MathOverflow is a question and answer site for professional mathematicians. It's 100% free, no registration required.

Sign up
Here's how it works:
  1. Anybody can ask a question
  2. Anybody can answer
  3. The best answers are voted up and rise to the top

Given a group $G$, we denote by $T(G)$ the subgroup generated by all (maximal) normal abelian subgroups of $G$.

Let define the series $(T_i(G))$ by $T_0(G)=1$ and $T_{i+1}(G)/T_i(G)=T(G/T_i(G)$, and $n(G)$ to be the smallest integer such that $T_n(G)=G$.

1) Can one produce finite p-groups $G$ with arbitrary large n(G)?

2) If $G$ is a finite p-group, what can one say in general about the index of $T(G)$ in $G$.

3) I found that the nilpotency class of $T(G)$ (assuming just that $G$ is finite), can not exceed $s$, where $s$ is the cardinal of the set of conjugacy class sizes in $G$. In fact if $1 \lt n_1 \lt ... \lt n_s$ are the conjugacy class sizes of $G$, we define $H_i$ to be the subgroup generated by the elements with conj class sizes $\leq n_i$, we use a result of Mann and Isaacs to show that $T(G)$ is a stability group of the series $H_i$ and the claim follows from a well known result of Kaloujnin.

Is this result trivial ?

share|cite|improve this question
I changed the symbols < to \lt ; usage of the former caused problems as they have a different meaning on this site. (There are severral such issues; as a general alternative workaround one can include the math withing dollar symbols that does not render properly withing additional backticks ` both at the beginning and the end a backtick, or include the relevant paragraph in p tags, that is <p> at the start and </p> at the end) – quid Jun 17 '13 at 16:25
Many thanks dear quid. – Yassine Guerboussa Jun 17 '13 at 16:38
what are examples of $p$-groups $G$ with $n(G)>1$? (i.e, $T(G)\neq G$). – YCor Jun 17 '13 at 20:45
@Yves Cornulier : There exist p-groups of a maximal class with a maximal subgroup that is abelian (for instance the dihedral groups $D_{2^n}$), if G is such a group with A maximal abelian, then T(G)=A or G has class 2. So if the order of G is large enough, n(G)>1. – Yassine Guerboussa Jun 18 '13 at 14:10
Anyway, OK I'm convinced that the dihedral group of order $2^n\ge 16$ satisfies $n(G)=2$. Note that it can be embedded in a group of upper triangular matrices over $\mathbf{Z}/2\mathbf{Z}$ with 1 on the diagonal, and the latter satisfies $n(G)=1$. In particular, $n$ can, unlike the nilpotency or solvability length, increase when passing to subgroups. – YCor Jun 19 '13 at 8:45
up vote 3 down vote accepted

The answer to question 1 is yes. We will demonstrate a way to add one to $n(G)$, so $n(G)$ can be any natural number.

Given a group $G$, and an abelian group $A$, take a faithful action of $G$ on $A$, and consider the semidirect product $A \rtimes G$ .

We need the following condition: If $g$ is a nontrivial element of $g$, then there exists $a \in A$ such that $g^2(a)-2g(a)+a\neq 0$. Such an action on an abelian group exists for every $G$. For instance, this is satisfied by the regular representation of $G$ over $\mathbb F_p$ for $p$ odd and the regular representation of $G$ over $\mathbb Z/4$ when $p=2$.

Then we will show that $T(A \rtimes G)=A$, so $n(A \rtimes G) = n(G)+1$. $A$ is abelian and normal, so contained in $T(G)$, so we must only check that each abelian normal subgroup is contained in $A$. Suppose instead that $H$ is an abelian normal subgroup containing an element $x$ which projects to a nontrivial element $g$ of $G$. Let $a$ be an element of $H$, then

$$g(a)-a=(xax^{-1}) a^{-1} =x (ax^{-1}a^{-1}) \in H$$

by normality.

Since $H$ is abelian, $g(a)-a$ commutes with $x$, so $g (g(a)-a) - g(a)-a =0$, so $g^2(a)-2g(a) +a=0$, but this cannot hold for all $a$, so there is a contradiction.

share|cite|improve this answer
Very good answer Will Sawin. Thank you and best wishes. – Yassine Guerboussa Aug 5 '13 at 17:38

The answer to Qustion 2 is that the index of $T(G)$ in $G$ can be unboundedly large. The reason is that if $G = X \times Y$, the direct product, then $T(G) = T(X) \times T(Y)$. Thus, for example, if $G$ is the direct product of $n$ copies of a dihedral group of order $16$, then $|G:T(G)| = 2^n$. To prove this lemma on direct products, it suffices to show that if $U$ is maximal normal abelian in $G$, then $D = A \times B$, where $A$ and $B$ are maximal normal abelian in $X$ and $Y$, respectively.

Here is the argument. Let $P = XD$ and note that $P/X$ is abelian. Let $B = P \cap Y$, so $B$ is abelian and $P = XB$. Now $B$ is a direct factor of $P$ and hence is central in $P$. It follows that $B \subseteq D$, and thus $D = A \times B$, where $A = D \cap X$. Since $D$ is maximal normal abelian in $G$, both $A$ and $B$ are normal, and we see that they must be maximal abelian normal in $X$ and $Y$, respectively.

share|cite|improve this answer
Thank you Professor M. Isaacs. – Yassine Guerboussa Aug 5 '13 at 17:39

The Sylow subgroup $\Sigma_n$ of the Symmetric group $S_{p^n}$ has only one maximal normal abelian subgroup, say $B$, for $p>2$ and $n>1$. As $\Sigma_n/B$ is isomorphic to
$\Sigma_{n-1}$, the group $\Sigma_n$ yields a positive answers on Questions 1 and 2.


share|cite|improve this answer

Your Answer


By posting your answer, you agree to the privacy policy and terms of service.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.