclidean geometry is basically useless. There was undoubtedly a time when people used ruler and compass constructions in architecture or design, but that time is long gone.

  • Euclidean geometry is obsolete. Even those students who go into mathematics will probably never use it again.

Arguments for linear algebra:

  • $\mathbb{R}^2$ with the standard inner product is a model for the Euclidean axioms, so in particular you can still prove the same theorems if you really want to.

  • Linear algebra generalizes easily to dimensions larger than 3 where most students' geometric intuition breaks down, so it is easier for them to appreciate the need for axioms and theorems.

  • Linear algebra - particularly eigenvalues and eigenvectors - is ubiquitous in modern science and engineering. I would argue that the average person is much more likely to encounter an eigenvalue problem than a calculus problem.

  • Linear algebra is, of course, still the basic language in which most of mathematics is expressed and thus a linear algebra class is a more honest taste of what math is all about.

  • Providing students with an early foundation in linear algebra would make later education run more smoothly. Even many non-scientists use software that is based on solving linear systems or computing matrix decompositions, and it might help for such people to have a little more context. And those who go on to take further science classes - particularly physics - would more obviously benefit. If nothing else, we might finally be able to teach our students the correct second derivative test in multivariable calculus classes...

Post Made Community Wiki by Paul Siegel