Welcome to MathOverflow

Question

8

1

We have no topologists on our faculty, and from time to time I get to teach our topology course. I know that there are examples of inequivalent knots with the same Homfly polynomial, and I know that there are non-trivial knots with trivial Alexander polynomial, but I don't know whether the question has been settled as to whether there is a non-trivial knot (or link?) with a trivial Homfly polynomial. I'd like to give my students up-to-date information on this, and being outside the area I don't know quite where to look.

edited May 25 2010 at 0:10

asked May 24 2010 at 6:27

Gerry Myerson
15.6k●1●47●87

1

Wikipedia says it's open whether there even exists a nontrivial knot with trivial Jones polynomial, although of course it's unclear how up to date that information is. – Qiaochu Yuan May 24 2010 at 6:35

1

That's true to the best of my knowledge. On the other hand, it's now known no knot has trivial HOMFLY homology by work of Mrowka and Kronheimer. – Ben Webster♦ May 24 2010 at 12:58

Roland van der Veen · Accepted Answer · 2010-05-24 10:16:16Z UTC

4

All I know is that in their 2003 paper Eliahou, Kauffman and Thistlethwaite write that they did not find any links with trivial HOMFLY-PT. Although they do find links with both trivial Jones and Alexander.

http://www.math.uic.edu/~kauffman/ekt.pdf

My guess would be there exist links with trivial HOMFLY-PT but no such knots.

Although as Qiaochu mentions it is still open whether there are knots with trivial Jones, Joergen Andersen claims on his website that there are no knots with trivial Colored Jones. (a.k.a Jones of all the cables of the knot)

http://home.imf.au.dk/andersen/

edited May 24 2010 at 10:16

answered May 24 2010 at 9:58

Roland van der Veen
531●2●7

1

You might be interested in these results of Matthew Hedden and Liam Watson about Khovanov homology and its colored variants detecting the unknot: front.math.ucdavis.edu/0805.4423 and front.math.ucdavis.edu/0805.4418 – Sammy Black May 24 2010 at 14:48

My thanks to all who responded to my question. I hope my acceptance of an answer will not stop anyone who has more to say from posting. – Gerry Myerson May 25 2010 at 0:20

1

Kronheimer & Mrowka have announced that Khovanov homology detects the unknot: msri.org/communications/vmath/VMathVideos/… – Agol May 25 2010 at 1:53

1

The link to Kronheimer & Mrowka's preprint is here arxiv.org/abs/1005.4346 – jc May 25 2010 at 20:11

Is there a non-trivial knot with trivial Homfly polynomial?

Remember to vote up questions/answers you find interesting or helpful (requires 15 reputation points)

1 Answer

You can accept an answer to one of your own questions by clicking the check mark next to it. This awards 15 reputation points to the person who answered and 2 reputation points to you.