Take the 2-minute tour ×
MathOverflow is a question and answer site for professional mathematicians. It's 100% free, no registration required.

For a field $L$, let $\widetilde L$ be the splitting field of all irreducible polynomials over $L$ having prime-power degree.

Question: Do we have $\widetilde{\mathbf Q}=\overline{\mathbf Q}$?

My money is on "no", because I see no obvious reason why it should be true. If the answer is indeed negative, can one say what degree occurs as the smallest degree of an $f\in \mathbf Q[X]$ which does not split in $M$?

In any case, it seems quite difficult (to me)...

A variation: We have a chain $$L \subset \widetilde L \subset \widetilde {\widetilde L} \subset \dots$$ Let $\widehat L$ be the limit of this chain. Is it even true that $\widehat{\mathbf Q}=\overline{\mathbf Q}$? Does the chain stabilize? The field $\widehat{\mathbf Q}$ has the strange property of having no finite extensions of prime-power degree. Correspondingly, the Galois group $\text{Gal }(\overline{\mathbf Q}/\widehat{\mathbf Q})$ has the strange property of having no open subgroups of prime-power index...

For $L$ a finite field, it is easy to see that $\widetilde{L}=\overline{L}$. We obviously have $\widetilde{\mathbf R}=\overline{\mathbf R}$. I do not know if $\widetilde{\mathbf Q_p}=\overline{\mathbf Q_p}$, or if $\widehat{\mathbf Q_p}=\overline{\mathbf Q_p}$. (Edit: Every finite Galois extension of $\mathbf Q_p$ is solvable, and I believe it follows from this that $\widehat{\mathbf Q_p}=\overline{\mathbf Q_p}$.)

(I have asked this on MSE: please see the discussion there.)

share|improve this question
Obviously $\tilde{L}$ contains all abelian (or even nilpotent) Galois extensions of $L$, and therefore $\hat{L}$ contains all solvable extensions of $L$. –  YCor Jun 3 at 20:25
The question is tricker than one could expect (see the discussion on MSE!). For instance it's possible that $L$ contains a Galois extension of $L$ with Galois group the alternating group $A_6$. Indeed, let $A_6$ act on $F_p^5$ in a standard way. Then in the semidirect product $G=A_6\ltimes F_p^5$, the intersection of conjugates of $A_6$ is trivial. Thus if one has a Galois extension $L\subset L'$ with Galois group $G$, then this Galois extension is generated by splitting fields of polynomial of $p$-power degree. (...) –  YCor Jun 3 at 20:32
(...) because $A_6$ has $p$-power index in $G$ and the intersection of conjugates of $A_6$ in $G$ is trivial. On the other hand, $L'$ admits a smaller Galois extension $L''$ with Galois group $A_6$ over $L$, which contains no subextension $\neq L$ of prime power degree (because $A_6$ has no proper subgroup of prime power index), still we have $L''\subset L'\subset\tilde{L}$. Such extensions can be found on a suitable field of characteristic zero, and probably over $\mathbf{Q}$. –  YCor Jun 3 at 20:35
add comment

1 Answer 1

up vote 31 down vote accepted

$\def\QQ{\mathbb{Q}}$Building on YCor's construction, your field is $\overline{\mathbb{Q}}$. Let $L$ be any finite Galois extension of $\QQ$ with Galois group $G$; I will show that $L$ is contained in your field.

We can find an element $x$ in $L$ so that, for any nonempty subset $S$ of $G$, the product $\prod_{\sigma \in S} x^{\sigma}$ is not square. For example, choose $x$ to generate a principal prime ideal of $L$ lying over a prime of $\mathbb{Q}$ which is completely split in $L$. Let $M$ be the result of adjoining to $L$ all square roots $\sqrt{x^{\sigma}}$, for all $\sigma \in G$. So $Gal(M/\mathbb{Q}) \cong G \ltimes (\mathbb{Z}/2)^G$, where the first $G$ acts by permuting the factors in the second $G$.

Let $F \subset M$ be the fixed field of $G \ltimes \{ 0 \}$. This group has index $2^{|G|}$ in $Gal(M/\mathbb{Q})$, so $[F:\QQ]=2^{|G|}$. Let $f$ be the minimal polynomial of a primitive element of $F$. So $f$ splits in your field. Thus, your field contains $F$ and all Galois conjugates of $F$. But the intersection $\bigcap_{h \in G \ltimes (\mathbb{Z}/2)^G} h (G \ltimes \{ 0 \}) h^{-1}$ is trivial, so the collection of Galois conjugates of $F$ generates $M$. We have shown that your field contains $M$, and hence contains $L$.

share|improve this answer
Nice. In other words, this shows that every Galois extension of $\mathbf{Q}$ of degree $d$ is contained in the splitting field of a polynomial of degree $2^d$ (the splitting field having degree $d2^d$). –  YCor Jun 4 at 12:32
Very nice (and, for me, unexpected!) –  Bruno Joyal Jun 4 at 12:44
@DavidSpeyer: Why is the extension $1\to(\mathbf{Z}/2)^G\to Gal(M/\mathbf{Q})\to G\to 1$ split? –  YCor Jun 4 at 13:05
Right, but probably working harder than is necessary: The field was just being used as a convenient thing for the groups to act on. I think the following is a restatement in the language of groups: Given $1 \to A^G \to E \to G \to 1$, choose a set-theoretic section $s: G \to E$. Define $\Gamma \subset E$ to be the group sending the set $s(G)$ to itself. I think you should get that $\Gamma \to G$ is an isomorphism. (Maybe I'll assign this next time I teach group theory :).) –  David Speyer Jun 4 at 16:51
Dear David: if you'd like to post your beautiful answer at MSE also, I'll happily accept it there as well. Cheers! –  Bruno Joyal Jun 9 at 2:56
show 8 more comments

Your Answer


By posting your answer, you agree to the privacy policy and terms of service.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.