MathOverflow is a question and answer site for professional mathematicians. Join them; it only takes a minute:

Sign up
Here's how it works:
  1. Anybody can ask a question
  2. Anybody can answer
  3. The best answers are voted up and rise to the top

I read a lemma 1.12 in Tobias H.Colding's paper "Ricci curvature and volume convergence"."Suppose that $Ri{c_{{M^n}}} \ge \left( {n - 1} \right)\Lambda {R^{ - 2}}$,p and $q \in M$ with d(p,q)>8R,and ${b^ + } = d\left( {q, \cdot } \right) - d\left( {q,p} \right)$.Furthermore,let b be the harmonic function on ${B_{4R}}\left( p \right)$ with $b\left| {{S_{4R}}} \right.\left( p \right) = {b^ + }\left| {{S_{4R}}} \right.\left( p \right)$.Then$$\int_{{B_R}\left( p \right)} {{{\left| {Hess\left( b \right)} \right|}^2}} \le C\left( {\Lambda ,n} \right){R^{ - 2}}Vol\left( {{B_R}\left( p \right)} \right)$$.After proving when R=1,we use the metric Rg instead of g.Then $$Vo{l_{Rg}}\left( {{B_R}\left( p \right)} \right) = {R^n}Vo{l_g}\left( {{B_1}\left( p \right)} \right)$$.In metric Rg, $$\left| {Hess\left( b \right)} \right| = {R^{ - 2}}\left| {Hess\left( b \right)} \right|$$ in metric g.So$$\int_{{B_R}\left( p \right)} {{{\left| {Hess\left( b \right)} \right|}^2}} = {R^n}\int_{{B_1}\left( p \right)} {{R^{ - 4}}{{\left| {Hess\left( b \right)} \right|}^2}} \le C\left( {\Lambda ,n} \right){R^{ - 4}}Vo{l_{Rg}}\left( {{B_R}\left( p \right)} \right)$$.I get${R^{ - 4}}$ instead of ${R^{ - 2}}$.Where I am wrong?

share|cite|improve this question

You made several mistakes.

First, you should apply the result with $R=1$ to the manifold $(M,R^{-2}g)$, so that the unit ball in this scaled metric equals the $R$-size ball in the metric $g$.

Second, the correct scaling of the norm of the Hessian of a function $f$ is $|Hess(f)|^2_{g}=R^{-4}|Hess(f)|^2_{R^{-2}g}$.

Third, in Colding's paper, the function $f$ needs to be rescaled as well! In particular, the function $b$ for the metric $R^{-2}g$ is $R^{-2}$ times the corresponding function $b$ for the metric $g$.

Putting all these together, you get the correct statement claimed by Colding.

share|cite|improve this answer
@YangMills:Thank you!But I think ${R^{ - 1}}$ times instead. – jiangsaiyin Jun 18 '13 at 3:14
Rescaling the metric tensor by $R^{-2}$ rescales distances like $R^{-1}$, which is what you want. – YangMills Jun 18 '13 at 13:50

Your Answer


By posting your answer, you agree to the privacy policy and terms of service.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.