# Open subgroups of free profinite groups

The following questions popped out while I was preparing a course on profinite groups.

Closed subgroups of free profinite groups are not necessarily profinite free (e.g. the p-sylow subgroups, or the kernel of the map on the maximum p quotient, and many more other examples) thus the Nielsen-Schreier theorem fails in the profinite category.

Nevertheless, Nielsen-Schreier theorem carries over for open subgroups. The proofs I found (in Field Arithmetic by Fried-Jarden and in Profinite Groups by Ribes-Zalesskii) use the construction of free profinite groups as restricted completion of free abstract groups AND the Schreier basis of a finite indexed subgroup of a free abstract group. By restricted I mean that if X is a basis of a free abstract group, then the completion is w.r.t. the family of finite index normal subgroups that contain all but finitely many elements of X.

First question: can one avoid the use of the Schreier basis in proving that an open subgroup of free profinite is free profinite?

Note that in the finitely generated case the restricted completion is the same as the profinite completion, thus one does not need to use the Schreier basis in this case. Therefore it suffices to affirmatively answer the following.

Second question: is N-S for open subgroups of finitely generated free profinite groups implies N-S for open subgroups of non-finitely generated free profinite groups?

I apologize that the question became a bit lengthy...

-