MathOverflow is a question and answer site for professional mathematicians. Join them; it only takes a minute:

Sign up
Here's how it works:
  1. Anybody can ask a question
  2. Anybody can answer
  3. The best answers are voted up and rise to the top

Dear friends, I have the following question:

Let K be an algebraic number field and [K:Q]=n. Let O_K be a full ring of integers of K. Assume that O \subset O_K is a subring such that rank of O over Z is n (=rk_{Z}O_K). Let pO_K=P_1^e_1 ... P_m^e_m is a decomposition into prime ideals in O_K. (We know that there exists a primary decomposition of ideal pO)

Do we know, how many primary ideals in the decomposition are? Is this number m?

share|cite|improve this question
up vote 3 down vote accepted

You don't say which ideal in $O$ you are trying to decompose. I will guess you mean to decompose the ideal $pO$. The number of primary ideals in a minimal primary ideal decomposition of $pO$ in $O$ need not be the same as the number of prime ideal factors of $pO_K$ in $O_K$.

Example: Pick your favorite prime number $p$ and let $O$ be the ring ${\mathbf Z} + pO_K$. Set ${\mathfrak b} = pO$ and ${\mathfrak P} = pO_K$. Obviously ${\mathfrak b}$ is an ideal in $O$, but note that ${\mathfrak P}$ is also an ideal in $O$ (it's an ideal in the bigger ring $O_K$ which happens to lie in the ring $O$, so it's also an ideal in $O$) and ${\mathfrak P}$ is a prime ideal in $O$ (not necessarily in $O_K$!) since $[O:{\mathfrak P}] = [O:pO_K] = p$ is a prime. Since, set-theoretically, ${\mathfrak b}$ contains ${\mathfrak P}^2 = p^2O_K$ and is contained in ${\mathfrak P}$, ${\mathfrak b}$ is a primary ideal, and thus the minimal primary ideal decomposition of ${\mathfrak b} = pO$ in $O$ is ${\mathfrak b}$ itself. I have put no conditions on $p$ at all here (though we chose $O$ depending on $p$) so for instance you could now let $p$ be a prime number which splits completely in $O_K$ (there are infinitely many of those), and in that case your $m$ is $n$ and that is not the number of ideals in the minimal primary decomposition of ${\mathfrak b} = pO$ in $O$ (well, assuming $K \not= {\mathbf Q}$, so $n > 1$).

The subtlety here is related to the conductor of your ring $O$. The answer to your question would be $m$ for prime numbers that are relatively prime to the conductor of the ring $O$ you use. In the example above, the conductor of $O$ is $pO_K$, which contains $p$ and thus one can anticipate complications.

Perhaps it would help if you explained why you are asking this question.

share|cite|improve this answer
Dear Keith, thank you very much for your detail answer. Here the more precise question. Let $A$ be an abelian variety over a finite field $F_{p^s}$ with endomorphism ring $End(A)$ isomorphic to a subring $O$ in the full the ring of integers $O_K$ of $K\cong End(A)\otimes Q$. I am interested in the minimal primary ideal decomposition of $pO$ in $O$ and the decomposition into primes of $pO_K$ in $O_K$ (where $p=char(F_{p^s})$). In particular, I am interested in the number of such elements in the decompositions – Alexey Zaytsev Mar 29 '11 at 10:14
One more comment, mostly I am interested in unramified case. – Alexey Zaytsev Mar 29 '11 at 14:18

Your Answer


By posting your answer, you agree to the privacy policy and terms of service.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.