MathOverflow is a question and answer site for professional mathematicians. Join them; it only takes a minute:

Sign up
Here's how it works:
  1. Anybody can ask a question
  2. Anybody can answer
  3. The best answers are voted up and rise to the top

Let $X$ be a topological vector space (or, perhaps, more generally uniform space). Let $A\subset X$ be a subset. Let $A^s$ denote the set of limits of all convergent sequences (I guess $A^s$ is called sequential closure of $A$, but I am not sure). If $X$ is not metrizable, then $A^s$ may not be closed or even sequentially closed. Thus one may repeat the procedure of taking "sequential closure".

By transfinite induction, for any ordinal $\omega$ one defines $A^\omega$ as follows:

1) if $\omega=1$ then $A^\omega:=A^s$;

2) if $\omega=\omega'+1$ then $A^\omega=(A^{\omega'})^s$;

3) if $\omega$ is a limit ordinal then $A^\omega=\cup_{\omega'<\omega}A^{\omega'}$.

It is easy to see that there exists sufficiently large ordinal $\eta_0$ such that the process stabilizes: for any $\eta\geq \eta_0$ one has $A^{\eta}=A^{\eta_0}$. In particular $A^{\eta_0}$ is sequentially closed.

QUESTIONS. (1) Is there a standard name and notation of $A^{\eta_0}$?

(2) Does $A^{\eta_0}$ have to be topologically closed? Particularly I am interested in the situation when $X$ is a locally convex vector space, and $A$ is a linear subspace.

share|cite|improve this question
You probably already know of it, but in case not I mention that the paper of Ostrovskii and the references contained therein may be of interest; consideration of this idea was included in the appendix to Banach's book. – Philip Brooker Jun 8 '14 at 6:50
@PhilipBrooker: thanks for the reference. As I learned from it just now (and already checked in the source), the sequential closures of transfinite order (this is the terminology used in the paper) were already introduced by Banach in his classical book " Th/'eorie des op/'erations lineares", 1932 (see p. 213). – sva Jun 8 '14 at 13:54

This answer on math.SE discusses the operator $A \mapsto A^{\eta_0}$ obtained by transfinitely iterating the sequential closure until stabilization is reached. It gives it the notation $\operatorname{scl}^*$. I don't know if the notation is standard, but the author of that answer is a general topologist, so there's some authority there.

By the way, the least ordinal $\eta_0$ such that iterating the sequential closure $\eta_0$ times gives you $\operatorname{scl}^*$ is called the sequential order of the space.

You ask if $\operatorname{scl}^*(A)$ is necessarily closed. Since $A \subset \operatorname{scl}^*(A) \subset \overline{A}$, this happens iff $\operatorname{scl}^*(A) = \overline{A}$: a space satisfying this property for all subsets is called sequential. These facts, together with some references, appear in $\S$ 2.2 of my notes on convergence. Perhaps the easiest example (= Example 2.1.5 in my notes) of a nonsequential space is an uncountable set endowed with the cocountable topology, in which a proper subset is closed precisely when it is countable. This space is sequentially discrete -- the only convergent sequences are the eventually constant ones -- so every subset is sequentially closed.

I am not a functional analyst (nor a topologist!), but it is my understanding that yes, non-sequential spaces arise in functional analysis. Now being equipped with the necessary terminology, you should have little trouble (less than me, probably) tracking down examples.

share|cite|improve this answer

Let $I$ be an uncountable set, and give $\mathbb{R}^{I}$ the product topology. Then $\mathbb{R}^{I}$ becomes a complete locally convex topological vector space. Let $A\subseteq\mathbb{R}^{I}$ be the set of all sequences $(x_{i})_{i\in I}$ such that $x_{i}\neq 0$ for at most countably many indices. Then $A$ is a sequentially closed, but $A$ is dense in $\mathbb{R}^{I}$, so $A$ is not closed.

share|cite|improve this answer

Such concepts have been studied intensively in functional analysis, in particular for spaces of continuous functions with pointwise convergence. You could start by googling "angelic spaces". Authors who spring to mind: Floret, Fremlin, Orihuela and many others.

share|cite|improve this answer

Your Answer


By posting your answer, you agree to the privacy policy and terms of service.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.