4
votes
1answer
518 views
Why do mathematicians prefer one definition over the other when they both define the same concept?
Here is a basic, though very important, example:
Hilbert takes as primary the notion of “congruence” (or “equal”) between segments. His first axiom of congruence “requires the poss …
11
votes
2answers
378 views
Is this a vertex algebroid?… What is vertex algebroid?
A couple of day ago, I was lamenting to a friend about the fact that I have no idea what vertex algebroids are.
During our discussion, I came up with a guess of what a vertex algeb …
5
votes
4answers
934 views
On similar concepts in mathematics whose similarity is a non-trivial fact.
Recently, while undertaking a study of commutative algebra, I learned three concepts: (i) a local ring, (ii) a regular local ring and (iii) a regular ring.
At the end, I found mys …
2
votes
2answers
133 views
On the definition of ‘smooth vectors’ in Rieffel’s “Deformation Quantization for Actions of $ \mathbb{R}^{d} $”.
On the first page of Chapter 1 of Rieffel's Deformation Quantization for Actions of $ \mathbb{R}^{d} $, Rieffel defines a family of seminorms on the space $ A^{\infty} $ of smooth …
1
vote
2answers
120 views
Understanding the left-separated spaces
A space $X$ is called left-separated if it can be well-ordered in such a way that every initial segment is closed in $X$.
Could someone post some left-separated space to help me u …
42
votes
23answers
17k views
What are the most misleading alternate definitions in taught mathematics?
I suppose this question can be interpreted in two ways. It is often the case that two or more equivalent (but not necessarily semantically equivalent) definitions of the same idea/ …
2
votes
2answers
437 views
Set theory definition of addition, negative numbers, and subtraction? [closed]
Using the definition of natural numbers $0 = \emptyset$ and $S(n) = n \cup \lbrace n \rbrace$ where S is the successor function, what is the definition of addition on natural numbe …
23
votes
11answers
4k views
What does the adjective “natural” actually mean?
Terms like "in the natural way" or "the natural X" are used frequently in mathematical writing. While it is certainly clear most of the time what is meant, on occasion, I have been …
45
votes
16answers
6k views
Can a mathematical definition be wrong?
This question originates from a bit of history. In the first paper on quantum Turing machines, the authors left a key uniformity condition out of their definition. Three mathematic …
8
votes
4answers
950 views
Grothendieck Topologies versus Pretopologies
The wikipedia article(s) as well as the nlab article(s) about Grothendieck topologies and Grothendieck pretopologies are careful to differentiate the two very emphatically and to p …
7
votes
2answers
429 views
What are Penrose Tilings, and how do they relate to Quasicrystals?
The question is in the title, but let me elaborate a little.
Background
Penrose Tilings are really pretty and satisfy some remarkable properties. For instance, I believe the foll …
2
votes
2answers
260 views
Defining the integral of a function using the product measure
Imagine that we're trying to define the expression
$$\int_U f(x)dx$$
in a rigorous way.
Assume that $f:X \rightarrow \mathbb{R}^{\geq 0}$ where $(X,\mu)$ is a measure space, and su …
3
votes
2answers
581 views
A scheme simple over Spec(A)?
What does it mean to say that a scheme $X$ is simple over $Spec(A)$ ?
I stumbled on this terminology in a paper of S. Lubkin entitled "On a conjecture of Andre Weil".
4
votes
3answers
543 views
What makes a distance?
In the answers to my previous question, I learned that there are different concepts of distance, that is of distance-like functions with the usual metric being only the most popula …
14
votes
1answer
649 views
Surreal exponentiation — are the varying definitions equivalent? If not, is there agreement on which ones are better?
The surreal numbers are sometimes introduced as a place where crazy expressions like $(\omega^2+5\omega-13)^{1/3-2/\omega}+\pi$ (to use the nLab's example) make sense. The proble …

