The game of Mafia, also marketed as Werewolf, depends in practice mostly on how skillful the players are at lying, but there are some fascinating mathematical questions that arise when tries to devise optimal strategies for expert players. Let me describe one such expert strategy to give the flavor. In what follows, I will assume basic knowledge of the (simple) rules, which you can find at the above Wikipedia link.
Suppose there is a detective, who secretly learns someone's identity each night. How can the detective communicate his knowledge without exposing himself to the Mafia? Each day, each townsperson claims to be the detective, and announces the piece of information he learned the previous night. The real detective tells the truth, but the Mafia will usually not be able to distinguish the real detective from all the impersonators. Of course, the townspeople will not know either—until the detective is killed. Then the townspeople, being expert players with excellent memories, will remember everything the detective said before being killed, and will therefore get a windfall of truthful information that they can they exploit to their advantage.
Many questions arise naturally. What is the probability that the townspeople win if they use this strategy? The Mafia have some extra information (they know who they are) and hence if some townsperson makes a false statement while impersonating the detective, the Mafia will detect this and know that that townsperson is not the detective. So perhaps the detective should lie occasionally to counter this strategy? How should the townspeople lie? Should they attempt to give mutually consistent stories or not? As far as I know, these strategic issues have remained largely unexplored.
See also this MO question that announces a mathematical paper on the Mafia game.
