Skip to main content
replaced http://mathoverflow.net/ with https://mathoverflow.net/
Source Link

This is a variation of the question Can a tangle of arcs interlock?Can a tangle of arcs interlock?, asked by Joseph O'Rourke, and solved. I reproduce the question here:

Can a (finite) collection of disjoint circle arcs in $\mathbb{R}^3$ be interlocked in the sense in that they cannot be separated, i.e. each moved arbitrarily far from one another while remaining disjoint (or at least never crossing) throughout? (Imagine the arcs are made of rigid steel; but infinitely thin.) The arcs may have different radii; each spans strictly less than $2 \pi$ in angle, so each has a positive "gap" through which arcs may pass.

My proposed variation is:

Can they interlock in $\mathbb R^2$?

I posted a commenta comment at the original question, claiming that three circle arcs can be locked.

enter image description here

And two cannot

enter image description here

I soon realized that the examples with three arcs can in fact be unlocked, and I think Joseph O'Rourke did the samedid the same. I reproduce here my solution to unlock them: enter image description here

So, the question is still open for two dimensions.

This is a variation of the question Can a tangle of arcs interlock?, asked by Joseph O'Rourke, and solved. I reproduce the question here:

Can a (finite) collection of disjoint circle arcs in $\mathbb{R}^3$ be interlocked in the sense in that they cannot be separated, i.e. each moved arbitrarily far from one another while remaining disjoint (or at least never crossing) throughout? (Imagine the arcs are made of rigid steel; but infinitely thin.) The arcs may have different radii; each spans strictly less than $2 \pi$ in angle, so each has a positive "gap" through which arcs may pass.

My proposed variation is:

Can they interlock in $\mathbb R^2$?

I posted a comment at the original question, claiming that three circle arcs can be locked.

enter image description here

And two cannot

enter image description here

I soon realized that the examples with three arcs can in fact be unlocked, and I think Joseph O'Rourke did the same. I reproduce here my solution to unlock them: enter image description here

So, the question is still open for two dimensions.

This is a variation of the question Can a tangle of arcs interlock?, asked by Joseph O'Rourke, and solved. I reproduce the question here:

Can a (finite) collection of disjoint circle arcs in $\mathbb{R}^3$ be interlocked in the sense in that they cannot be separated, i.e. each moved arbitrarily far from one another while remaining disjoint (or at least never crossing) throughout? (Imagine the arcs are made of rigid steel; but infinitely thin.) The arcs may have different radii; each spans strictly less than $2 \pi$ in angle, so each has a positive "gap" through which arcs may pass.

My proposed variation is:

Can they interlock in $\mathbb R^2$?

I posted a comment at the original question, claiming that three circle arcs can be locked.

enter image description here

And two cannot

enter image description here

I soon realized that the examples with three arcs can in fact be unlocked, and I think Joseph O'Rourke did the same. I reproduce here my solution to unlock them: enter image description here

So, the question is still open for two dimensions.

edited body
Source Link
Cristi Stoica
  • 4.3k
  • 4
  • 40
  • 57

This is a variation of the question Can a tangle of arcs interlock?, asked by Joseph O'Rourke, and solved. I reproduce the question here:

Can a (finite) collection of disjoint circle arcs in $\mathbb{R}^3$ be interlocked in the sense in that they cannot be separated, i.e. each moved arbitrarily far from one another while remaining disjoint (or at least never crossing) throughout? (Imagine the arcs are made of rigid steel; but infinitely thin.) The arcs may have different radii; each spans strictly less than $2 \pi$ in angle, so each has a positive "gap" through which arcs may pass.

My proposed variation is:

Can they interlock in $\mathbb R^2$?

I posted a comment at the original question, claiming that three circle arcs can be locked.

enter image description here

And two cannot

enter image description here

I soon realized that the examples with three arcs can in fact be unlocked, and I think Joseph O'Rourke did the same. I reproduce here my solution to unlock them: enter image description hereenter image description here

So, the question is still open for two dimensions.

This is a variation of the question Can a tangle of arcs interlock?, asked by Joseph O'Rourke, and solved.

My proposed variation is:

Can they interlock in $\mathbb R^2$?

I posted a comment at the original question, claiming that three circle arcs can be locked.

enter image description here

And two cannot

enter image description here

I soon realized that the examples with three arcs can in fact be unlocked, and I think Joseph O'Rourke did the same. I reproduce here my solution to unlock them: enter image description here

So, the question is still open for two dimensions.

This is a variation of the question Can a tangle of arcs interlock?, asked by Joseph O'Rourke, and solved. I reproduce the question here:

Can a (finite) collection of disjoint circle arcs in $\mathbb{R}^3$ be interlocked in the sense in that they cannot be separated, i.e. each moved arbitrarily far from one another while remaining disjoint (or at least never crossing) throughout? (Imagine the arcs are made of rigid steel; but infinitely thin.) The arcs may have different radii; each spans strictly less than $2 \pi$ in angle, so each has a positive "gap" through which arcs may pass.

My proposed variation is:

Can they interlock in $\mathbb R^2$?

I posted a comment at the original question, claiming that three circle arcs can be locked.

enter image description here

And two cannot

enter image description here

I soon realized that the examples with three arcs can in fact be unlocked, and I think Joseph O'Rourke did the same. I reproduce here my solution to unlock them: enter image description here

So, the question is still open for two dimensions.

Source Link
Cristi Stoica
  • 4.3k
  • 4
  • 40
  • 57

Can a tangle of arcs interlock in plane?

This is a variation of the question Can a tangle of arcs interlock?, asked by Joseph O'Rourke, and solved.

My proposed variation is:

Can they interlock in $\mathbb R^2$?

I posted a comment at the original question, claiming that three circle arcs can be locked.

enter image description here

And two cannot

enter image description here

I soon realized that the examples with three arcs can in fact be unlocked, and I think Joseph O'Rourke did the same. I reproduce here my solution to unlock them: enter image description here

So, the question is still open for two dimensions.