MathOverflow is a question and answer site for professional mathematicians. Join them; it only takes a minute:

Sign up
Here's how it works:
  1. Anybody can ask a question
  2. Anybody can answer
  3. The best answers are voted up and rise to the top

I was not sufficiently clear on my last attempt at asking a similar (but not identical) question. Tom Goodwillie mentioned (in the accepted answer) that the question can be reduced to this one and mentioned a fact of which I was unaware, but after trying to prove this for the past day, I have returned to ask for a sketch of the proof:

Let $X$ be a simplicial set, and let $p:X\to \Delta^n$ be a right fibration (has the right lifting property with respect to all right horn inclusions (equivalently, it has the right lifting property with respect to the maps $$\Delta^1\times A\coprod_{\{1\}\times A}\{1\}\times B\to \Delta^1\times B$$ for any inclusion $A\hookrightarrow B$). (These generate the same weakly saturated class of maps)).

Let $i_0:\{0\}\hookrightarrow \Delta^n$ be the inclusion of the 0th vertex of $\Delta^n$. We'd like to show that the pullback of this map by $p$ (i.e. the induced map $f:X\times_{\Delta^n} \{0\}\hookrightarrow X$) is a deformation retract.

According to Tom, we can use the second characterization of right fibrations to obtain some kind of lifting of the homotopy and retraction for $i_0$ (which is a deformation retract).

Would somebody mind sketching the proof?

Edit: If this question is answered by 2AM EST (roughly three hours and forty-five minutes from the time of this current edit), I will award the answerer with a 450 point bounty as soon as it becomes possible (one must wait 48 hours from when the question was asked).

share|cite|improve this question
The reason I am offering this bounty within this time limit is that I'm currently trying to read a proof where this fact is used at least four times. I'd like to understand why it's true before continuing. – Harry Gindi Jul 2 '10 at 2:22
up vote 4 down vote accepted

Harry, let $Y$ be the fiber of $X\to\Delta^n$ over the 0th vertex. The sense in which $Y$ is going to be a deformation retract of $X$ is going to be the following: There is a map $\Delta^1\times X\to X$ such that (1) on $1\times X$ it's the identity and (2) on $\Delta^1\times Y$ it's the constant homotopy (i.e. projection to $Y$ followed by inclusion) and (3) it takes $0\times X$ to $Y$. This is the same sense in which the 0th vertex is a deformation retract of $\Delta^n$.

So make a square in which the upper left object is $\Delta^1\times Y\cup 1\times X$, the lower left is $\Delta^1\times X$, the left map is inclusion, the right-hand map is the given right fibration $p:X\to \Delta^n$, the upper map is inclusion into $\Delta^1\times X$ followed by projection of $\Delta^1\times X$ to $X$, and the lower map is $Id\times p$ to $\Delta^1\times \Delta^n$ followed by the deformation retraction to $\Delta^n$.

A slanting arrow $\Delta^1\times X\to X$ making the triangles commute will have the desired restriction to $\Delta^1\times Y\cup 1\times X$ because of the upper triangle, and will take $0\times X$ into $Y$ because of the lower triangle.

share|cite|improve this answer
Dear Tom, that's literally exactly how I did it when I was trying to prove it myself. What I couldn't show is that the restriction to $\{0\}\times X$ maps into $Y$. – Harry Gindi Jul 2 '10 at 2:51
You've got it now, right? 0xX goes into Y because it's related to this other map that takes 0xDelta^n into 0th vertex. I would have answered earlier, but I've been busy all day. – Tom Goodwillie Jul 2 '10 at 2:57
Lower triangle says pH=h(Id x p). Apply h(Id x p) to 0 x X. Id x p takes 0 x X into 0 x Delta^n. h takes 0 x Delta^n into 0th vertex. So pH takes 0 x X into 0th vertex, so H takes 0 x X into Y. – Tom Goodwillie Jul 2 '10 at 3:19
Harry, if on Thursday morning I had bothered to say 'I'll get back to you with a fuller explanation tonight' then you would have had no need to offer a bounty. In an odd way I'm being rewarded for unresponsiveness. You should keep the points. Also, as an old person to a young person let me put in a good word for patience. – Tom Goodwillie Jul 2 '10 at 15:04
I will accept the bounty in the spirit in which it is offered. – Tom Goodwillie Jul 3 '10 at 20:14

Your Answer


By posting your answer, you agree to the privacy policy and terms of service.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.