Skip to main content
replaced http://mathoverflow.net/ with https://mathoverflow.net/
Source Link

This is an extension of a previous question of mine (nicely answered by Douglas Zare): Filling a bin with one type of element when uniformly selecting from a set of two (with bias)Filling a bin with one type of element when uniformly selecting from a set of two (with bias)

Say I fill a multiset by flipping a biased coin and putting the element $A$ in the set if I see heads, and $B$ if I see tails. However, as soon as there are $k$ copies of element $B$ in the multiset, I sequentially select elements with uniform probability (regardless of whether they are $A$ or $B$) and prune them until no more copies of $B$ exist. I then return to flipping my coin and filling the multiset in the aforementioned manner. I halt the process when there exists exactly $N$ copies $A$ in the multiset and no copies of $B$.

If we reach $N$ copies of $A$ in the multiset, and we have $>0$ copies of $B$, we automatically begin the pruning process.

My question here is: does the value of $k$ matter when $k \leq N$? If the value does matter, what value minimizes the number of coin flips required to reach the halt state with exactly $N$ copies of the element $A$ in the multiset and no copies of element $B$?

This is an extension of a previous question of mine (nicely answered by Douglas Zare): Filling a bin with one type of element when uniformly selecting from a set of two (with bias)

Say I fill a multiset by flipping a biased coin and putting the element $A$ in the set if I see heads, and $B$ if I see tails. However, as soon as there are $k$ copies of element $B$ in the multiset, I sequentially select elements with uniform probability (regardless of whether they are $A$ or $B$) and prune them until no more copies of $B$ exist. I then return to flipping my coin and filling the multiset in the aforementioned manner. I halt the process when there exists exactly $N$ copies $A$ in the multiset and no copies of $B$.

If we reach $N$ copies of $A$ in the multiset, and we have $>0$ copies of $B$, we automatically begin the pruning process.

My question here is: does the value of $k$ matter when $k \leq N$? If the value does matter, what value minimizes the number of coin flips required to reach the halt state with exactly $N$ copies of the element $A$ in the multiset and no copies of element $B$?

This is an extension of a previous question of mine (nicely answered by Douglas Zare): Filling a bin with one type of element when uniformly selecting from a set of two (with bias)

Say I fill a multiset by flipping a biased coin and putting the element $A$ in the set if I see heads, and $B$ if I see tails. However, as soon as there are $k$ copies of element $B$ in the multiset, I sequentially select elements with uniform probability (regardless of whether they are $A$ or $B$) and prune them until no more copies of $B$ exist. I then return to flipping my coin and filling the multiset in the aforementioned manner. I halt the process when there exists exactly $N$ copies $A$ in the multiset and no copies of $B$.

If we reach $N$ copies of $A$ in the multiset, and we have $>0$ copies of $B$, we automatically begin the pruning process.

My question here is: does the value of $k$ matter when $k \leq N$? If the value does matter, what value minimizes the number of coin flips required to reach the halt state with exactly $N$ copies of the element $A$ in the multiset and no copies of element $B$?

deleted 3 characters in body; added 129 characters in body
Source Link
VGore
  • 43
  • 4

This is an extension of a previous question of mine (nicely answered by Douglas Zare): Filling a bin with one type of element when uniformly selecting from a set of two (with bias)

Say I fill a multiset by flipping a biased coin and putting the element $A$ in the set if I see heads, and $B$ if I see tails. However, as soon as there are $k$ copies of element $B$ in the multiset, I sequentially select elements with uniform probability (regardless of whether they are $A$ or $B$) and prune them until no more copies of $B$ exist. I then return to flipping my coin and filling the multiset in the aforementioned manner. I halt the process when there exists exactly $N$ copies $A$ in the multiset and no copies of $B$.

If we reach $N$ copies of $A$ in the multiset, and we have $>0$ copies of $B$, we automatically begin the pruning process.

My question here is: does the value of $k$ matter when $k \leq N$? If the value does matter, what value minimizes the number of coin flips required to reach the halt state with exactly $N$ copies of the element $A$ in the multiset and no copies of element $B$?

This is an extension of a previous question of mine (nicely answered by Douglas Zare): Filling a bin with one type of element when uniformly selecting from a set of two (with bias)

Say I fill a multiset by flipping a biased coin and putting the element $A$ in the set if I see heads, and $B$ if I see tails. However, as soon as there are $k$ copies of element $B$ in the multiset, I sequentially select elements with uniform probability (regardless of whether they are $A$ or $B$) and prune them until no more copies of $B$ exist. I then return to flipping my coin and filling the multiset in the aforementioned manner. I halt the process when there exists exactly $N$ copies $A$ in the multiset and no copies of $B$.

My question here is: does the value of $k$ matter when $k \leq N$? If the value does matter, what value minimizes the number of coin flips required to reach the halt state with exactly $N$ copies of the element $A$ in the multiset and no copies of element $B$?

This is an extension of a previous question of mine (nicely answered by Douglas Zare): Filling a bin with one type of element when uniformly selecting from a set of two (with bias)

Say I fill a multiset by flipping a biased coin and putting the element $A$ in the set if I see heads, and $B$ if I see tails. However, as soon as there are $k$ copies of element $B$ in the multiset, I sequentially select elements with uniform probability (regardless of whether they are $A$ or $B$) and prune them until no more copies of $B$ exist. I then return to flipping my coin and filling the multiset in the aforementioned manner. I halt the process when there exists exactly $N$ copies $A$ in the multiset and no copies of $B$.

If we reach $N$ copies of $A$ in the multiset, and we have $>0$ copies of $B$, we automatically begin the pruning process.

My question here is: does the value of $k$ matter when $k \leq N$? If the value does matter, what value minimizes the number of coin flips required to reach the halt state with exactly $N$ copies of the element $A$ in the multiset and no copies of element $B$?

deleted 17 characters in body
Source Link
VGore
  • 43
  • 4

This is an extension of a previous question of mine (nicely answered by Douglas Zare): Filling a bin with one type of element when uniformly selecting from a set of two (with bias)

Say I fill a multiset by flipping a biased coin and putting the element $A$ in the set if I see heads, and $B$ if I see tails. However, as soon as there are $k$ copies of element $B$ in the multiset, I sequentially select elements with uniform probability (regardless of whether they are $A$ or $B$) and prune them until no more copies of $B$ exist. I then return to flipping my coin and filling the multiset in the aforementioned manner. I halt the process when there exists exactly $N$ copies $A$ in the multiset and no copies of $B$.

My question here is: does the value of $k$ matter when $k \leq N$? If the value does matter, what is its optimal value to minimizeminimizes the number of coin flips required to reach the halt state with exactly $N$ copies of the element $A$ in the multiset and no copies of element $B$?

This is an extension of a previous question of mine (nicely answered by Douglas Zare): Filling a bin with one type of element when uniformly selecting from a set of two (with bias)

Say I fill a multiset by flipping a biased coin and putting the element $A$ in the set if I see heads, and $B$ if I see tails. However, as soon as there are $k$ copies of element $B$ in the multiset, I sequentially select elements with uniform probability (regardless of whether they are $A$ or $B$) and prune them until no more copies of $B$ exist. I then return to flipping my coin and filling the multiset in the aforementioned manner. I halt the process when there exists exactly $N$ copies $A$ in the multiset and no copies of $B$.

My question here is: does the value of $k$ matter when $k \leq N$? If the value does matter, what is its optimal value to minimize the number of coin flips required to reach the halt state with exactly $N$ copies of the element $A$ in the multiset and no copies of element $B$?

This is an extension of a previous question of mine (nicely answered by Douglas Zare): Filling a bin with one type of element when uniformly selecting from a set of two (with bias)

Say I fill a multiset by flipping a biased coin and putting the element $A$ in the set if I see heads, and $B$ if I see tails. However, as soon as there are $k$ copies of element $B$ in the multiset, I sequentially select elements with uniform probability (regardless of whether they are $A$ or $B$) and prune them until no more copies of $B$ exist. I then return to flipping my coin and filling the multiset in the aforementioned manner. I halt the process when there exists exactly $N$ copies $A$ in the multiset and no copies of $B$.

My question here is: does the value of $k$ matter when $k \leq N$? If the value does matter, what value minimizes the number of coin flips required to reach the halt state with exactly $N$ copies of the element $A$ in the multiset and no copies of element $B$?

Source Link
VGore
  • 43
  • 4
Loading