User jonathan - MathOverflowmost recent 30 from http://mathoverflow.net2013-05-24T21:56:31Zhttp://mathoverflow.net/feeds/user/22668http://www.creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc/2.5/rdfhttp://mathoverflow.net/questions/38098/geometrization-for-3-manifolds-that-contain-two-sided-projective-planes/93185#93185Answer by jonathan for Geometrization for 3-manifolds that contain two-sided projective planes jonathan2012-04-05T03:38:22Z2012-04-05T03:38:22Z<p>If $N$ is a non-orientable closed 3-manifold then $H_3(N;Q)=0$.
Since $\chi(N)=0$ the first rational Betti number must be strictly positive.
Therefore there is an essential map $f:N\to{S^1}$,
and so $N$ contains an essential 2-sided surface.
Haken-ness then follows easily.</p>
http://mathoverflow.net/questions/71543/embedding-the-product-of-three-circles-in-the-4-sphere/93056#93056Answer by jonathan for Embedding the product of three circles in the 4-sphere. jonathan2012-04-04T00:42:48Z2012-04-04T00:42:48Z<p>No embedding of a product $M=T_g\times{S^1}$ in $S^4$ can have one complementary component
$X$ with $H_1(X)=0$.
For otherwise, the other component $Y$ would have $H_2(Y)=0$.
But then the inclusions of $M$ and of a wedge of $2g+1$ circles into $Y$ would induce
isomorphisms on the lower central series quotients of the fundamental groups,
by an old theorem of Stallings.
This cannot be so, as $\pi_1(M)$ has a central factor,
whereas the free group $F(2g+1)$ does not.</p>
http://mathoverflow.net/questions/18661/pd3-groups-and-pd4-complexes/93052#93052Answer by jonathan for PD3 groups and PD4 complexesjonathan2012-04-03T23:48:42Z2012-04-03T23:48:42Z<p>Suppose that $M$ is a closed 4-manifold (or $PD_4$-complex)
with fundamental group a $PD_3$-group $G$.
Then $M$ cannot be aspherical.
Since the homology of the universal cover $\widetilde{M}$ is 0 in degree 1
(it is simply-connected),'
in degree 3 (since $H^1(G;\mathbb{Z}[G])=0$, i.e., $G$ has one end)
and in degrees greater than 3 (since $G$ is infinite),
$\pi_2(M)=H_2(\widetilde{M};\mathbb{Z})$ must be non-zero.</p>