According to Magma, the projective closure of the variety associated to the problem (given by the equations $$x(x-y) + 1 = z_1^2, \quad (x+y)(x-y) + 1 = z_2^2, \quad (x+2y)(x-y) + 1 = z_3^2,$$ $$(x+y)x + 1 = z_4^2, \quad (x+2y)x + 1 = z_5^2, \quad (x+2y)(x+y) + 1 = z_6^2 \quad)$$ is an irreducible surface in ${\mathbb P}^8$ with 34 isolated singularities. Since it is a complete intersection of six quadrics, it should be of general type (and it has trivial rational points with $x = y = 0$ and slightly less trivial ones with $y = 0$, so reduction methods will not work), which makes it very likely that this is a hard question.
According to Magma, the projective closure of the variety associated to the problem (given by the equations $$x(x-y) + 1 = z_1^2, \quad (x+y)(x-y) + 1 = z_2^2, \quad (x+2y)(x-y) + 1 = z_3^2,$$ $$(x+y)x + 1 = z_4^2, \quad (x+2y)x + 1 = z_5^2, \quad (x+2y)(x+y) + 1 = z_6^2 \quad)$$ is an irreducible surface in ${\mathbb P}^8$ with 34 isolated singularities. Since it is a complete intersection of six quadrics, it should be of general type (and it has trivial rational points with $x = y = 0$ and slightly less trivial ones with $y = 0$, so reduction methods will not work), which makes it very likely that this is a hard question.