MathOverflow is a question and answer site for professional mathematicians. It's 100% free, no registration required.

Sign up
Here's how it works:
  1. Anybody can ask a question
  2. Anybody can answer
  3. The best answers are voted up and rise to the top

Consider a fixed smooth algebraic curve $C$ over $\mathbb C$. It is well-known that $\mathbb CP^3$ contains curves that are abstractly isomorphic to $C$. What is the minimal degree of a curve in $\mathbb CP^3$, abstractly isomorphic to $C$, which is not on any cubic surface?

share|cite|improve this question
The minimum degree of a smooth rational curve that is not contained in any cubic surface is 7. – Charles Staats May 26 '13 at 19:22
and how to get it? It seems that the claim is that on a cubic there is no a one-dimensional family of rational curves of degree 7... – Nikita Kalinin May 26 '13 at 20:03
Not exactly. The claim is that if $C$ is a general rational curve of degree 7, then there is no cubic hypersurface containing $C$. There are some rather involved ways to see this by "pure thought," but one can also simply choose a degree 7 rational curve with random coefficients and compute (using Macaulay2, for instance) its homogeneous ideal. If you do this, you will see that the homogeneous ideal contains no polynomials of degree $\leq 3$. – Charles Staats May 26 '13 at 20:12
to Charles Staats: Thank you! I just had in mind dimension computations: there is 20-dimensional space of rational curves degree 7 and 19-dimensional space of cubic surfaces. – Nikita Kalinin May 27 '13 at 18:30
Nikita: I have edited your question in an attempt to clarify your intent, as I now understand it. Obviously, you should feel free to modify/undo any or all of my edits. – Charles Staats May 27 '13 at 20:27

NOTE: The following addressed an earlier version of the question in which it was not clear that the abstract isomorphism type of the curve $C$ was supposed to be fixed. Thus, the hypothesis "if I have correctly understood the question" is false.

The answer is seven, if I have correctly understood the question.

Claim 1: If $C$ is an irreducible curve in $\mathbb P^3$ of degree $d \leq 6$, then there exists a cubic surface containing $C$.

Proof: First, note that it suffices to prove that there exists a cubic surface containing $3d+1$ distinct points on $C$. This is because a degree $3$ surface that does not contain $C$ can intersect $C$ in at most $3\cdot\deg C$ distinct points.

The complete linear system of all cubic surfaces in $\mathbb P^3$ has dimension $\binom{3+3}{3}-1 = 19$. If $V$ is any linear system and $p$ is a point, then the subsystem of $V$ consisting of divisors containing $p$ has dimension either $\dim V$ or $\dim V - 1$. Thus, if we choose $3d+1$ points on $C$, the space of all cubic surfaces containing these $3d+1$ points has dimension greater than or equal to $$19-(3d+1) = 18-3d.$$ If $d \leq 6$, then this dimension is nonnegative, showing that the space of cubics containing these points is nonempty. $\square$

Claim 2: If $C$ is a general rational curve in $\mathbb P^3$ of degree $d \geq 7$, then $C$ is not contained in any cubic surface.

Proof: First, by semicontinuity, it suffices to show that there exists a (possibly reducible) genus zero curve of degree $d$ that is not contained in any cubic surface. If $d=7$, such a curve may be exhibited as the image of the morphism $$[t,s] \mapsto [t^{7}, \,s t^{6}+s^{2} t^5,\,s^{5} t^{2}+s^{6} t,\,s^{2} t^{5}-s^{7}]$$ from $\mathbb P^1 \to \mathbb P^3$. Computing the homogeneous ideal of polynomials that vanish on its image (e.g., using Macaulay2) will reveal that no homogeneous polynomials of degree $\leq 3$ vanish on this rational curve.

If $d > 7$, take a union $C = C'' \cup C'$, where $C''$ is a rational curve of degree $7$ that does not lie on any cubic surface and $C'$ is a rational curve of degree $d-7$ such that the two curves intersect in exactly one point (which is a node). Clearly, $C$ is not contained in any cubic surface; a generic deformation of $C$ will be a smooth rational curve of degree $d$, and by semicontinuity, will not be contained in any cubic surface. $\square$

share|cite|improve this answer
For a more general solution to this sort of problem (that does not rely on a computer), see Hirschowitz, "Sur la postulation generique des courbes rationelles." – Charles Staats May 26 '13 at 21:39
Note that a general curve of degree $7$ and genus $g$ is not contained in a cubic, for $0\le g\le 2$ but is contained in a cubic if $g\ge 3$ (and even on a quadric if $g\ge 6$). See for example – Jérémy Blanc May 26 '13 at 21:52
Thank you! but question is about any curve $C$, i.e. we fix a complex structure on a curve of genus $g$ and we are looking for minimal degree map of such a curve to $\mathbb C^3$. (sure, it is not known does there exist such a map) – Nikita Kalinin May 27 '13 at 18:32
Here is some partial answer: Lemma 2.3 in : Let $C$ be a smooth curve of genus $g$ and degree $d$ in $\mathbb{P}^3$. If $(2g-2)/3 < d < (19+g)/3$ then $C$ is contained in a cubic surface. – Jérémy Blanc Jun 6 '13 at 15:34

Your Answer


By posting your answer, you agree to the privacy policy and terms of service.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.