bio  website  gilkalai.wordpress.com 

location  Jerusalem  
age  59  
visits  member for  5 years 
seen  2 hours ago  
stats  profile views  17,188 
Professor of Mathematics at the Hebrew University of Jerusalem and at Yale University
2d

comment 
Number of graphs with M edges that does not contain Kclique
I don't see what is wrong with this question. 
Sep 27 
comment 
Characterizing faces of 3dimensional polyhedra. (Related to Victor Eberhard's Theorem [1890]:)
Dear Kundor, as it turned out the question remains open. (I forgot to update.) 
Jul 26 
comment 
Stable matchings when switches have costs
Very nice question!! 
Jul 9 
comment 
Solutions to the Continuum Hypothesis
Asaf, ok I will delete it. 
May 23 
comment 
Examples of graph properties characterized by forbidden (not necessarily induced) subgraphs
In the case of graphs on surfaces we get a finite list of graphs so that a graph which is cannot be embedded must contain a subdivision of a graph from the list. 
May 2 
comment 
How to find ICM talks?
Quid, beside ICM and ECM what are other major congresses/conferences with major proceedings that we can ask about? (I could think also of INTERNATIONAL CONGRESS OF MATHEMATICAL PHYSICS (ICMP)), I am worry that a completely openended question will not be so useful without careful management. 
May 1 
comment 
How to find ICM talks?
I am not sure about asking and answering my own question as you suggested, Quid. If you want to ask this, or a more general question, I will be happy to answer. Meanwhile it can be a nice supplement here. 
Apr 30 
comment 
GrassmannPlücker relations for permanents
Dear Abdelmalek, many thanks for the answer. You wrote "Set theoretic equations (of degree d+1) were discovered by Brill and Gordan." Can you elaborate on these equations? 
Apr 29 
comment 
A question about pairs of lines in 3D projective space
Amazing!! Many thanks, David. Very nice result. 
Apr 28 
comment 
A question about pairs of lines in 3D projective space
Thanks, David. Yes this is correct. But we can identify the quaternions with 2 dimensional v.s. over the complex so we get 8 choose 4. and then we can save a bit by intersecting with a generic hyperplane and get 7 choose 3. I wonder if Amitsur's theorem is relevant. 
Apr 28 
comment 
A question about pairs of lines in 3D projective space
The following MO question is of some relevance mathoverflow.net/questions/65421/… 
Apr 24 
comment 
Why was John Nash's 1950 Game Theory paper such a big deal?
Joël, Of course there are also issues with the notion of value for zerosum 2person games, like the need to have mixed strategies which is problematic in various cases (and various others issues). Once you apply Von Neumann and Morgenstern utility theory on mixed outcomes you often loose the zerosum property. But I agree that the notion of a value of zerosum games is also very important. 
Apr 23 
comment 
Why was John Nash's 1950 Game Theory paper such a big deal?
Dear Joël, I agree. To a large extent Nash equilibrium is a miracle concept leading to (almost) all the problems in applied game theory. It often represents genuine problems and shortcomings not only of economics theory but also of economics reality. Certainly this is something we, as mathematicians can celebrate and be enthusiastic about! 
Mar 28 
comment 
First PhD in pure math and the second PhD in applied math
I am aware of several such cases. (Prhaps in Israel and Europe there is more flexibility.) 
Mar 17 
comment 
Infinitely many primes, and Mobius randomness in sparse sets
Dear Joro, Yes, I think we need to regard it as artificial. Probably Problems 2 and 3 are more "imune" against such examples. 
Jan 30 
comment 
Is there an analog of Sperner's lemma for the Hopf invariant?
Lovely question! 
Jan 30 
comment 
Logic in mathematics and philosophy
Many thanks Joel, for your answer. As a graet fan (albeit rather ignorant) of both areas (and also of Y. Gurevich) I am certainly happy to hear on stengthening relations between philosophy and set theory/logic. 
Jan 19 
comment 
Semidirected firstpassage percolation on $\mathbb{Z}^2$ with deterministic vertical weights
Nice and natural model! 
Jan 12 
comment 
Floors of rationals to powers: Infinite number of primes?
Thanks a lot, Lucia and Victor. 
Jan 8 
comment 
Mathematical study of Mpemba effect?
I certainly support and encourage questions of this type on MO. 