# definition of group operation in elliptic curves

Hi,

Using the isomorphism between an elliptic curve $E$ and its $Pic_1(E)$ group, one can easily give $E$ the structure of a group variety after choosing a point $O\in E$. The operation that one gets is: $$P+Q+R = 0\text{ in E iff }P+Q+R-3O\text{ (as divisors) is a principal divisor}.$$

• Question: Why is the condition $P+Q+R-3O$ being a principal divisor equivalent to $P+Q+R$ being the intersection divisor of $E$ with a line?

Thanks!

-

This is true if $O$ is an inflexion point. In this case $3O$ is cut out by a line, so $3O$ is linearly equivalent to the intersection of a line with a curve. Thus $P + Q + R$ is linearly equivalent to $3O$ if and only if it is cut out by a line.
@Sasha: good point, it only works if $O$ is an inflexion point. – Joe Silverman Nov 17 '11 at 3:27
I think its worth noting that you can still define the group law even when you choose a point $O$ that is not an inflection point. Thinking of $E \subset \mathbb{P}^2$, if $P,Q \in E$ let $l_{P,Q}$ be the line joining them. Let $R$ be the third point of intersection in $E \cap l_{P,Q}$ then $P+Q \in E$ is the third point of intersection in $E \cap l_{O,R}$. This works because the divisor of $l_{P,Q}/l_{O,R}$ is $P + Q - (P+Q) - O$. In other words, the line bundle $O_E(P - O)\otimes O_E(Q - O)$ is isomorphic to $O_E((P+Q)- O)$. – solbap Nov 17 '11 at 3:57
Rough idea (you can fill in the details): If $P+Q+R-3O$ is a principal divisor, it's the divisor of $f(x,y)$, and $f=0$ intersects $E$ in three points iff $f$ is a linear function, so $P,Q,R$ lie on a line. Converse is pretty clear.