MathOverflow is a question and answer site for professional mathematicians. Join them; it only takes a minute:

Sign up
Here's how it works:
  1. Anybody can ask a question
  2. Anybody can answer
  3. The best answers are voted up and rise to the top

I just read a quite sketchy proof, where some details were skipped and it appears to me that the proof uses some of the following things. However a (probably very easy) question came up:

Assume that we force with a Boolean algebra of the form $P(A) / I$, where $A$ is an arbitrary set and $I$ is an ideal over $A$; i.e. our forcing conditions are $I$-postive subsets of $A$ and $p \le q$ iff $p \supset q$.

Moreover assume that $P(A) /I$ forces that $\dot{f}$ is a function in $V$ from $A$ to $V$ (where $V$ denotes our ground model), then it follows that there exists a maximal antichain $(S_{\alpha} : \alpha < \lambda)$ in $P(A)/I$ and corresponding functions (lying in $V$ ) $g_{\alpha}$:$A$ $\to V$ such that $S_{\alpha} \Vdash \dot{f} = g_{\alpha}$.

Now if the antichain can be written in a way such that the representatives of the $S_{\alpha}'s$ are even pairwise disjoint then the partial functions $g_{\alpha}\upharpoonright S_{\alpha}$ can be glued together to a new function $g$ and now it should follow that $P(A) / I$ forces that $\dot{f} = g$.

My question now is: How does one see that the $P(A) /I $ forces $\dot{f} =g$ ?

share|cite|improve this question
I don't think your gluing fact is true in the generality you've given. For example, do random forcing and take $\dot{f}$ to name the function which is constantly whatever value the adjoined random real takes at 0. Gluing will net you a $g$ which isn't a constant function. – Justin Palumbo Apr 6 '11 at 15:57
If you're right, Justin then this would explain why I had a hard time proving it. The above 'gluing fact' seems to appear in a lemma in the lecture of my professor, and no one of the sophisticated audience said anything against it. However Jech's book (currently my only source of knowledge at hand) has to say very little about Random Forcing, so I would be glad if you could explain your comment a little bit. – Stefan Hoffelner Apr 6 '11 at 16:49
Take $A$ to be $2^\omega$, and let $I$ be the ideal of all measure zero sets. This is random forcing. Let $X$ be the collection of all members of $2^\omega$ whose first digit is 0, and $Y$ be all those whose first digit is 1. Exactly one of these lie in any generic filter $G$. Let $\dot{f}$ name the function which is constantly 0 if $G$ contains $X$, and constantly 1 if $G$ contains $Y$. Then $X$ and $Y$ together form a maximal antichain, but if you do the gluing process you describe, you get a function which is 0 on $X$ and 1 on $Y$, and so cannot equal $\dot{f}$, whatever it ends up being. – Justin Palumbo Apr 6 '11 at 17:06
(by the way this argument has almost nothing to do with random forcing, and will work for essentially any A and I) – Justin Palumbo Apr 6 '11 at 17:17
Thank you very much Justin – Stefan Hoffelner Apr 6 '11 at 18:44
up vote 2 down vote accepted

The generic subset $G\subseteq P(A)/I$ adjoined by your forcing can be viewed as an ultrafilter on $A$ (disjoint from the ideal $I$). Your glued-together $g$ will (be forced to) be equal to $f$ on a set in this ultrafilter; that is, $g$ and $f$ will represent the same element of the generic ultrapower of $V$. But, as Justin Palumbo noted, they won't generally be equal everywhere.

share|cite|improve this answer
Now, with your help I see that it was just a notational issue: The brackets around $f$ and $g$ (denoting the elements in the generic ultrapower) were missing. Thank you very much. – Stefan Hoffelner Apr 6 '11 at 18:50

Your Answer


By posting your answer, you agree to the privacy policy and terms of service.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.