Skip to main content
improved grammar, formatting
Source Link
Charles Staats
  • 7.3k
  • 5
  • 67
  • 86

Before discussing on the main Question I should recall two notions in the area of commutative rings.

By $Max(R)$, we mean the set of all maximal ideals of the commutative unitary ring $R$.

Definition1Definition 1:A A commutative ring $R$ is called separable, if for any subset $(M_{\alpha})_{\alpha \in A} \subset Max(R)$ with $\cap _{\alpha \in A}M _{\alpha}=(0)$, there exists a countable subset $A_0 \subset A$ that $\cap _{\alpha \in A _{0}}M _{\alpha}=(0)$.

and

Definition2Definition 2:A A commutative ring $R$ is called $\aleph_{1}$-cogenerated if for any collection $(I_{\alpha})_{\alpha \in A}$, with $\cap _{\alpha \in A} I _{\alpha}=(0)$ there exists a countable subset $A_0 \subset A$ so that $\cap _{\alpha \in A _{0}}I _{\alpha}=(0)$.

It is clear that every $\aleph_1$-cogenerated ring is separable.I I am looking for a commutative $J-$ semisimple$J$-semisimple ring $R$ $($i.e. $J(R)=0)$ so that is a separable ring but is not $\aleph_1$-cogenerated.

Question: Is there a commutative $J-$ semisimple$J$-semisimple ring $R$ so that it is separable but is not $\aleph_1$-cogenerated.


Addendum: The ring $C(X)$ of all continuous real valued functions on a topological space $X$ is an example of a commutative $J-$ semisimple$J$-semisimple ring thatfor which separability and $\aleph_1$-cogenerated are equivalent.

Before discussing on the main Question I should recall two notions in the area of commutative rings.

By $Max(R)$, we mean the set of all maximal ideals of the commutative unitary ring $R$.

Definition1:A commutative ring $R$ is called separable, if for any subset $(M_{\alpha})_{\alpha \in A} \subset Max(R)$ with $\cap _{\alpha \in A}M _{\alpha}=(0)$, there exists a countable subset $A_0 \subset A$ that $\cap _{\alpha \in A _{0}}M _{\alpha}=(0)$.

and

Definition2:A commutative ring $R$ is called $\aleph_{1}$-cogenerated if for any collection $(I_{\alpha})_{\alpha \in A}$, with $\cap _{\alpha \in A} I _{\alpha}=(0)$ there exists a countable subset $A_0 \subset A$ so that $\cap _{\alpha \in A _{0}}I _{\alpha}=(0)$.

It is clear that every $\aleph_1$-cogenerated ring is separable.I am looking for a commutative $J-$ semisimple ring $R$ $($i.e. $J(R)=0)$ so that is a separable ring but is not $\aleph_1$-cogenerated.

Question: Is there a commutative $J-$ semisimple ring $R$ so that it is separable but is not $\aleph_1$-cogenerated.


Addendum: The ring $C(X)$ of all continuous real valued functions on a topological space $X$ is an example of a commutative $J-$ semisimple ring that separability and $\aleph_1$-cogenerated are equivalent.

Before discussing on the main Question I should recall two notions in the area of commutative rings.

By $Max(R)$, we mean the set of all maximal ideals of the commutative unitary ring $R$.

Definition 1: A commutative ring $R$ is called separable, if for any subset $(M_{\alpha})_{\alpha \in A} \subset Max(R)$ with $\cap _{\alpha \in A}M _{\alpha}=(0)$, there exists a countable subset $A_0 \subset A$ that $\cap _{\alpha \in A _{0}}M _{\alpha}=(0)$.

and

Definition 2: A commutative ring $R$ is called $\aleph_{1}$-cogenerated if for any collection $(I_{\alpha})_{\alpha \in A}$, with $\cap _{\alpha \in A} I _{\alpha}=(0)$ there exists a countable subset $A_0 \subset A$ so that $\cap _{\alpha \in A _{0}}I _{\alpha}=(0)$.

It is clear that every $\aleph_1$-cogenerated ring is separable. I am looking for a commutative $J$-semisimple ring $R$ $($i.e. $J(R)=0)$ that is a separable ring but is not $\aleph_1$-cogenerated.

Question: Is there a commutative $J$-semisimple ring $R$ that is separable but is not $\aleph_1$-cogenerated.


Addendum: The ring $C(X)$ of all continuous real valued functions on a topological space $X$ is an example of a commutative $J$-semisimple ring for which separability and $\aleph_1$-cogenerated are equivalent.

Source Link
Ali Reza
  • 1.8k
  • 10
  • 20

separability of commutative rings

Before discussing on the main Question I should recall two notions in the area of commutative rings.

By $Max(R)$, we mean the set of all maximal ideals of the commutative unitary ring $R$.

Definition1:A commutative ring $R$ is called separable, if for any subset $(M_{\alpha})_{\alpha \in A} \subset Max(R)$ with $\cap _{\alpha \in A}M _{\alpha}=(0)$, there exists a countable subset $A_0 \subset A$ that $\cap _{\alpha \in A _{0}}M _{\alpha}=(0)$.

and

Definition2:A commutative ring $R$ is called $\aleph_{1}$-cogenerated if for any collection $(I_{\alpha})_{\alpha \in A}$, with $\cap _{\alpha \in A} I _{\alpha}=(0)$ there exists a countable subset $A_0 \subset A$ so that $\cap _{\alpha \in A _{0}}I _{\alpha}=(0)$.

It is clear that every $\aleph_1$-cogenerated ring is separable.I am looking for a commutative $J-$ semisimple ring $R$ $($i.e. $J(R)=0)$ so that is a separable ring but is not $\aleph_1$-cogenerated.

Question: Is there a commutative $J-$ semisimple ring $R$ so that it is separable but is not $\aleph_1$-cogenerated.


Addendum: The ring $C(X)$ of all continuous real valued functions on a topological space $X$ is an example of a commutative $J-$ semisimple ring that separability and $\aleph_1$-cogenerated are equivalent.