61

19

By a blackbox theorem I mean a theorem that is often applied but whose proof is understood in detail by relatively few of those who use it. A prototypical example is the Classification of Finite Simple Groups (assuming the proof is complete). I think very few people really know the nuts and bolts of the proof but it is widely applied in many areas of mathematics. I would prefer not to include as a blackbox theorem exotic counterexamples because they are not usually applied in the same sense as the Classification of Finite Simple Groups.

I am curious to compile a list of such blackbox theorems with the usual CW rules of one example per answer.

Obviously this is not connected to my research directly so I can understand if this gets closed.

flag
1 
The simpler proofs are still at least 20 pages of fairly technical mathematics though. – Karl Schwede Jun 13 at 21:38
8 
Domain of use is important here. Many theorems are invoked by physicists who have no idea of the actual proofs. – Steve Huntsman Jun 13 at 22:05
6 
@Zsbán: That theorem has nice consequences, e.g., in finite geometry. But treating it as a blackbox is just laziness, since the proof is just a couple of pages of basic graduate algebra. – Felipe Voloch Jun 15 at 0:19
2 
The classification is used by people working on permutation groups and graph theory all the time. Also they are used in profinite group theory. – Benjamin Steinberg Jun 16 at 19:21
2 
In my mind I was hoping for things used in at least 100 papers and understood in all technical detail by fewer than 5% of people in the general area to which the theorem belongs. But it need not be this rigid. – Benjamin Steinberg Jun 17 at 3:08
show 7 more comments

closed as no longer relevant by Benjamin Steinberg, Bill Johnson, Felipe Voloch, Will Jagy, Asaf Karagila Sep 15 at 9:38

60 Answers

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.