MathOverflow is a question and answer site for professional mathematicians. Join them; it only takes a minute:

Sign up
Here's how it works:
  1. Anybody can ask a question
  2. Anybody can answer
  3. The best answers are voted up and rise to the top

Assume $\Gamma$ acts by isometries on a separable Hilbert space $H$, and $$\operatorname{diam} H/\Gamma\le 1.$$ Is it true that $H/\Gamma$ is compact?

Stupid example. Assume the action of $\Gamma$ on $H=\ell_2$ is generated by coordinate translations $x_n\mapsto x_n+\epsilon_n$. Then $$\operatorname{diam} H/\Gamma=\tfrac12\cdot\sqrt{\sum_{n=1}^\infty\epsilon_n^2}.$$ Thus, if $\operatorname{diam} H/\Gamma\le 1$ then $H/\Gamma$ is a quotient of Hilbert cube, and has to be compact.

share|cite|improve this question
Just a thought: Let $H=\ell_2$. Let $\Gamma$ be the subgroup of the additive group of $H$ generated by sequences with integral norms. Then $\Gamma$ acts on $H$ by translations. What is the diameter of $H/\Gamma$ and is the quotient compact? I do not have time to check it myself now. But it should not be that difficult. – Mark Sapir Oct 22 '10 at 0:07
@Anton: Of course you did not say what $\Gamma$ is. – Mark Sapir Oct 22 '10 at 0:09
@Mark: (1) $diam=\infty$ (2) Γ is a group, what else can act? – Anton Petrunin Oct 22 '10 at 1:55
@Anton: Since you have computed the diameter of the quotient, could you then give an example of two orbits arbitrary far apart? I thought of the following argument. Suppose that $f\in \ell_2$ has norm $M$. Subtract $[M]/M \cdot f$ (with integral norm $[M]$), get norm $<1$. Hence the diam. is at most 2. If I do not see something here, did you consider already all subgroups $\Gamma$ of the additive group of $H$ acting by translations? – Mark Sapir Oct 22 '10 at 3:05
@Mark: If the dimension of $H$ is at least 2, the group $\Gamma$ generated by vectors of integral norms is transitive: Given $f \in H, f\neq 0$, connect $v:=\frac{f}{||f||}$ to $-v$ via an arc $\phi\colon [0,1]\to H$ on the unit sphere and consider $w_t:=\phi(t)+f$. By the intermediate value theorem, $||w_{t_0}||$ will be integral for some $t_0$, so $f$ is the difference of two vectors of integral norm. – Guntram Oct 22 '10 at 7:30
up vote 3 down vote accepted

The answer is "NO". To show this let us use the following:

Lemma. Let $L$ be a lattice in $\mathbb R^q$ ($q$ is any positive integer). Assume $$\operatorname{diam} \mathbb R^q/L>1000.$$ Then there is a midpoint $m$ of two points in $L$ such that $|m-x|>1$ for any $x\in L$?

Modulo Lemma one can construct an action of parallel translations the following way: Let us construct inductively a sequence of lattices $L_q$ on $\mathbb R^q$ such that $\mathop{diam} \mathbb R^q/L_q<1000$ and such that $|x|>1$ for any $x\in L$. Start with standard $L_1=\mathbb Z$ in $\mathbb R$. To construct $L_{q}$ take $$L_{q}'=L_{q-1}\times \mathbb Z\subset \mathbb R^{q-1}\times\mathbb R = \mathbb R^{q}.$$ If $\mathop{diam} \mathbb R^q/L'_q < 1000$ set $L_q = L'_q$. Othewise pass to the minimal lattice which contains $L'_q$ and the midpoint provided by the Lemma. Applying this construction finitely many times you get a lattice $L_q$ with $\mathop{diam} \mathbb R^q/L_q<1000$.

Continue the process, we get lattice $L_\infty$ in $H$ which is a $1000$-net, its fundamental doamin contains a ball of radius 1; i.e. $H/L_\infty$ is not compact.

Proof of Lemma. For $z\in\mathbb R^q$, denote by $\rho(z)$ the minimal distance to a point in $L$. Take a point $z\in\mathbb R^q$ which maximize distance to $L$. So $\rho(z)\ge 1000$. Then there is a couple of points $x,y\in L$ such that $\angle xzy\ge\pi/2$ and $|x-z|=|x-z|=\rho(z)$. Let $m$ be the midpoint for $x$ and $y$. Then $$|z-m|\le \frac{\rho(z)}{\sqrt{2}}$$ and therefore the distance from $m$ to any point of $L$ is at least $1000{\cdot}(1-\tfrac1{\sqrt{2}})>1$. $\square$

share|cite|improve this answer

Your Answer


By posting your answer, you agree to the privacy policy and terms of service.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.