Skip to main content
broken link fixed, cf. https://meta.mathoverflow.net/q/5301/70594
Source Link
Glorfindel
  • 2.8k
  • 6
  • 28
  • 38

What is known about the distribution of average edge-degrees for 3-manifold triangulations (with the number of 3-simplices less than a fixed constant)?

This is my first question on mathoverflow! It relates to a project I'm undertaking with a student.

Work by TamuraTamura (extending results by Luo and StongLuo and Stong) shows that for any closed 3-manifold $M$ and any rational number $4.5 < r < 6$ there is a triangulation $T$ of $M$ for which that the average edge-degree $\mu(T)$ is $r$. Here the degree of an edge $e$ is the number of 3-simplices having $e$ as a face.

Now, fix a closed 3-manifold $M$ and consider the (necessarily finite) set of all triangulation of $M$ containing at most $K$ 3-simplices. Call this set $\mathcal{T}_K(M)$.

QUESTION: Does anyone know of results concerning the "distribution" of the average edge-degree $\mu(T)$ for $T\in \mathcal{T}_K(M)$? That is, what is known about the fraction of triangulations from $\mathcal{T}_K(M)$ for which the edge-degree lies in a given small interval $[r - \epsilon, r+\epsilon] \subset (4.5,6)$? Results concerning any closed 3-manifold $M$ would be fine.

I suspect this is extremely difficult to answer in a precise way. However, I'd be very interested in knowing any asymptotic ($K\rightarrow \infty$) or approximate results as well. Thanks for your help!

NOTE: For the project we plan to use the Metropolis algorithm to sample from $\mathcal{T}_K(M)$ where $M$ is the 3-torus. Using these samples we hope to empirically estimate the distribution in question.

What is known about the distribution of average edge-degrees for 3-manifold triangulations (with the number of 3-simplices less than a fixed constant)?

This is my first question on mathoverflow! It relates to a project I'm undertaking with a student.

Work by Tamura (extending results by Luo and Stong) shows that for any closed 3-manifold $M$ and any rational number $4.5 < r < 6$ there is a triangulation $T$ of $M$ for which that the average edge-degree $\mu(T)$ is $r$. Here the degree of an edge $e$ is the number of 3-simplices having $e$ as a face.

Now, fix a closed 3-manifold $M$ and consider the (necessarily finite) set of all triangulation of $M$ containing at most $K$ 3-simplices. Call this set $\mathcal{T}_K(M)$.

QUESTION: Does anyone know of results concerning the "distribution" of the average edge-degree $\mu(T)$ for $T\in \mathcal{T}_K(M)$? That is, what is known about the fraction of triangulations from $\mathcal{T}_K(M)$ for which the edge-degree lies in a given small interval $[r - \epsilon, r+\epsilon] \subset (4.5,6)$? Results concerning any closed 3-manifold $M$ would be fine.

I suspect this is extremely difficult to answer in a precise way. However, I'd be very interested in knowing any asymptotic ($K\rightarrow \infty$) or approximate results as well. Thanks for your help!

NOTE: For the project we plan to use the Metropolis algorithm to sample from $\mathcal{T}_K(M)$ where $M$ is the 3-torus. Using these samples we hope to empirically estimate the distribution in question.

What is known about the distribution of average edge-degrees for 3-manifold triangulations (with the number of 3-simplices less than a fixed constant)

This is my first question on mathoverflow! It relates to a project I'm undertaking with a student.

Work by Tamura (extending results by Luo and Stong) shows that for any closed 3-manifold $M$ and any rational number $4.5 < r < 6$ there is a triangulation $T$ of $M$ for which that the average edge-degree $\mu(T)$ is $r$. Here the degree of an edge $e$ is the number of 3-simplices having $e$ as a face.

Now, fix a closed 3-manifold $M$ and consider the (necessarily finite) set of all triangulation of $M$ containing at most $K$ 3-simplices. Call this set $\mathcal{T}_K(M)$.

QUESTION: Does anyone know of results concerning the "distribution" of the average edge-degree $\mu(T)$ for $T\in \mathcal{T}_K(M)$? That is, what is known about the fraction of triangulations from $\mathcal{T}_K(M)$ for which the edge-degree lies in a given small interval $[r - \epsilon, r+\epsilon] \subset (4.5,6)$? Results concerning any closed 3-manifold $M$ would be fine.

I suspect this is extremely difficult to answer in a precise way. However, I'd be very interested in knowing any asymptotic ($K\rightarrow \infty$) or approximate results as well. Thanks for your help!

NOTE: For the project we plan to use the Metropolis algorithm to sample from $\mathcal{T}_K(M)$ where $M$ is the 3-torus. Using these samples we hope to empirically estimate the distribution in question.

added 2 characters in body
Source Link

This is my first question on mathoverflow! It relates to a project I'm undertaking with a student.

Work by Tamura (extending results by Luo and Stong) shows that for any closed 3-manifold $M$ and any rational number $4.5 < r < 6$ there is a triangulation $T$ of $M$ for which that the average edge-degree $\mu(T)$ is $r$. Here the degree of an edge $e$ is the number of 3-simplices having $e$ as a face.

Now, fix a closed 3-manifold $M$ and consider the (necessarily finite) set of all triangulation of $M$ containing at most $K$ 3-simplices. Call this set $\mathcal{T}_K(M)$.

QUESTION: Does anyone know of results concerning the "distribution" of the average edge-degree $\mu(T)$ for $T\in \mathcal{T}_K(M)$? That is, what is known about the fraction of triangulations from $\mathcal{T}_K(M)$ for which the edge-degree lies in a given small interval $[r - \epsilon, r+\epsilon] \subset (4.5,6)$? Results concerning any closed 3-manifold $M$ would be fine.

QUESTION: Does anyone know of results concerning the "distribution" of the average edge-degree $\mu(T)$ for $T\in \mathcal{T}_K(M)$? That is, what is known about the fraction of triangulations from $\mathcal{T}_K(M)$ for which the edge-degree lies in a given small interval $[r - \epsilon, r+\epsilon] \subset (4.5,6)$? Results concerning any closed 3-manifold $M$ would be fine.

I suspect this is extremely difficult to answer in a precise way. However, I'd be very interested in knowing any asymptotic ($K\rightarrow \infty$) or approximate results as well. Thanks for your help!

NOTE: For the project we plan to use the Metropolis algorithm to sample from $\mathcal{T}_K(M)$ where $M$ is the 3-torus. Using these samples we hope to empirically estimate the distribution in question.

This is my first question on mathoverflow! It relates to a project I'm undertaking with a student.

Work by Tamura (extending results by Luo and Stong) shows that for any closed 3-manifold $M$ and any rational number $4.5 < r < 6$ there is a triangulation $T$ of $M$ for which that the average edge-degree $\mu(T)$ is $r$. Here the degree of an edge $e$ is the number of 3-simplices having $e$ as a face.

Now, fix a closed 3-manifold $M$ and consider the (necessarily finite) set of all triangulation of $M$ containing at most $K$ 3-simplices. Call this set $\mathcal{T}_K(M)$.

QUESTION: Does anyone know of results concerning the "distribution" of the average edge-degree $\mu(T)$ for $T\in \mathcal{T}_K(M)$? That is, what is known about the fraction of triangulations from $\mathcal{T}_K(M)$ for which the edge-degree lies in a given small interval $[r - \epsilon, r+\epsilon] \subset (4.5,6)$? Results concerning any closed 3-manifold $M$ would be fine.

I suspect this is extremely difficult to answer in a precise way. However, I'd be very interested in knowing any asymptotic ($K\rightarrow \infty$) or approximate results as well. Thanks for your help!

NOTE: For the project we plan to use the Metropolis algorithm to sample from $\mathcal{T}_K(M)$ where $M$ is the 3-torus. Using these samples we hope to empirically estimate the distribution in question.

This is my first question on mathoverflow! It relates to a project I'm undertaking with a student.

Work by Tamura (extending results by Luo and Stong) shows that for any closed 3-manifold $M$ and any rational number $4.5 < r < 6$ there is a triangulation $T$ of $M$ for which that the average edge-degree $\mu(T)$ is $r$. Here the degree of an edge $e$ is the number of 3-simplices having $e$ as a face.

Now, fix a closed 3-manifold $M$ and consider the (necessarily finite) set of all triangulation of $M$ containing at most $K$ 3-simplices. Call this set $\mathcal{T}_K(M)$.

QUESTION: Does anyone know of results concerning the "distribution" of the average edge-degree $\mu(T)$ for $T\in \mathcal{T}_K(M)$? That is, what is known about the fraction of triangulations from $\mathcal{T}_K(M)$ for which the edge-degree lies in a given small interval $[r - \epsilon, r+\epsilon] \subset (4.5,6)$? Results concerning any closed 3-manifold $M$ would be fine.

I suspect this is extremely difficult to answer in a precise way. However, I'd be very interested in knowing any asymptotic ($K\rightarrow \infty$) or approximate results as well. Thanks for your help!

NOTE: For the project we plan to use the Metropolis algorithm to sample from $\mathcal{T}_K(M)$ where $M$ is the 3-torus. Using these samples we hope to empirically estimate the distribution in question.

edited title
Link

What is known about the distribution of the average edge-degreedegrees for a randomly selected 3-manifold triangulationtriangulations (chosen from those withwith the number of 3-simplices less than a fixed constant)?

edited body; edited title
Source Link
Loading
deleted 2 characters in body
Source Link
Loading
added 235 characters in body; edited title; edited title; edited title
Source Link
Loading
Source Link
Loading