MathOverflow is a question and answer site for professional mathematicians. Join them; it only takes a minute:

Sign up
Here's how it works:
  1. Anybody can ask a question
  2. Anybody can answer
  3. The best answers are voted up and rise to the top

Suppose that $V$ is a locally convex topological vector space and $f:V^2 \to V$ is a bilinear map. Suppose that $C \subseteq V$ is compact and convex, $f$ maps $C^2$ into $C$ and $f \restriction C^2$ is separately continuous. Must $f \restriction C^2$ be jointly continuous?

In the particular application I have in mind, $V = \ell_\infty^*$ with the weak* topology. Moreover the function $f$ is injective. I suspect even in this setting that this is false.

I am also interested in a good reference for the optimal results of concerning separate and joint continuity of bilinear maps. Ideally this would be written for someone who is not a functional analyst.

share|cite|improve this question

A personal obsession is (weakly) almost period functions. Let $G$ be a discrete group (you can work more generally) and for $f\in \ell^\infty(G)$ let $O(f)$ be the set of translate of $f$ by the group action. Set $$ AP(G) = \{ f\in \ell^\infty(G) : O(f)\text{ is relatively compact}\} \\$$ $$WAP(G) = \{ f\in \ell^\infty(G) : O(f)\text{ is weakly relatively compact}\}$$

Then these are unital sub-$C^*$-algebras of $\ell^\infty(G)$ and so have character spaces $G^{AP}$ and $G^{WAP}$. You can extend the product from $G$ to these: then the product on $G^{AP}$ is jointly continuous, but that on $G^{WAP}$ only separately jointly continuous. Translated back to algebra, this means that the measure spaces $M(G^{AP})$ and $M(G^{WAP})$ become Banach algebras for the convolution product. The continuity translates to say that the product on $M(G^{WAP})$ is separately weak$^*$-continuous, and that on $M(G^{AP})$ is even jointly weak$^*$-continuous on bounded sets.

So that gives an example: if $C$ is the closed unit ball of $M(G^{WAP})$ and $f$ is the product map, then $f$ satisfies your requirements, but $f$ is not jointly continuous unless $WAP(G) = AP(G)$ (I think-- this last claim needs a little chasing of definitions). If $G$ is abelian then $G^{AP}$ is the classical Bohr compacitification, but $G^{WAP}$ is much larger. There are books by Berglund (and coauthors) on this topic; they do, IMHO, need a functional analysis background.

Surely there are easier examples for what you want though. (And $f$ is not injective in my example).

share|cite|improve this answer
Thanks. This is in the spirit of what I was lookng for. – Justin Moore Apr 7 '11 at 16:37

Your Answer


By posting your answer, you agree to the privacy policy and terms of service.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.