References/literature for pushouts in category of commutative monoids? [ed. - amalgams] - MathOverflow most recent 30 from http://mathoverflow.net 2013-05-24T19:05:22Z http://mathoverflow.net/feeds/question/6442 http://www.creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc/2.5/rdf http://mathoverflow.net/questions/6442/references-literature-for-pushouts-in-category-of-commutative-monoids-ed-ama References/literature for pushouts in category of commutative monoids? [ed. - amalgams] Yemon Choi 2009-11-22T08:19:18Z 2009-12-01T21:54:31Z <p>This is more of a request for pointers to <em>relevant</em> literature than a question per se. I am, erm, looking at a paper which uses a kind of iterated pushout construction to obtain a commutative monoid with certain desired properties. The particular "gluing" construction the authors want to do is handled by quite direct means, and while that's probably fine for this particular problem, it would be nice to put it in the proper context.</p> <p>My copy of Howie's "Introduction to Semigroup Theory" discusses the general notion of "semigroup amalgams" but doesn't seem to say anything about the pushouts in the smaller category of commutative monoids. The closest I can find via MathSciNet is a 1968 paper of Howie, which seems to be working in the category of commutative semigroups, but I can't get hold of a copy at the moment.</p> <p>Anyway: I'm hoping that someone reading might know of a sensible place to look for a summary of some general results. (The issue is whether the constituent pieces "embed" into the pushout, not the mere existence of the pushout.)</p> <p><b>EDIT:</b> On further reflection, while pushouts are undoubtedly relevant, for the purposes of the paper I'm looking at, faithfulness of the embedding is more important than the universal property of pushouts. So I'm changing the title of the question to reflect this. I also think that while the suggestions below have been useful in a broad sense they don't quite address the case I need - which could just be an illustration that said case falls between the two extremes most commonly looked at by semigroup theorists.</p> http://mathoverflow.net/questions/6442/references-literature-for-pushouts-in-category-of-commutative-monoids-ed-ama/6772#6772 Answer by Reid Barton for References/literature for pushouts in category of commutative monoids? [ed. - amalgams] Reid Barton 2009-11-25T06:51:43Z 2009-11-25T06:51:43Z <p>I'm not sure exactly what you're looking for, but here is a somewhat weird example of a pushout in commutative monoids I recently came across:</p> <p>$\begin{matrix} \mathbb{N}&amp;\to&amp;\mathbb{Z}\\ \downarrow&amp;&amp;\downarrow\\ 0&amp;\to&amp;0 \end{matrix}$</p> <p>This can't happen in abelian groups (more precisely a pushout square with 0 in the lower left whose top arrow is a monomorphism is also a pullback square).</p> http://mathoverflow.net/questions/6442/references-literature-for-pushouts-in-category-of-commutative-monoids-ed-ama/6795#6795 Answer by Tom Leinster for References/literature for pushouts in category of commutative monoids? [ed. - amalgams] Tom Leinster 2009-11-25T12:32:08Z 2009-11-25T12:32:08Z <p>I don't know a reference, but in case you never find one, here's a possible strategy for figuring it out yourself. </p> <p>Let $F$ be the functor from commutative monoids to abelian groups that adjoins formal inverses to every element. Then $F$ is left adjoint to the forgetful functor $U$, so preserves colimits and in particular pushouts. I believe it's the case that for a commutative monoid $M$, the canonical map $M \to UF(M)$ is injective iff $M$ is cancellable, i.e. $m + n = m' + n$ implies $m = m'$ (for $m, m', n \in M$). This might allow you to transfer known results about pushouts of abelian groups over to the category of commutative monoids. </p> http://mathoverflow.net/questions/6442/references-literature-for-pushouts-in-category-of-commutative-monoids-ed-ama/6863#6863 Answer by S. Carnahan for References/literature for pushouts in category of commutative monoids? [ed. - amalgams] S. Carnahan 2009-11-26T01:41:55Z 2009-11-29T00:33:07Z <p>Arthur Ogus wrote a book on logarithmic geometry, apparently soon to be published, and there is a <a href="http://math.berkeley.edu/~ogus/preprints/log%5Fbook/" rel="nofollow">preprint version</a> on his webpage. The first chapter is about commutative monoids, and in particular, it has a bit about pushouts (starting on page 12, and you can tell your computer to search for other instances of the word).</p> <p>General pushouts can be quite pathological, but you can say interesting things if the monoids satisfy some properties such as integrality. For example, if all of the monoids are integral and one of the monoids is a group, then the pushout is integral, and its group completion is the pushout of the group completions. This reduces Reid's example to a calculation with groups.</p> http://mathoverflow.net/questions/6442/references-literature-for-pushouts-in-category-of-commutative-monoids-ed-ama/7444#7444 Answer by Gonçalo Marques for References/literature for pushouts in category of commutative monoids? [ed. - amalgams] Gonçalo Marques 2009-12-01T15:12:38Z 2009-12-01T15:18:59Z <p>Have you looked at the book <a href="http://books.google.pt/books?id=4gPhmmW-EGcC&amp;dq=Monoids,+Acts+and+Categories+with+Applications+to+Wreath+Products+and+Graphs&amp;printsec=frontcover&amp;source=bl&amp;ots=1lTFC5WTuc&amp;sig=ZrU_auTCCfLSQZsxa4xfSvW534Y&amp;hl=pt-PT&amp;ei=ezAVS6LDO4uH4QbQqsTKBg&amp;sa=X&amp;oi=book_result&amp;ct=result&amp;resnum=4&amp;ved=0CBwQ6AEwAw#v=onepage&amp;q=&amp;f=false" rel="nofollow">Monoids, Acts and Categories</a> by Mati Kilp, Ulrich Knauer and Alexander V. Mikhalev? Pushouts are discussed in chapter II. </p>