Take the 2-minute tour ×
MathOverflow is a question and answer site for professional mathematicians. It's 100% free, no registration required.

Let $F$ be an infinite field and $f$ a homogeneous form on $F$ such that $f$ has no non-trivial zero in $F$. Let $F'$ be a finite extension of $F$ such that $f$ has a non-trivial zero in $F'$. Is it true there exists a simple extension of $F$ of the form $F(\alpha)$ contained in $F'$ which contains a non-trivial zero of $f$?

share|improve this question
Isn't every finite separable extension $F'$ of $F$ of the form $F'=F(\alpha)$ for some $\alpha\in F'$ ? –  Chandan Singh Dalawat Mar 31 '13 at 6:15
@Dalawat: Ofcourse but in our case $F'$ is not necessarily separable. –  Jana Mar 31 '13 at 7:01
$x^p+sy^p+tz^p \in \mathbb{F}_p(s,t)[x,y,z]$? –  M P Mar 31 '13 at 11:05
@MP: if I've understood correctly then adjoining a $p$th root $\tau$ of $-t$ would be enough to give you the point $[\tau:0:1]$ so this doesn't look like a counterexample to me unless I've misunderstood what you're suggesting. –  user30035 Mar 31 '13 at 15:03
@wccanard: you have interpreted my comment correctly, and I was wrong! –  M P Mar 31 '13 at 16:52

1 Answer 1

up vote 5 down vote accepted

I believe the following is a negative example: Let $s,t,u,v$ be variables over $\mathbb F_p$. Set $F=\mathbb F_p(s,t,u,v)$ and $F'=F(\sigma,\tau)$ with $\sigma^p=s$, $\tau^p=t$.

Set $$f(X,Y,Z)=(X^p-sZ^p)u+(Y^p-tZ^p)v.$$

Then $f(\sigma,\tau,1)=0$.

We show that any solution of $f=0$ over $F'$ has this form up to a scalar factor: Let $x,y,z\in F'$ with $f(x,y,z)=0$. As $F'=\mathbb F_p(u,v,\sigma,\tau)$, we get $$x^p-sz^p, y^p-tz^p\in\mathbb F_p(u^p,v^p,\sigma^p,\tau^p)=\mathbb F_p(u^p,v^p,s,t),$$ hence $$A(u^p,v^p,s,t)u+B(u^p,v^p,s,t)v=0$$ for rational functions $A,B$ over $\mathbb F_p$ with $x^p-sz^p=A(u^p,v^p,s,t)$ and $y^p-tz^p=B(u^p,v^p,s,t)$.

This implies $A(u^p,v^p,s,t)=0$, for otherwise $u$ were a rational function in $u^p$. For the same reason $B(u^p,v^p,s,t)=0$. We get $x^p-tz^p=0=y^p-tz^p$, and the claim follows.

share|improve this answer
May I ask how one sees that $x^p-sz^p$ equals $A(u^p, v^p,\sigma,\tau)$ for some $A$ over $\mathbf F_p$? –  Ariyan Javanpeykar Mar 31 '13 at 23:35
I extended the answer, hope it is clearer now. –  Peter Mueller Apr 1 '13 at 8:12
This is very nice, I must say! If I understand correctly, you show that for the polynomial $f$ we must add at least $two$ elements to $F$ to get a root of $f$ inside $F^\prime$. I think, but I might be wrong, that one can slightly alter your construction (by adding more variables, and writing down $F$, $f$ and $F^\prime$ analogous to your construction) to obtain examples where one must add at least $n$ (with $n$ fixed, but arbitrarily large) variables to $F$ to obtain a root of $f$ within $F^\prime$. –  Ariyan Javanpeykar Apr 1 '13 at 17:21

Your Answer


By posting your answer, you agree to the privacy policy and terms of service.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.