Short Course Suggestions For High School Students - MathOverflow most recent 30 from http://mathoverflow.net 2013-05-24T11:59:43Z http://mathoverflow.net/feeds/question/84032 http://www.creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc/2.5/rdf http://mathoverflow.net/questions/84032/short-course-suggestions-for-high-school-students Short Course Suggestions For High School Students Sonat Suer 2011-12-21T19:34:57Z 2012-01-01T05:48:22Z <p>I am planning to teach a course for talented high school students at a summer camp and I need suggestions for possible topics. The students usually have different backgrounds but most of them are familiar with single variable calculus and very basic linear algebra over the reals. The teaching format will be two hours per day, six days per week and two weeks in total. Suggestions for one week courses are also welcome.</p> <p>There are two things I want about this course. First, it should have a direction and a final goal. So it shouldn't be based on isolated Olympiad-type problems. Second, it should introduce at least one new concept or object which is not a part of the high school curriculum.</p> <p>For instance, classification of frieze patterns is a good topic. There is a clear goal and one needs to introduce the concept of a group which is new for high school students. Any other suggestions?</p> http://mathoverflow.net/questions/84032/short-course-suggestions-for-high-school-students/84036#84036 Answer by Joseph O'Rourke for Short Course Suggestions For High School Students Joseph O'Rourke 2011-12-21T19:54:05Z 2011-12-21T19:54:05Z <p>If I may forgiven for self-promotion, you might examine <em><a href="http://www.cambridge.org/us/knowledge/isbn/item6015150/How%20to%20Fold%20It/?site_locale=en_US" rel="nofollow">How To Fold It: The Mathematics of Linkages, Origami, and Polyhedra</a></em> (Cambridge University Press, 2011). All of its topics are accessible to high-school students, but all fall outside the high-school curriculum. See also <a href="http://howtofoldit.org/" rel="nofollow"><code>howtofoldit.org</code></a> for some (not yet well-organized) supplementary material.</p> http://mathoverflow.net/questions/84032/short-course-suggestions-for-high-school-students/84037#84037 Answer by Igor Rivin for Short Course Suggestions For High School Students Igor Rivin 2011-12-21T19:54:37Z 2011-12-21T19:54:37Z <p>When I was at that stage, I really enjoyed some introductory lectures in set theory a la Cantor in two weeks you can probably get to Schroeder-Bernstein or thereabouts...</p> http://mathoverflow.net/questions/84032/short-course-suggestions-for-high-school-students/84038#84038 Answer by Gerhard Paseman for Short Course Suggestions For High School Students Gerhard Paseman 2011-12-21T20:12:33Z 2011-12-21T20:12:33Z <p>I believe (and I may have some of the details wrong) Mark Sapir had at one time a curriculum for fourth graders that involved combinatorics on infinite words. I do not know if he still has it, or how adaptable it is, but it introduced the Thue-Morse sequence and (I believe) had some applications, such as (non-FIDE) unending chess, analysis of certain dynamical systems, and so on. Since I may be mistaken as to the details and availability, I suggest asking Mark Sapir or rolling your own.</p> <p>Gerhard "Ask Me About System Design" Paseman, 2011.12.21</p> http://mathoverflow.net/questions/84032/short-course-suggestions-for-high-school-students/84039#84039 Answer by Lovre for Short Course Suggestions For High School Students Lovre 2011-12-21T20:13:06Z 2011-12-21T20:18:51Z <p>My first suggestion would be a course on <strong>set theory</strong>. Starting with naive set theory, you examine the diagonal argument, paradoxes, and early developments. Then you use that to motivate axiomatic set theory (perhaps ZF), derive Peano Postulates, prove Cantor-Schroeder-Bernstein, survey cardinal arithmetic.</p> <p>If they've seen computational side of calculus, another idea could be to do <strong>introductory analysis</strong> course. Assuming little but rational numbers, you could construct real numbers, show their uncountability; then do the calculus they were taught, proving everything on your way.</p> <p>Other suggestion with which, I feel, one cannot go wrong, is <strong>elementary number theory</strong>. I would stress the prime number theory, proving Bertrand's Postulate and stating prime number theorem.</p> <p>Full disclosure: I'm currently a high school student.</p> http://mathoverflow.net/questions/84032/short-course-suggestions-for-high-school-students/84040#84040 Answer by Yemon Choi for Short Course Suggestions For High School Students Yemon Choi 2011-12-21T20:14:40Z 2011-12-21T20:14:40Z <p>2 by 2 Markov chains? (Don't formally define eigenvectors etc at start; just introduce the idea of the matrix as an update rule for some kind of "dynamical system", get them to do some calculations and make some guesses, then do some ad hoc proof of convergence to equilibrium in non-degenerate case.)</p> http://mathoverflow.net/questions/84032/short-course-suggestions-for-high-school-students/84044#84044 Answer by rschwieb for Short Course Suggestions For High School Students rschwieb 2011-12-21T21:41:22Z 2011-12-21T21:41:22Z <p>Some elementary graph theory with the intent of solving traversal or traveling salesman type problems is pretty easy at that level. Introducing incidence matrices can also be a foothold for learning matrix multiplication.</p> http://mathoverflow.net/questions/84032/short-course-suggestions-for-high-school-students/84046#84046 Answer by Predrag Punosevac for Short Course Suggestions For High School Students Predrag Punosevac 2011-12-21T21:58:19Z 2011-12-21T21:58:19Z <p>You have not told us where the students are coming from but it is pretty safe to say that these days no high school students (with exception of few countries on the world) are exposed to any meaningful Geometry course. </p> <p>How about teaching them some real old fashion synthetic (Euclidean/Lobachevsky) geometry course based let say on Kiselev's classic</p> <p><a href="http://www.amazon.com/Kiselevs-Geometry-Book-I-Planimetry/dp/0977985202" rel="nofollow">http://www.amazon.com/Kiselevs-Geometry-Book-I-Planimetry/dp/0977985202</a></p> <p>with possible excursion into Projective geometry.</p> <p>There is no more natural place to introduce the concept of groups (actions on the sets) than in Geometry (composition of isometric transformations). There is no more natural place to introduce them to the concept of measure. It is very easy to involve hard combinatorial problems and many other things. Finally, set theory is all over the geometry and axiomatic method rules.</p> <p>Many of the most challenging "Olympic problems" are geometric in its nature.</p> <p>Best,</p> <p>Predrag</p> http://mathoverflow.net/questions/84032/short-course-suggestions-for-high-school-students/84052#84052 Answer by Sean Tilson for Short Course Suggestions For High School Students Sean Tilson 2011-12-21T22:41:40Z 2011-12-21T22:41:40Z <p>I realized recently that you can do something really cool with good students after they learn the standard forms for conic sections: you can compute the compactifications of their moduli spaces. I gave an undergraduate talk based on this, and I think it went really well. You have to wave your hands a bit and you might not want to use the word compactification. It is pretty obvious how to draw the uncompactified spaces of conic sections centered at the origins, but something really cool happens when you approach the boundary. I think this could be stretched out a bit longer than an hour and you could probably do several nice lectures on it, one for each different moduli space.</p> <p>Let me know if you come up with any new low level examples for the moduli spaces. Mine were: -Triangles in the plane, -circles centered at the origin, -circles in the plane, -ellipses centered at the origin, -hyperbolas centered at the origin.</p> <p>You could also look at how the discriminant is a function on the moduli space.</p> http://mathoverflow.net/questions/84032/short-course-suggestions-for-high-school-students/84064#84064 Answer by Boris Novikov for Short Course Suggestions For High School Students Boris Novikov 2011-12-22T00:59:59Z 2011-12-22T00:59:59Z <p>In similar situation I gave courses:</p> <p>Groups and combinatorics (Polya theorem}</p> <p>Semigroups and automata</p> http://mathoverflow.net/questions/84032/short-course-suggestions-for-high-school-students/84065#84065 Answer by Zack Wolske for Short Course Suggestions For High School Students Zack Wolske 2011-12-22T01:22:28Z 2011-12-22T01:22:28Z <p>Serge Lang's book "Math Talks for Undergraduates" (Springer, 1999) has quite a few topics which will work for anyone with some calculus. Topics include symmetric polynomials, approximation theorems in analysis, prime numbers, and the abc conjecture.</p> http://mathoverflow.net/questions/84032/short-course-suggestions-for-high-school-students/84066#84066 Answer by Phil Isett for Short Course Suggestions For High School Students Phil Isett 2011-12-22T01:40:52Z 2011-12-22T01:40:52Z <p>If you can teach game theory, that could be good. It's bread and butter for mathematical economics and political science (even ecologists learn it now) -- I think the subject illustrates the point that math is not limited in application to situations which involve numbers. In addition to being useful, it's very elementary to solve games (although the fundamental fact that mixed strategy Nash equilibria exist requires topology to prove, it doesn't provide an algorithm for finding them -- actually solving games is more combinatorial). Proving that sets of strategies are/are not Nash equilibria can introduce students to the concept of a formal mathematical proof in a setting which I think is straightforward. </p> <p>Unfortunately, I can't think of a textbook that would be good, but maybe someone else knows one.</p> http://mathoverflow.net/questions/84032/short-course-suggestions-for-high-school-students/84067#84067 Answer by darij grinberg for Short Course Suggestions For High School Students darij grinberg 2011-12-22T02:15:17Z 2011-12-22T15:43:52Z <p><a href="http://arxiv.org/abs/0801.3306" rel="nofollow">Chip-firing, rotor-routing and cycle-popping</a> can be understood by anyone with or without combinatorial background, and provide new insights on lots of old combinatorial problems (counting Eulerian cycles and spanning trees, for instance). <a href="http://www.artofproblemsolving.com/Forum/viewtopic.php?f=42&amp;t=220599" rel="nofollow">Here</a> are some more basic facts, and <a href="http://www.math.cornell.edu/~levine/local-global.pdf" rel="nofollow">here</a> are some newer results. While the papers linked are probably too concise and too scholarly to be understood by students directly, it shouldn't be that difficult to make the results accessible for school students by writing them down in a more expository manner. (Needless to say, this would actually add a lot of value.) There are some notions from algebra used (group, group action, monoid, determinant), but (except for some linear algebra, which also can be avoided if so desired) mostly just the language is being used, not any nontrivial theorems.</p> <p>Gröbner bases and elimination theory are another good field, but I don't have a good elementary reference for this. The question how to solve a system of polynomial equations in general is a natural one and a good student <em>should</em> have asked himself this question at least once. Unfortunately the answer is never given even in university lectures. Algebraic geometry is not an answer.</p> <p>Now that we are talking about solving equations, I remember Vladimir Arnold having written a school-level (well, something he considered school level, referring to Russian schools) treatment of a topological proof (or an almost-proof, up to some intuitively obvious technicalities that should be cleared up in an analysis course) of the unsolvability of the generic quintic in radicals. Unfortunately I remember neither the proof nor the source, and it might be just my imagination...</p> <p><strong>EDIT:</strong> <a href="http://www.amazon.com/Abels-Theorem-Problems-Solutions-International/dp/1402021860" rel="nofollow">Here</a> is the text (not by Arnold, but based on Arnold's lectures). It is much longer than what I had in my memory, although the price tag of over $100 is questionable... You can get the <a href="http://ilib.mccme.ru/pdf/alekseev.pdf" rel="nofollow">Russian original</a> for free, but then again with some rudimentary Russian you can just as well get the translated book in djvu...</p> <p><em>PS.</em> I got from chip-firing to Gröbner bases through a curious and tremendously useful mathematical fact, the Newman lemma (often also called diamond lemma by algebraists, whereas computer scientists use "diamond lemma" for a much easier version of this fact), which is (sometimes) used in proving the basic facts of both of these fields. While it can be avoided in both chip-firing and Gröbner bases, I think it should at least be mentioned (the <a href="http://www.phil.uu.nl/~oostrom/publication/pdf/newmansproof.pdf" rel="nofollow">proof</a> is a wonderful exercise on algorithmic thinking) for the sake of general education.</p> http://mathoverflow.net/questions/84032/short-course-suggestions-for-high-school-students/84101#84101 Answer by Anna Varvak for Short Course Suggestions For High School Students Anna Varvak 2011-12-22T17:04:24Z 2011-12-22T17:04:24Z <p>It really depends on what is the objective of the summer camp, and what kind of students are recruited. Are the students selected based on their competency in mathematics, and the goal is to convince them to pursue mathematics in college? In that case, it doesn't help to have a course of more of the same, like a course in geometry, conic sections, or even set theory, as has been suggested. That would only reinforce the view in these students' minds that all the great math has already been done centuries ago.</p> <p>I see a lot of great suggestions here already, and I would add a recommendation of exploring the <a href="http://math.serenevy.net/?page=Origami-WhereMath" rel="nofollow">mathematics of origami</a>. There have been many recent discoveries in that field. The obvious advantage is that it deals with the obviously beautiful.</p> http://mathoverflow.net/questions/84032/short-course-suggestions-for-high-school-students/84125#84125 Answer by Qiaochu Yuan for Short Course Suggestions For High School Students Qiaochu Yuan 2011-12-22T22:15:04Z 2011-12-22T22:15:04Z <p>I think a course about homogeneous linear recurrence relations with constant coefficients should be manageable. The simplest nontrivial example is probably the Fibonacci recurrence $$F_{n+2} = F_{n+1} + F_n.$$</p> <p>A large supply of nontrivial accessible examples is given by counting walks on graphs or, roughly equivalently, words in regular languages (e.g. the language of all words not containing a particular word$w$). When the characteristic polynomial has distinct roots, the solutions are given by powers of the roots, and this is a very nice example of how using a non-obvious basis for a vector space (the vector space of all solutions) can clarify a situation, and also a fairly concrete example of how complex numbers can naturally occur in answers to real questions (if the characteristic polynomial has complex roots). </p> <p>The general case is somewhat difficult to explain directly, but can be described using any of the following approaches, roughly in increasing order of abstraction:</p> <ul> <li>partial fraction decomposition of a generating function,</li> <li>factorization of a polynomial in the shift operator$S(f_n) = f_{n+1}$,</li> <li>Jordan normal form of a companion matrix. </li> </ul> <p>The second approach allows the clearest analogy to the case of homogeneous linear ODEs with constant coefficients if the students are familiar with those.</p> <p>Of course to cut down on the abstraction it's probably best to focus on examples, and I think the students will be pleasantly surprised at how many difficult-looking combinatorial questions reduce to the counting of words in regular languages, which turns out to be relatively easy. </p> <p>There is also a cute connection to Pisot numbers, e.g. it is not obvious why the powers of$2 + \sqrt{3}$should rapidly approach integers until you realize that $$(2 + \sqrt{3})^n + (2 - \sqrt{3})^n$$</p> <p>is a sequence of integers satisfying a linear recurrence with integer coefficients and that$|2 - \sqrt{3}| &lt; 1$; moreover, this sequence counts the number of closed walks of length$n$on the multigraph with adjacency matrix$\left[ \begin{array}{cc} 2 &amp; 1 \\ 3 &amp; 2 \end{array} \right]$so has a direct combinatorial interpretation as well.</p> <p>The closest thing I know to a complete reference for this material is Chapter 4 of Stanley's <a href="http://www-math.mit.edu/~rstan/ec/" rel="nofollow">Enumerative Combinatorics Vol. I</a>; section A.I.4 of Flajolet and Sedgewick's <a href="http://algo.inria.fr/flajolet/Publications/books.html" rel="nofollow">Analytic Combinatorics</a> may also be useful. </p> http://mathoverflow.net/questions/84032/short-course-suggestions-for-high-school-students/84128#84128 Answer by Marcin Kotowski for Short Course Suggestions For High School Students Marcin Kotowski 2011-12-22T23:31:26Z 2011-12-22T23:31:26Z <p>I have successfully taught a course for gifted high school students (somewhat shorter than yours, about 9 hours) devoted to the probabilistic method (based, naturally, on Alon and Spencer + some other material). I managed to cover the basics, second moment method, some random graphs, games and derandomization. With a little more time I would have squeezed in the Lovasz Local Lemma. </p> <p>There was a lot of problem solving, but I was also able to show them some more advanced techniques. In general, combinatorics seems to be a good context to introduce some nontrivial probabilistic tools (say, Chernoff-type bounds). </p> <p>Another probability-based course in the similar format was "random walks and electrical networks". Very nice topic, quite elementary^1, lots of physical intuition - and at the same time, points at the more advanced math beneath (Markov chains, spectral graph theory)</p> <p>1 - until the kids ask you "wait, how is this probability on the set of infinite trajectories defined? ;) Luckily, I managed to avoid invoking the Kolmogorov extension theorem.</p> http://mathoverflow.net/questions/84032/short-course-suggestions-for-high-school-students/84133#84133 Answer by fedja for Short Course Suggestions For High School Students fedja 2011-12-23T01:46:00Z 2011-12-23T01:46:00Z <p>Combinatorial Nullstellenzatz is a great topic. You can combine it with Dwir's ideas and some other stuff where the key idea is to construct an impossible polynomial though there is no mention of any polynomial in the original problem setup. Let me know if you want more details (I've got to run now) :).</p> http://mathoverflow.net/questions/84032/short-course-suggestions-for-high-school-students/84341#84341 Answer by Anton Petrunin for Short Course Suggestions For High School Students Anton Petrunin 2011-12-26T23:09:27Z 2012-01-01T05:48:22Z <p>You can do Monsky's theorem, that a square cannot be divided into an odd number of equal area triangles. On the way you will have to do</p> <ol> <li>p-adic numbers, </li> <li>Sperner's lemma,</li> <li>present$\mathbb{R}$as a vector space over$\mathbb{Q}\$.</li> </ol> <p>In case if you have more time, you could </p> <ul> <li>use Sperner's lemma to prove Brouwer's fixed point theorem.</li> <li>use (3) to do Dehn Invariants </li> <li>and I am sure you can find what to do with p-adic numbers</li> </ul>