The math-philosophy tag has no wiki summary.

**38**

votes

**2**answers

12k views

### Is the analysis as taught in universities in fact the analysis of definable numbers?

Ten years ago when I studied in the university I had no idea about definable numbers, but I came to this concept myself. My thoughts were as follows:
All numbers are divided into two classes: those ...

**31**

votes

**7**answers

5k views

### Arguments against large cardinals

I started to learn about large cardinals a while ago, and I read that the existence, and even the consistency of the existence of an inaccessible cardinal, i.e. a limit cardinal which is additionally ...

**12**

votes

**3**answers

2k views

### What was Weierstrass's counterexample to the Dirichlet Principle?

Shortly after his work on the foundations of geometry David Hilbert turned his attention to finding a suitable statement of the Dirichlet principle, from which to prove the Riemann mapping theorem and ...

**15**

votes

**2**answers

3k views

### Question arising from Voevodsky's talk on inconsistency

This question arises from the talk by Voevodsky mentioned in
this recent MO question. On one of his slides, Voevodsky says that
a general formula even with one free variable describes a subset of ...

**72**

votes

**16**answers

16k views

### What if Current Foundations of Mathematics are Inconsistent? [closed]

The title of the question is also the title of a talk by Vladimir Voevodsky, available here.
Had this kind of opinion been expressed before?
EDIT. Thanks to all answerers, commentators, voters, ...

**15**

votes

**2**answers

2k views

### Universe view vs. Multiverse view of Set Theory

Here I refer to Hamkins' slides:
http://lumiere.ens.fr/~dbonnay/files/talks/hamkins.pdf
particularly, to the "Universe view simulated inside Multiverse", p. 22.
My question is: is it very unsound ...

**12**

votes

**1**answer

728 views

### evil properties, higher category theory and well-chosen tensor products

Let's start with the following random example: If $F$ is a presheaf, then for every chain of open subsets $U \subseteq V \subseteq W$, the morphisms $F(W) \to F(V) \to F(U)$ and $F(W) \to F(U)$ ...

**20**

votes

**6**answers

2k views

### Interpretation of the Second Incompleteness Theorem

For simplicity, let me pick a particular instance of G\"odel's Second Incompleteness
Theorem:
ZFC (Zermelo-Fraenkel Set Theory plus the Axiom of Choice, the usual foundation of mathematics) does ...

**50**

votes

**3**answers

6k views

### Nelson's program to show inconsistency of ZF

At the end of the paper Division by three by Peter G. Doyle and John H. Conway, the authors say:
Not that we believe there really are any such things as infinite sets, or that the Zermelo-Fraenkel ...

**16**

votes

**7**answers

4k views

### What is Realistic Mathematics?

This post is partially about opinions and partially about more precise mathematical questions. Most of this post is not as formal as a precise mathematical question. However, I hope that most readers ...

**9**

votes

**2**answers

1k views

### Proving Independence of Axioms by Exhibiting Models Which Don't Satisfy Our Intuition

I recently saw the proof of the independence of ZF (with allowance for multiple empty sets) and AC. The proof constructed the model based on a set theory generated by infinitely many empty sets and ...

**7**

votes

**7**answers

2k views

### Meaning of Kronecker's comment to Lindemann

At the Mactutor history page, it is said that Kronecker remarked to Lindemann:
"What good your beautiful proof on [the transcendence of] π? Why investigate such problems, given that irrational ...

**8**

votes

**3**answers

2k views

### Use of Conjectures to Prove a Theorem

Name a theorem T that has a proof based upon the truth of a conjecture C, and also has another proof based upon the falsehood of the same conjecture C, but for longtime has no known direct proof that ...

**6**

votes

**2**answers

949 views

### When is a statement provable?

We all know that Gödel showed that there, in a formal system, are true statements that are non-provable (undecidable). In ZFC, there's Kaplansky's Conjecture, the Whitehead problem, etc.
We can also ...

**12**

votes

**3**answers

1k views

### Are there natural examples of mathematical statements which follow from consistency statements?

Motivation
One of the methods for strictly extending a theory $T$ (which is axiomatizable and consistent, and includes enough arithmetic) is adding the sentence expressing the consistency of $T$ ( ...

**60**

votes

**18**answers

7k views

### Can a mathematical definition be wrong?

This question originates from a bit of history. In the first paper on quantum Turing machines, the authors left a key uniformity condition out of their definition. Three mathematicians subsequently ...

**13**

votes

**3**answers

1k views

### Has there ever been a weaker Church-like thesis?

Background. The Church-Turing thesis, in one of its many equivalent formulations, states that the intuitively computable arithmetical functions are exactly those computed by Turing machines.
...

**29**

votes

**15**answers

5k views

### Abstract Thought vs Calculation

Jeremy Avigad and Erich Reck in their remarkable historical paper "Clarifying the nature of the infinite: the development of metamathematics and proof theory" claim that one of the factors of becoming ...

**9**

votes

**6**answers

1k views

### Defining variable, symbol, indeterminate and parameter

Are there precise definitions for what a variable, a symbol, a name, an indeterminate, a meta-variable, and a parameter are?
In informal mathematics, they are used in a variety of ways, and often in ...

**18**

votes

**9**answers

4k views

### Why are proofs so valuable, although we do not know that our axiom system is consistent? [closed]

As a person who has been spending significant time to learn mathematics, I have to admit that I sometimes find the fact uncovered by Godel very upsetting: we never can know that our axiom system is ...

**1**

vote

**2**answers

724 views

### Mathematics of the Anthropic Principle [closed]

A form of the anthropic principle is as follows: "We can observe the universe only because we can exist within it in some way such that we can observe it, and it exists such that we can observe it."
...

**44**

votes

**34**answers

10k views

### nontrivial theorems with trivial proofs

A while back I saw posted on someone's office door a statement attributed to some famous person, saying that it is an instance of the callousness of youth to think that a theorem is trivial because ...

**13**

votes

**2**answers

2k views

### Clarification of Gödel's second incompleteness theorem

I am sorry for the following question, because the actual answer to this question is in the beautiful works of Feferman and Jeroslow, but, unfortunately, I havn't any time to go into that specific ...

**4**

votes

**0**answers

596 views

### BGG category everywhere implies generalized Kazhdan-Lusztig formula?

Maybe this question is vague. I am not an expert on what I asked, if I made mistake, please point out.
BGG category was discoverd in Lie algebra setting. One has Verma module $M(\lambda)$, ...

**17**

votes

**8**answers

4k views

### To what extent is it true that “number theory = mathematics”? [closed]

In a thought-provoking answer to this MO question, Kevin Buzzard
and several commentators have described a multitude of ways in which
number theory is related to other parts of mathematics. It seems ...

**6**

votes

**1**answer

841 views

### Using the multiverse approach to decide the law of the exluded middle?

Recently, in response to deciding the Continuum Hypothesis $CH$, Hamkins and Gitman have proposed consider a multiverse of set-theoretic universes, some in which $CH$ is true, some in which $\neg CH$ ...

**29**

votes

**5**answers

3k views

### Why do categorical foundationalists want to escape set theory?

This is a question that I have seen asked passively in comments relating to the separation of category theory from set theory, but I haven't seen it addressed in full.
I know that it's possible to ...

**7**

votes

**3**answers

756 views

### What are trig classes like within a universe that's “noticeably” hyperbolic?

[I want to think that this question has an answer, but it may be more a "community wiki" discussion. Feel free to re-tag.]
What are trig classes like within a universe that's "noticeably"[*] ...

**0**

votes

**1**answer

524 views

### Formal definition of 'useful' ?

Has anyone worked out a formal, general-enough definition of what is 'useful', so that it could reflectively be used in mathematics? I am aware of the work in utility theory from economics (but ...

**14**

votes

**6**answers

1k views

### Extensional theorems mostly used intensionally

Some theorems are stated and proved extensionally, but in practice are almost always used intensionally. Let me give an example to make this clear -- integration by parts:
$$ \int_a^b f(x)g'(x)ds = ...

**42**

votes

**9**answers

4k views

### How do they verify a verifier of formalized proofs?

In an unrelated thread Sam Nead intrigued me by mentioning a formalized proof of the Jordan curve theorem. I then found that there are at least two, made on two different systems. This is quite an ...

**2**

votes

**3**answers

1k views

### The problem of infinity [closed]

Background and motivation
The following is copied from my blog since someone thought it was the clearest statement I had made regarding a problem I recently posed. On their advice, it is a community ...

**-3**

votes

**2**answers

1k views

### Finite versus infinite on non-Hausdorff topologies [closed]

Question: Does there exist some real-valued function $f(x)$ where $f: \mathbb{R} \to \mathbb{R}$, for which $\lim_{x \to \infty}$ converges on a non-Hausdorff topology but does not converge on a ...

**5**

votes

**5**answers

3k views

### Models of ZFC Set Theory - Getting Started

For just any first-order theory: What are the sets I am supposed/allowed to think of when thinking of models as sets (of something + additional structure)?
Provided:
I can think of models of any ...

**1**

vote

**4**answers

2k views

### Are all mathematical theorems necessarily true?

Define a formal tautology as a statement where by the nature of its atomic components there exists no truth-value assignment where it is not true. A contingent statement is a statement that is true by ...

**43**

votes

**2**answers

5k views

### Lawvere's “Some thoughts on the future of category theory.”

In Lecture Notes in Mathematics 1488, Lawvere writes the introduction to the Proceedings for a 1990 conference in Como.
In this article, Lawvere, the inventor of Toposes and Algebraic Theories, ...

**4**

votes

**1**answer

865 views

### Co-Objects are better [closed]

This is a rather vague question, but perhaps we can talk about it.
There are two types of mathematical objects (which don't exclude each other):
A) There is a good description of morphisms defined ...

**0**

votes

**2**answers

407 views

### In what sense Fraissean view point shows Model Theory can be done without any formal syntax and deduction rule?

In this post I want to look at an issue I was in doubt when looking at the comment of F. G. Dorais in the post In model theory, does compactness easily imply completeness?
F. G. Dorais remark was:
...

**11**

votes

**2**answers

792 views

### Where are we working when we prove metamathematical theorems?

I am posting my comment from this question as a separate question, as was recommended to me.
(EDIT: I'm sorry if it ended up being too similar a question, I just wanted to phrase it in the ...

**32**

votes

**5**answers

3k views

### Were Bourbaki committed to set-theoretical reductionism?

A set-theoretical reductionist holds that sets are the only abstract objects, and that (e.g.) numbers are identical to sets. (Which sets? A reductionist is a relativist if she is (e.g.) indifferent ...

**15**

votes

**10**answers

1k views

### Can you prove equivalence without being able to calculate it?

In mathematics we often seek to classify objects up to an equivalence relation, where two objects A and B are said to be equivalent if there exists a map $f:A\rightarrow B$ satisfying certain ...

**7**

votes

**3**answers

2k views

### randomness in nature [closed]

What is the explanation of the apparent randomness of high-level phenomena in nature?
For example the distribution of females vs. males in a population (I am referring to randomness in terms of the ...

**19**

votes

**3**answers

3k views

### Category of categories as a foundation of mathematics

In
Lawvere, F. W., 1966, “The Category of
Categories as a Foundation for
Mathematics”, Proceedings of the
Conference on Categorical Algebra, La
Jolla, New York: Springer-Verlag,
1–21.
...

**8**

votes

**3**answers

1k views

### categorification of logic

has there be an effort to categorify first order logic? More particularly, structures in the sense of logic.
If so, then every structure of a first order theory is a category. so in particular, the ...

**6**

votes

**4**answers

1k views

### Alternative axiom to induction

Is anyone aware of alternative axioms to induction? To be precise, consider peano axioms without induction PA-. Is there any axiom/axiom schema that is equiconsistent to induction, assuming PA-? If ...

**27**

votes

**5**answers

5k views

### Categorical foundations without set theory

Can there be a foundations of mathematics using only category theory, i.e. no set theory? More precisely, the definition of a category is a class/set of objects and a class/set of arrows, satisfying ...

**1**

vote

**4**answers

469 views

### Does the Golden Ratio Apply to Timing as Well? [closed]

I've seen the golden section applied to art, but does it apply to sound/timing as well? Just curious.

**12**

votes

**2**answers

801 views

### synthetic differential geometry and other alternative theories

There are models of differential geometry in which the intermediate value theorem is not true but every function is smooth. In fact I have a book sitting on my desk called "Models for Smooth ...

**4**

votes

**4**answers

4k views

### Badiou and Mathematics [closed]

Does anyone have an opinion on Alain Badiou's use of set theory? Is there anything interesting mathematically there? Also could anyone shed any light on the comment in the Wikipedia article link text ...

**3**

votes

**2**answers

470 views

### Broken Symmetry

I have a tangled web of ideas about natural transformations, vector spaces, equivalence classes, local coordinates, etc. in my head that I'm trying to unravel. So here are some of the questions I ...