MathOverflow is a question and answer site for professional mathematicians. Join them; it only takes a minute:

Sign up
Here's how it works:
  1. Anybody can ask a question
  2. Anybody can answer
  3. The best answers are voted up and rise to the top

Let $S$ be a $C^2$-regular hypersurface with $S=\partial V$ for some open set $V \subset R^{N+1}$, and let $\nu(P)$ be the exterior unit normal of $S$ with respect to $V$.

Assume that $S$ satisfies the R-sphere condition, that is for every $P\in S$ the tangent balls $B^\pm(P,R):= \{Q \in R^{N+1}: \ |P\pm R \nu(P) - Q|<R\}$ do not contain any points of $S$.

Let the origin $O\in S$ and assume that $\nu(O)=e_{N+1}$. By the implicit function theorem we know that $S$ can be written locally as a graph of function. In particular, there exists $r>0$ and a real valued function $u$ such that $$ \{ (x,u(x)): |x|<r \} \subset S .$$

**Can we conclude that $r=R$ **?

I proved that this is true for $N=1$ as sketched in the following. By writing the touching balls at $O$ we obtain that $$ |u(x)| \leq \rho - \sqrt{\rho^2-x^2},\quad |x|<\rho. $$ If we assume that $\nu((x_0,u(x_0))) \cdot e_2 = 0$ for some $|x_0|<\rho$, then the centers $C^\pm$ of the two touching balls at $(x_0,u(x_0))$ must satisfy $|C^\pm|\geq \rho$ (otherwise one of the two touching balls will contain the origin). By writing down the inequality and using the above estimate on $u$ we find a contradiction.

Unfortunately, it seems to me that the same argument does not work for $N\geq 2$.

share|cite|improve this question
up vote 3 down vote accepted

It is true and not too hard. WLOG, $R=1$

Let $p,q$ be two points on $S$. Let $a$,$b$ be the outer unit normals to $S$ at $p$ and $q$ respectively. Let $v=\overline {pq}$. Since $B(p-a,1)\cap B(q+b,1)=\varnothing$, we have $|a+b+v|^2\ge 4$. Since $B(p+a,1)\cap B(q-b,1)=\varnothing$, we get $|a+b-v|^2\ge 4$. Adding those up, opening the parentheses, dividing by $4$, and expressing $(a,b)=\cos\theta$ where $\theta$ is the angle between $a,b$, we get $\cos\theta+\frac{|v|^2}2\ge 1$, which, for infinitesimally small $v$, means $\theta\le|v|$, i.e., if you move along any curve on $S$, the angle between the normals at the endpoints of the curve is at most the curve length.

The rest is trivial: to define the function at $x\in\mathbb R^n$ with $|x|<1$ just start moving along $S$ at speed $1$ so that the projection of your velocity vector to $\mathbb R^n$ points at $x$. You have no trouble as long as the scalar product of the normal with $e_{n+1}$ stays positive, i.e., the length $\frac\pi 2$ is always yours. But, since the normal to the surface rotates not faster than you go, your projected speed pointed toward $x$ is at least the cosine of the distance your travelled, so you are doomed to reach $x$ (because $\int_0^{\frac\pi 2}\cos \ell\,d\ell=1>|x|$). The continuity and smoothness of the resulting function is just the usual mumbo-jumbo about the dependence of a solution to a parametric ODE on the parameters.

This will make an excellent problem for a qualifier exam in differential geometry. Thanks for the idea! :-)

share|cite|improve this answer
I think that once we have that $\cos\theta+\frac{|v|^2}2\ge 1$, then can conclude easily by using that $$|v|^2 \leq |x|^2 + (1-\sqrt{1-|x|^2})^2,$$ for $|x|\leq1$, which follows by writing the touching spheres at $O$. Indeed we find that $\cos\theta \geq \sqrt{1-|x|^2}$ and we conclude. Thank you again for your answer! – pedro May 17 '14 at 13:20

Your Answer


By posting your answer, you agree to the privacy policy and terms of service.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.