show/hide this revision's text 6 deleted 197 characters in body

I remember a friend in graduate school throwing an early edition of Jurgen Neukirch's Algebraic Number Theory book against a wall (so hard that it split the binding) after he had worked for a number of days to reconcile something he realized was an error (or typo) in the book.

For the life of me, I cannot remember what this error was.

Has anyone come across a particularly annoying error in an early edition of Neukirch? If so, what was it?


To give context to some of the answers below, I include the original statement of this question, which Scott and David pointed out was a bit too "spammy". Sometimes I feel like a little kid at a sleepover when I am reading MO, and post a bit wildly... so I'm grateful for the voices of reason:

What are your "favorite" annoying errors and typos in otherwise excellent sources?

Please especially try to include subtle errors that can mislead, as these are very important.

Disclaimer: The author of this quesion thinks that working to resolve an error like this is a very worthwhile exercise, at least from the standpoint of having cool war stories that make a topic memorable. I'm not sure, therefore, whether I would want to post an answer to this question myself. I posted the question because I thought it would be fun.

show/hide this revision's text 5 added 10 characters in body; edited title; added 25 characters in body

Error Has anyone found an error in an early version of Neukirch.?

I remember a friend in graduate school throwing an early edition of Jurgen Neukirch's Algebraic Number Theory book against a wall (so hard that it split the binding) after he had worked for a number of days to reconcile something he realized was an error (or typo) in the book.

For the life of me, I cannot remember what this error was.

Has anyone come across a particularly annoying error in an early edition of Neukirch? If so, what was it?


To give context to some of the answers below, I include the original statement of this question, which Scott and David pointed out was a bit too "spammy". Sometimes I feel like a little kid at a sleepover when I am reading MO, and post a bit wildly... so I'm grateful for the voices of reason:

What are your "favorite" annoying errors and typos in otherwise excellent sources?

Please especially try to include subtle errors that can mislead, as these are very important.

Disclaimer: The author of this quesion thinks that working to resolve an error like this is a very worthwhile exercise, at least from the standpoint of having cool war stories that make a topic memorable. I'm not sure, therefore, whether I would want to post an answer to this question myself. I posted the question because I thought it would be fun.

show/hide this revision's text 4 added 393 characters in body; edited title; added 14 characters in body; edited tags; edited tags

Annoying typos and errors Error in nice books and papersan early version of Neukirch.

This is meant as a public service.

Sometimes wonderful sources contain errors that can stump a novice for a long time.

I remember a friend in graduate school throwing an early edition of Jurgen Neukirch's Algebraic Number Theory book against a wall (so hard that it split the binding) after he had worked for a number of days to reconcile something he realized was an error (or typo) in the book.

For the life of me, I cannot remember what this error was.

Has anyone come across a particularly annoying error in an early edition of Neukirch? If so, what was it?


To give context to some of the answers below, I include the original statement of this question, which Scott pointed out was a bit too "spammy". Sometimes I feel like a little kid at a sleepover when I am reading MO, so I'm grateful for the voices of reason:

What are your "favorite" annoying errors and typos in otherwise excellent sources?

Please especially try to include subtle errors that can mislead, as these are very important.

Disclaimer: The author of this quesion thinks that working to resolve an error like this is a very worthwhile exercise, at least from the standpoint of having cool war stories that make a topic memorable. I'm not sure, therefore, whether I would want to post an answer to this question myself. I posted the question because I thought it would be fun.

show/hide this revision's text 3 spelling
show/hide this revision's text 2 added 150 characters in body
show/hide this revision's text 1 [made Community Wiki]