show/hide this revision's text 2 Oops. I think I am answering a homework question. What to do?

For the pants, yes. In general, no. To prove this for the pants, classify all geodesic arcs and just observe the result. There are many ways to find a "no" example in the general case; the first one that came to my mind was taking a double cover.

EDIT - I see that this is a near-duplicate of a closed question. You could improve your question by giving some motivation. Reading the FAQ will be very useful in writing questions that get good answers. In particular please see http://mathoverflow.net/faq#whatnot

show/hide this revision's text 1

For the pants, yes. In general, no. To prove this for the pants, classify all geodesic arcs and just observe the result. There are many ways to find a "no" example in the general case; the first one that came to my mind was taking a double cover.